One Dose/ Soroush

[M. Irfan Qureshi]

Dear Soroush
Thank for correcting me for Finrod and your name.
Secondly the reference: "Principles of Prescribing Collected from Clinical Experiences of Pioneers of Homoeopathy" by Dr. Kailash Narayan Mathur, published by B. Jain Publishers (P) Ltd, New Delhi-110055.
I second your opinion and thank you very much for trying to explain the point with an example of engine. Why should we not keep on turning the ignition switch after a little pause till engine starts, even in an old engine, wherein it is more needed than in a new engine? And what if the plug wire or battery cable is disconnected?? I think this example does not fully fit here.
Yes, we should base our faith on solid grounds and analyse the experience and history on the basis of facts and scientific grounds.
What is PND?
Thanking you, M.Irfan Qureshi.
Dear Irfan

Thank you for your response.

Firstly Finrod (faithful friend of man - Lord of the Rings) is my
company
name!

Secondly, please give me the references to Kent's practice.

It all depends on whether the case is chronic or acute.
If it is acute and desperate, you can repeat often provided you plus
the
remedy. In one of my best cases I gave the remedy Ant-t 200 C in water
and
plussed 10 times every time in 10-15 minute intervals.
Nothing happened after the first 2 doses. However, within 2 minutes of
the
third dose, the PND that was causing the painful cough stopped and the
patient went on to make a recovery.

However, chronic cases are completely different.
Kent also says that the best result he ever had was when he waited for
60
days for a reaction!

If I may give an example from a car. Let us assume that the engine has
been
flooded and won't start well. You turn the starter until it fires. At
first
the engine may run very badly but while doing so, do turn the starter?
No,
if you do you damage the engine. So you wait, either the engine will
eventually fire well, or will stop - in which case if former all is
well and
if the latter you start again (using auxiliary battery even).

All I need is logic - explain the logic properly with good evidence and
it
may become acceptable. But not just because X, Y or Z said so.
These guys were not infallible.

All experiences - even wrong ones are valuable - that is how we learn!
History repeats itself because we do not learn from experiences!

Rgds
Soroush
---------------------------------
Yahoo! Messenger - Communicate instantly..."Ping" your friends today! Download Messenger Now

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]