[H] Scurvy & Pellegra (some things thought to beinfectiousfoundto vitamin deficiencies)]

[Tauseef Ahmad Khan]

I totally agree with Hahnemannian2002 here. Knowledge is not owned by
anybody - So we should use this opportunity to built upon the
discoveries of modern science and look upon them with the eye of a true
homeopath.

Look at it this way: If Hahnemann were alive today and like Sherri he
had denied the total existence of viruses or their role in diseases he
would have been booed even by homeopaths. He did not deny the existence
of small 'inimical' morbific agents in his time then why are some of us
doing it now!?

Regards,
Tauseef Khan
hahnemannian2002 wrote:

[muthu kumar]

Go ahead- The attempt of the post is to generate discussion

--- In minutus@yahoogroups.com, AH wrote:
with you.
However, this is
life - and
generations.
IS A
microbes,
miasmatic
microbes (cf
an
endogenous
Existence of
susceptibility by
which Zen
for
constitutional
on an
remedies in the
poisoning
patterns held on
and often
stature as the
disease; and
of it-
the
the human
biochemical
body
destruction of
cause of an
widespread
in degree
accounts
homeopathy.
should
the
prove
posted
categories (eg
effects of
process is
microbial
explanation for
are not
needed to
similar
stool".
can
can
the
cholera
and
in the
acutes was
with
given
force
notice.
war,
modern
worth?
disease
interaction of
is merely a
call "terrain".
empirical
results of
in the
disease in later
cause of
otherwise
colonization and
personality
by
in
Shahrdar, for
know the
case.
wholistic
nonphysical vital
an "etheric
passed by
(?);
fluids).
host genes,
can reverse
womb by
homeopathy.
Diseases) in
the cause of
importance
symptomologic toxins
and
cannot reverse
it can
species of
(application
keep the
the planet
almost
work, they are
nonphysical body
case, they
dividing open
possible
really is
of a
consumption is
on what is
vital
organism.
decomposers -- and at
elucidation of viral
What we
other forms
host as a
not produce
disease
mechanics of
is only
and other
leaves a
the host.
of the
through
theory as
LEAVE the
always
usually find
disease in
lineage
or
represents that
disease. This is
imbibed by a
available additional
some
virulence
defined the
reality
these
systems utilize
therapeutics
a precise
in JC
This occurs
a special
are the
There is a
physical body
operation
and motor
attention
program. By
purely
space, and
planetary bodies).
template,
previous
human or
of
coherent unit
subprogram
qualify as the
of
curriculum of the
attracts-
match of the
health
moment, but if
consciousness would
we can
most of the
foreign
regard
from its
shifts
chief
all
the vast
the chief
function.
coordinates
specialists into a
coherent
physical
invisible to the
are a
fields can
that are the
inimical
(overall
of phase
remedy. The
of the
well
is in one
to its
less than
to a bridge
homeopathic
wholism within
substances; or
thought forms
methods). TCM,
force.
which
state
foreign
shadows of
the
bodies.
could be
of the
operation] is Š one
microbial
infection Š
and other
torturing it Š
regular
now, the
to
principle in
energy
influence of
during the
[morbid
Health,
life
organism in
Paragraph 148
the
is indeed
principle
within the
certain
of these
automatic
of them
miasmatic
biological vital
PHYSICAL
of us look
them --
almost never
diseases like
their role
basis of what
=====================================================================
===
OR TRAUMA
in the
bodies of
Just as
(nonphysical
bodies can
Miasms, and
behave like
specie of
this
organs and
when stress
host's
pathology".
because they
pathogen
Livingston MD
and the
genome of
vital
whole
reproduce
host can be
and
but take
control of the
vital
cell
kind*. So the
of the
REPRODUCTION. The
with the
uncontrolled
multicellular
co-opt the
now
reasons -- are
most
have the
theory.
Ardavan
homeopaths are
Milgram:
the "religion" of
of new
is partly
of thinking
etched and
become
his life
Humans
is a
beings.
ideas because
who
crudely quote
avenue to
look at the
the "germ
valid
convincing
and "Polio"
iatrogenic etc)
microbes as
and egg
(TERRAIN)
disease as
unclean
negative
therapeutics.
another
looking
true forcing
prudent than
prophylaxis
legal
allopathic
field,
Emergency
surgery and
adjunct.
in its
so is the
(e.g. the
exposure to
or other
of the US
eradication.
whereas the
the treaty
a list to
so in a
later;
time;
producing
controlling
- as it
number of lives
disease
paralysis"
one that is
the disease
spreading
victims'
limbs are
paralysed, which
illness
worldwide between
names. The
was once
Vaccination
zones (DDT is
what is the
the "polio"
====================================================================
OF
disease
force) which
acute
Diseases).
fluids to
parasite
vital
causing
sixth ed.).
miasmatic
coexist
These
chronic
and
trauma. Life
radioactive
induction
(organic
be able to
source and
classification
wholism is
disease are to
only
disease
beyond the
germ is
microbes
and
biochemical
difficult
potential
and
generally not
effects of
categories.
THEORY".

[muthu kumar]

There are different ways you would advice to different infections-
In general patient care- the mode of transmission for example and
the period of incubation and infectivity all point to how you would
have the care-takers help the patient...

Even in homeopathy for example - if you know the cause is something
related to staphs or streps you would be able to give the relevant
nosode.

As I have been repeatedly asking - how would you tell the
progression of the disease? For viral eruptive fevers how would we
able to tell the general progresssion of the disease? How would you
generate a differential diagnosis?

I suggest that you take just the eruptive fevers category in any
standard text book of medicine and come up with an alternate way of
classifying them so that it is helpful for 1) Focused case taking 2)
diagnosis 2) treatment 3) predict the prognosis of what would happen
if it is not treated...

What we should be doing is not denying all these causes... we have
not shed any sweat doing this research and investigation
ourselves... instead it will be better for us to utilize all of this
so that our case management becomes better...

If you have not been able to make use of this information till now -
may be it is time to do so...and it can be improved still, the
publishing of the materia medica of viruses, bacteria etc. is a step
in the right direction.
--- In minutus@yahoogroups.com, Sheri Nakken
wrote:
owned by
a true
Sherri he
diseases he
existence
of us
bacteria or
-

[muthu kumar]

> Again, the symptom picture leads the way and the name of the group of
doesn't
there.

How do you have an incubation period without infection? What do you
incubate?
The incubation period is the amount of time between infection with a
virus or bacteria to the start of symptoms.

[Shannon Nelson]

On May 29, 2006, at 10:09 AM, Sheri Nakken wrote:
IMO prescribing issues aren't the driving factor in the discussion.
The driving factors are e.g. do "pathogen protection" measures matter?
There is a HUGE practical difference on that front!
Shannon

[muthu kumar]

Sheri-
Thanks for your persistence. I acknowledge that I have met a
superior wisdom and incisive intellect that dwarfs my arguments.
You have convinced me that all these infectious theories have been
the handiwork of vaccine manufacturers. You have convinced me so
much that I have started forming my own correct conclusions about
all therapies.

For example acupuncture is a bogus system kept alive by needle
manufacturers. Psychoanalysis exists only so that manufacturers of
recliners, sofas and couches can make a living. The Global Furniture
association has managed to manipulate the APA and other
organizations. All the alternative therapies are being funded by
subversive elements in each country to cause a social revolution
against established medicine and established governments. ( oops my
theory looks like self-accusing- well you cannot win them all)

Not bad for a new convert- uh?

Your statements have also freed my mind and health concerns.

I can get hurt, roll in horse refuse like nobody's business without
the least worry about tetanus.

I can get my food cheap because I can collect the expired food
stuff from super market garbages from the thrown away food cans - as
I do not have to worry about food poisoning. The expiry dates are
there just so people would buy the food again after throwing out
the expired ones ( food industry manipulates the fear about food
poisoning).

I can have rabid racoons and hydrophobic hounds for pets- rabis
virus does not exist; As long as I get Manganese and Calcium
supplements life will be hunky - dory for me...

I look at the promised land where mosquitoes and humans peacefully
coexist- mosquitoes not biting man but drinking soy protein drink
from saucers and even if they bite - they being chided fondly and
petted...and nobody ever getting malaria after that...

I can walk thru the woods of New Jersey teeming with ticks and
dancing deer without the least worried about Lyme's disease.

I look at a world where sanitary inspections do not exist and food
bearers serving food without washing their hands- too much washing
takes away the beauty of the hands- and where I can happily munch
the uncooked vegetables from an Indian market - amebiasis my foot-

I just cannot stop wondering at the marvelous world your vision has
opened up for me. Since my brain has been re-engineered so
thoroughly and the "terrain" has become so strong to resist any kind
of brain washing by vested interests from now on.

Long Live Paranoia - Death to Louis Pasteur and ML Tyler ( well they
are already dead but still)
-- In minutus@yahoogroups.com, Sheri Nakken
wrote:
group of
and the
are
you
with a
exposure to
just that.
-

[Joy Lucas]

This notion of incubation is a vague one at best as it is almost
impossible to 'see' for sure when it begins although in some
individuals, if you are observant, you can retrospectively name the
'beginning'. But all disease has some kind of incubation - from
causation to awareness, whatever that causation might be and will vary
enormously from one individual to another whether in acute conditions
or chronic.

For all we know all of us have some kind of incubation going on (again,
either for an acute condition or a chronic development) but it is our
susceptibilities, or lack of them, that will either open the door or
keep it shut.

So, in my opinion, the time between the so called incubation period and
the awareness of disease is merely! the vital force doing its work, or
trying to. Best wishes, Joy

http://www.homeopathicmateriamedica.com
http://www.homeopathicmateriamedica.blogspot.com
http://homepage.mac.com/joylucas/
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/provings

[Joy Lucas]

Oh for heaven's sake and for the sanity of most people on this list
going with this discussion, you have completely missed the point.

Regardless of whether or not there is a corruptive coercion going on in
the big wide world (and you'd have to have your eyes shut if you
thought there wasn't) the whole point being made is that getting up
front and personal with the bacteria, virus, germ, noxious substance,
i.e. naming them, is not an important part of our case analysis. Unless
you have extensive lab work done to assist you in naming a rogue
substance, which can be erroneous and circumspect at best and time
wasting at worst, it should not be part of your rubric selection, sx
ranking, or choice of rx. The most important decision in acutes is how
life threatening is this, what is the likely progress of the condition,
what organs are involved - THAT definitely has to be ranked, then you
take the sx and prescribe on them.

This is NOT to say that aetiology in disease is not important - it very
much is so and is intimately linked to the individual but it just
doesn't include naming a particular type of bacteria, virus, germ etc
that bears no real relation to the sx and the individual.

I would encourage people to read the little booklet edited by P
Sankaran "The Importance of Aetiology In Homepathy". Joy

http://www.homeopathicmateriamedica.com
http://www.homeopathicmateriamedica.blogspot.com
http://homepage.mac.com/joylucas/
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/provings
edited for the sake of decency otherwise I might have been rude and
then I'd have the minerals on my back

[Tauseef Ahmad Khan]

I will add a few of my newly found insights following my discussions
with Sheri, which very much like Hahnemannian2002 I lost, and that due
to her superior and most logical 'wisdom':

I can now have sex with all the HIV positive people anywhere anytime
without any fears. HIV virus does not exist at all so I should be safe -
now only if I could keep myself away from chlorinated swimming pools!

I can now also ask all the blood banks in my city to stop screening for
HIV, HBV, HCV etc. Its just waste of resources and we can save a lot of
money if I can just convince the local health authority. Maybe if I
forward them Sheri's mails they would be convinced as I have been!

I am also now free to tell the whole of Africa to forget mosquitoes and
malaria. It is DDT that is causing more than 300 million cases of
malaria leading to more than a million deaths in that continent. These
countries should use their money more wisely on food rather than buying
insecticide impregnated bednets. How far will this go in helping the
poor people of Africa! I just cannot imagine.

Thanks again Sheri for opening my eyes to the truth and giving me
freedom from germs!

Tauseef Khan

hahnemannian2002 wrote:

[muthu kumar]

I suggest reading "Koppikar's Clinical experiences of 70 years in
homeopathy" by S.P.Koppikar, who I think has a much better grasp of
homeopathy and its practice than most any one else.
--- In minutus@yahoogroups.com, Joy Lucas wrote:
list
on in
up
substance,
Unless
sx
how
condition,
you
very
etc
been
about
of
Furniture
by
oops my
without
and