Minutus

Which is why at the bottom of my last reply to nader I asked for a
list of miasms

regards
Simon King


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

It does also help to choose Rx where there is a question and is useful
especially for case management
but i have a suspicion you have already made your mind up on this,

Perhaps you could share your understanding of miasms?
regards
Simon King


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Dear Colleagues

This discussion is going nicely - Thank you and please continue.

To my good friend Nader -
You wrote: "I don't believe in such definitions as Psora is under-function
or sycosis is over-function and etc."

Please give the general symptoms of each of the miasms.
We can then check them against the above broad definitions.

Rgds
Soroush
Message: 1
Date: Sun, 14 Nov 2004 17:21:08 +0330
From: "Nader Moradi"
Subject: Re: Miasms - Remedy Selection

Dear Simon,

I don't believe in such definitions as Psora is under-function or sycosis is
over-function and etc.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Dear Joy,
I know this situation but in your previous mail you said:if the
older disease is stronger it will repel (I.e. diminish to the background to
a certain degree) the new disease. In this instance you would want to treat
the most dominant and/or dangerous but keep in mind the sx of the other..

when the strong older disease repels the new weaker one then how the symptoms of new weaker disease can be present!!!!!!!!!

Regarding complex disease you didn't say how you prescribe the remedy or may be I didn't understand well for your previous mail!!!!!!!!

Nader

No,it is not chicken.egg discussion,without miasm we can have viruses and microorganisms!!!!!!!!
It is like that to say without cholera we can not have vibrion cholera and etc!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
Miasm is infectious disease not infecting agent.

Kind Regards,
Nader

Dear Shannon,

Regarding to "miasm" I mean "Hahnemann's miasms concept".
Of course if I want to say my opinion about other authors such as Sankaran or others I can say that to some extent they wanted to relate their definition to Hahnemann theory otherwise it was better to name their theories other that "miasm" such as "piasm" or "siasm" etc.!!!!!!!!!
Then it is better before continuing our discussion on miasm every body tell his/her mean of "miasm"

Kind Regards,
Nader

Dear Shannon,

1-If you mean "Hahnemann miasm" then he has not said itch "mite" as a cause of psora.
2- Hahnemann has not said " miasm" as " susceptibility"!!!!!!!!!!!!
but if you mean "miasm" other than Hahnemann's one then I beg you pardon,pls do not answer to my mail.
Nader

Dear Shannon,

What is to be cured is miasms not other things else,of course after put aside other obstacles such as exciting &maintaining cause.In fact in true natural chronic diseases we do not treat anything except miasms.

Best,
Nader

we have chronic diseases which are not miasmatic diseases,pls refer to Organon.
Nader

The stronger disease can/will repel in degrees, sometimes entirely,
sometimes partly, according to the strength of both of the dissimilar
diseases - every individual will be different.

I prescribe the remedy as per the individual as well whether it be complex
disease, acute, serious physical pathology, emotional pathology, whatever
needs to be cured in any individual.

What do all the !!!!! mean?

Best, Joy

http://www.homeopathicmateriamedica.com
on 14/11/04 19:14, Nader Moradi at mn0021@issa2000.net wrote:

Dear Joy,
I know this situation but in your previous mail you said:if the
older disease is stronger it will repel (I.e. diminish to the background to
a certain degree) the new disease. In this instance you would want to treat
the most dominant and/or dangerous but keep in mind the sx of the other..

when the strong older disease repels the new weaker one then how the
symptoms of new weaker disease can be present!!!!!!!!!

Regarding complex disease you didn't say how you prescribe the remedy or may
be I didn't understand well for your previous mail!!!!!!!!

Nader
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]