This is not Homeopathy? Only indicative info for reference.

[MM]

Comparison table
(May not be useful to rebels)
H? = my list; low is short and high is long-acting. (H=May be Hering [Confessions])
GM = R. Gibson-Miller, in Boericke's Materia Medica, duration in days.
B = Boenninghausen, found in A Systematic Alphabetic Repertory, duration in days

Remedy name Abbr. H? GM B
Aceticum acidum Acet-ac 14-20
Aconitum napellus Acon 1
Aesculus hippocastanum Aesc 30
Agaricus muscarius Agar 3 40 40
Agnus castus Agn 2 8-14
Alcohol - Aethanolum Aeth 20-30
Allium cepa All-c 1
Aloe socotrina Aloe 30-40
Alumen Alumn long
Alumina - Argilla Alum 5 40-60 40
Ambra grisea Ambr 3 40
Ammonium carbonicum Am-c 5 40 36
Ammonium muriaticum Am-m 3 20-30
Anacardium orientale Anac 3 30-40 30
Angustera vera Ang 3 20-30
Antimonium crudum Ant-c 8 40
Antimonium tartaricum Ant-t 3 20-30
Argentum metallicum Arg-m 3 30
Argentum nitricum Arg-n 30
Arnica montana Arn 2 6-10
Arsenicum album Ars 7 60-90 36
Arum triphyllum Arum-t 1-2
Asafoetida Asaf 3 20-40
Asarum europum Asar 2 8-14
Asclepias tuberosa Asc-t 40-60
Aurum metallicum Aur 6 50-60 42
Baptisia tinctoria Bapt 6-8
Baryta carbonica Bar-c 8 40 40-50
Belladonna Bell 3 1-7 35
Berberis aquifolium Berb 20-30
Bismuthum subnitricum Bism 5 20-50
Borax veneta Bor 3 30
Bovista Bov 3 7-14 50
Bromum Brom 3 20-30
Bryonia alba Bry 2 7-21
Cactus grandifloris Cact 7-10
Caladium seguinum Calad 2 30-40
Calcarea carbonica Calc 9 60 50
Calcarea phosphorica Calc-p 60
Camphora officinarum Camph 1 1
Cannabis indica Cann-i 2
Cannabis sativa Cann-s 2 1-10
Cantharis vesicatoria - Lytta Canth 2 30-40
Capsicum annuum Caps 2 7
Carbo animalis Carb-an 5 60 36
Carbo vegetabilis Carb-v 6 60 36
Causticum Hahnemanni Caust 8 50 50
Chamomilla vulgaris Cham 2 20-30
Chelidonium majus Chel 2 7-14
Cicuta virosa Cic 3 35-40
Cimicifuga racemosa Cimic 8-12
Cina - Artemsia maritima Cina 2 14-20
Cinchona officinalis - China Chin 2 14-21
Clematis erecta Clem 3 14-20 35
Cobaltum nitricum Cob 30
Cocculus indicus Cocc 2 30
Coffea cruda-arabica Coff 1 1-7
Colchicum autumnale Colch 3 14-20
Collinsonia canadensis Coll 30
Colocynthis Coloc 4 1-7 30-40
Conium maculatum Con 4 30-50 30-35
Crocus sativus Croc 2 8
Crotalus horridus Crot-h 30
Croton tiglium Crot-t 30
Cuprum metallicum Cupr 3 40-50
Cyclamen europaeum Cycl 2 14-20
Digitalis purpurea Dig 4 40-50 42
Dioscorea villosa Dios 1-7
Drosera rotundifolia Dros 2 20-30
Dulcamara Dulc 4 30 30-40
Eupatorium perfoliatum Eup-per 1-7
Euphorbium officinarum Euph 3 50 49
Euphrasia officinalis Euphr 2 7
Ferrum metallicum Ferr 5 50
Fluoricum acidum Fl-ac 6 30 or 1-7
Gelsemium sempervirens Gels 30
Glonoinum Glon 1
Graphites Graph 8 40-50 40-50
Guaiacum officinale Guaj 3 40 35
Helleborus niger Hell 3 20-30
Hepar sulphuris calcareum Hep 8 40-50 56
Hyoscyamus niger Hyos 2 6-14
Hypericum perforatum Hyper 1-7
Ignatia amara Ign 2 9
Iodum Iod 4 30-40 42
Ipecacuanha Ip 1 7-10
Kali bichromicum Kali-bi 30
Kali carbonicum Kali-c 8 40-50 42
Kali iodatum Kali-i 20-30
Kali nitricum Kali-n 5 30-40 42
Kali sulphuricum Kali-s 45 written in
Kalmia latifolia Kalm 7-14
Kreosotum Kreos 2 15-20
Lachesis muta Lach 3 30-40
Laurocerasus Laur 1 4-8
Ledum palustre Led 3 30
Lilium tigrinum Lil-t 14-20
Lycopodium clavatum Lyc 7 40-50 40-50
Magnesia carbonica Mag-c 5 40-50 40-50
Magnesia muriatica Mag-m 4 40-50 40-50
Magnesia sulphurica Mag-s 2
Magnetis polus arcticus Mag-arct 2
Magnetis polus australis Mag-aust 2
Mancinella Manc 30-40
Manganum aceticum Mang 5 40 40
Marum verum teucrium 2
Menyanthes trifoliatia Meny 2 14-20
Mephitis putorius Meph 1
Mercurius vivus Merc 3 30-60 14-21
Mezereum Mez 3 30-60 45-50
Millefolium Mil 1-3
Moschus moschiferus Mosch 1 1
Muriaticum acidum Mur-ac 3 35 35
Natrum carbonicum Nat-c 6 30 30-40
Natrum muriaticum Nat-m 4 40-50 40-50
Nitricum acidum Nit-ac 4 40-60 40
Ntr-sul ? 30-40
Nux moschata Nux-m 2 60
Nux vomica Nux-v 2 1-7
Oleander Olnd 3 20-30
Opium Op 1 7
Paris quadrifolia Par 1 2-4
Petroleum Petr 6 40-50 40-50
Phosphoricum acidum Ph-ac 4 40 40
Phosphorus Phos 8 40 40
Platina metallicum Plat 6 35-40 35-42
Plumbum metallicum Plb 3 20-30
Podophyllum peltatum Podo 30
Psorinum Psor 30-40
Pulsatilla nigricans Puls 2 40
Ranunculus bulbosus Ran-b 2 30-40
Ranunculus sceleratus Ran-s 3 30-40
Rheum officinale Rheum 1 2-3
Rhododendron chrysanthum Rhod 3 35-40 35-42
Rhus toxicodendron Rhus-t 3 1-7
Ruta graveolens Ruta 2 30
Sabadilla officinarum Sabad 2 20-30
Sabina juniperus Sabin 3 20-30
Sambucus nigra Samb 1 1
Sarsaparilla Sars 3 35 35
Secale cornutum Sec 2 20-30
Selenium Sel 5 40
Senega - Polygala senega Seneg 3 30 28
Sepia officinalis Sep 8 40-50 40-50
Silicea terra Sil 8 40-60 40-50
Spigelia anthelmia Spig 3 20-30
Spongia marina tosta Spong 3 20-30
Squilla maritima- Scilla Squil 2 14-20
Stannum metallicum Stann 5 35 35
Staphysagria Staph 3 20-30
Stramonium Stram 1
Strontium carbonicum Stront 5 40 40
Sulphur Sulph 9 40-60 40-50
Sulphuricum acidum Sul-ac 3 30-40 28
Taraxacum officinale Tarax 1 14-21
Tellurium Tell 30-40
Teucrium marum verum Teucr 14-21
Theridion curassavicum Ther 30
Thuja occidentalis Thuj 3 60 21
Valeriana officinalis Val 2 8-10
Veratrum album Verat 2 20-30
Verbascum thapsus Verb 2 8-10
Viola odorata Viol-o 2 >2-4
Viola tricolor Viol-t 2 8-14
Zincum metallicum Zinc 4 30-40 30-40

[Shannon Nelson]

Hi Hahnemannian,

I may have missed some posts, but what is this post in reference to?? Also the formatting may not have carried through, as the columns are indistinct. But, re the duration of action of remedies, by *anyone's* chart, I thought it was pretty well accepted that those are meaningless without context--or at any rate, I can't imagine how any such blanket description could be made--take any one remedy and potency, and compare how long you might expect it to act in a mild acute, vs. a severe acute, vs. mild or severe trauma, vs. functional chronic case vs. pathological chronic case, on pts of varying degrees of sensitity, with varying degrees of correspondence / homeopathicity--aren't those charts pretty meaningless, except for purposes of comparing "tends to be longer-acting" vs. "tends to be shorter-acting"??

Shannon
Remedy name Abbr. H? GM B
Aceticum acidum Acet-ac 14-20
Aconitum napellus Acon 1
Aesculus hippocastanum Aesc 30
Agaricus muscarius Agar 3 40 40
Agnus castus Agn 2 8-14
Alcohol - Aethanolum Aeth 20-30
Allium cepa All-c 1
Aloe socotrina Aloe 30-40
Alumen Alumn long
Alumina - Argilla Alum 5 40-60 40
Ambra grisea Ambr 3 40
Ammonium carbonicum Am-c 5 40 36
Ammonium muriaticum Am-m 3 20-30
Anacardium orientale Anac 3 30-40 30
Angustera vera Ang 3 20-30
Antimonium crudum Ant-c 8 40
Antimonium tartaricum Ant-t 3 20-30
Argentum metallicum Arg-m 3 30
Argentum nitricum Arg-n 30
Arnica montana Arn 2 6-10
Arsenicum album Ars 7 60-90 36
Arum triphyllum Arum-t 1-2
Asafoetida Asaf 3 20-40
Asarum europum Asar 2 8-14
Asclepias tuberosa Asc-t 40-60
Aurum metallicum Aur 6 50-60 42
Baptisia tinctoria Bapt 6-8
Baryta carbonica Bar-c 8 40 40-50
Belladonna Bell 3 1-7 35
Berberis aquifolium Berb 20-30
Bismuthum subnitricum Bism 5 20-50
Borax veneta Bor 3 30
Bovista Bov 3 7-14 50
Bromum Brom 3 20-30
Bryonia alba Bry 2 7-21
Cactus grandifloris Cact 7-10
Caladium seguinum Calad 2 30-40
Calcarea carbonica Calc 9 60 50
Calcarea phosphorica Calc-p 60
Camphora officinarum Camph 1 1
Cannabis indica Cann-i 2
Cannabis sativa Cann-s 2 1-10
Cantharis vesicatoria - Lytta Canth 2 30-40
Capsicum annuum Caps 2 7
Carbo animalis Carb-an 5 60 36
Carbo vegetabilis Carb-v 6 60 36
Causticum Hahnemanni Caust 8 50 50
Chamomilla vulgaris Cham 2 20-30
Chelidonium majus Chel 2 7-14
Cicuta virosa Cic 3 35-40
Cimicifuga racemosa Cimic 8-12
Cina - Artemsia maritima Cina 2 14-20
Cinchona officinalis - China Chin 2 14-21
Clematis erecta Clem 3 14-20 35
Cobaltum nitricum Cob 30
Cocculus indicus Cocc 2 30
Coffea cruda-arabica Coff 1 1-7
Colchicum autumnale Colch 3 14-20
Collinsonia canadensis Coll 30
Colocynthis Coloc 4 1-7 30-40
Conium maculatum Con 4 30-50 30-35
Crocus sativus Croc 2 8
Crotalus horridus Crot-h 30
Croton tiglium Crot-t 30
Cuprum metallicum Cupr 3 40-50
Cyclamen europaeum Cycl 2 14-20
Digitalis purpurea Dig 4 40-50 42
Dioscorea villosa Dios 1-7
Drosera rotundifolia Dros 2 20-30
Dulcamara Dulc 4 30 30-40
Eupatorium perfoliatum Eup-per 1-7
Euphorbium officinarum Euph 3 50 49
Euphrasia officinalis Euphr 2 7
Ferrum metallicum Ferr 5 50
Fluoricum acidum Fl-ac 6 30 or 1-7
Gelsemium sempervirens Gels 30
Glonoinum Glon 1
Graphites Graph 8 40-50 40-50
Guaiacum officinale Guaj 3 40 35
Helleborus niger Hell 3 20-30
Hepar sulphuris calcareum Hep 8 40-50 56
Hyoscyamus niger Hyos 2 6-14
Hypericum perforatum Hyper 1-7
Ignatia amara Ign 2 9
Iodum Iod 4 30-40 42
Ipecacuanha Ip 1 7-10
Kali bichromicum Kali-bi 30
Kali carbonicum Kali-c 8 40-50 42
Kali iodatum Kali-i 20-30
Kali nitricum Kali-n 5 30-40 42
Kali sulphuricum Kali-s 45 written in
Kalmia latifolia Kalm 7-14
Kreosotum Kreos 2 15-20
Lachesis muta Lach 3 30-40
Laurocerasus Laur 1 4-8
Ledum palustre Led 3 30
Lilium tigrinum Lil-t 14-20
Lycopodium clavatum Lyc 7 40-50 40-50
Magnesia carbonica Mag-c 5 40-50 40-50
Magnesia muriatica Mag-m 4 40-50 40-50
Magnesia sulphurica Mag-s 2
Magnetis polus arcticus Mag-arct 2
Magnetis polus australis Mag-aust 2
Mancinella Manc 30-40
Manganum aceticum Mang 5 40 40
Marum verum teucrium 2
Menyanthes trifoliatia Meny 2 14-20
Mephitis putorius Meph 1
Mercurius vivus Merc 3 30-60 14-21
Mezereum Mez 3 30-60 45-50
Millefolium Mil 1-3
Moschus moschiferus Mosch 1 1
Muriaticum acidum Mur-ac 3 35 35
Natrum carbonicum Nat-c 6 30 30-40
Natrum muriaticum Nat-m 4 40-50 40-50
Nitricum acidum Nit-ac 4 40-60 40
Ntr-sul ? 30-40
Nux moschata Nux-m 2 60
Nux vomica Nux-v 2 1-7
Oleander Olnd 3 20-30
Opium Op 1 7
Paris quadrifolia Par 1 2-4
Petroleum Petr 6 40-50 40-50
Phosphoricum acidum Ph-ac 4 40 40
Phosphorus Phos 8 40 40
Platina metallicum Plat 6 35-40 35-42
Plumbum metallicum Plb 3 20-30
Podophyllum peltatum Podo 30
Psorinum Psor 30-40
Pulsatilla nigricans Puls 2 40
Ranunculus bulbosus Ran-b 2 30-40
Ranunculus sceleratus Ran-s 3 30-40
Rheum officinale Rheum 1 2-3
Rhododendron chrysanthum Rhod 3 35-40 35-42
Rhus toxicodendron Rhus-t 3 1-7
Ruta graveolens Ruta 2 30
Sabadilla officinarum Sabad 2 20-30
Sabina juniperus Sabin 3 20-30
Sambucus nigra Samb 1 1
Sarsaparilla Sars 3 35 35
Secale cornutum Sec 2 20-30
Selenium Sel 5 40
Senega - Polygala senega Seneg 3 30 28
Sepia officinalis Sep 8 40-50 40-50
Silicea terra Sil 8 40-60 40-50
Spigelia anthelmia Spig 3 20-30
Spongia marina tosta Spong 3 20-30
Squilla maritima- Scilla Squil 2 14-20
Stannum metallicum Stann 5 35 35
Staphysagria Staph 3 20-30
Stramonium Stram 1
Strontium carbonicum Stront 5 40 40
Sulphur Sulph 9 40-60 40-50
Sulphuricum acidum Sul-ac 3 30-40 28
Taraxacum officinale Tarax 1 14-21
Tellurium Tell 30-40
Teucrium marum verum Teucr 14-21
Theridion curassavicum Ther 30
Thuja occidentalis Thuj 3 60 21
Valeriana officinalis Val 2 8-10
Veratrum album Verat 2 20-30
Verbascum thapsus Verb 2 8-10
Viola odorata Viol-o 2 >2-4
Viola tricolor Viol-t 2 8-14
Zincum metallicum Zinc 4 30-40 30-40

[muthu kumar]

sorry I did not post this - it is MM who posted this( not Materia medica
--- In minutus@yahoogroups.com, Shannon Nelson wrote:

[Shannon Nelson]

Sorry, overdriving my headlights...