[H] Arnica, if taken promptly, can realign a broken [foot] bone?

[Teresa Kramer]

My lay-homeopath friend, now living in Costa Rica, wrote me, a couple of days ago, “I am suffering from a fall on the road in which I think broke a bone which was put back by arnica. Immediately afterward, I made the mistake of walking on it for more than 2 hours. Now I have pain that does not respond more than a little to the best selected remedies. I am making slow progress.”
She is a very liberal user of H remedies--not exactly my take on it, but it seems to work really well for her. When I wrote to say maybe she needed a boot on the foot to immobilize the bone at least, she replied:
“You must have forgotten what Will Taylor taught us in Portland...if arnica is taken quickly enough it can realign bones. Anyway I am getting back to normal. Screwy things such as camomille, baryta carb and kali bich. are unexpectedly helpful.”
Thought I would pass on the idea, to the lurkers (my usual status) anyway. I didn’t happen to hear Will Taylor at the NCH conference in Portland. Wish I had! Teresa (Northern VA, USA)

[Shannon Nelson]

Yikes, re-aligning it is great, but *walking* on it????
It still should be immobilized until the bone has had a chance to
knit!!!
That's my vote...