Expert Opinion Requested.

[Khalid Saboor]

Expert Opinion Requested.
An interesting case for mental exercise. Inviting all
the members to comment, discuss or suggest remedy.

A case of chronic constipation with headache.

Age 38 years, married Father of three children, medium
height and built, healthy looking.

Past History:
For three years use to masturbate while living away
from home.
Headache started in 1990 when in UAE after a meal
containing flatulent food causing flatulent
distention, vomiting
Constipation since childhood. Use to eat clay and
charcoal when a child and the stool used to be of
black color. Have at least passed worms once. Stool
used to be knotty, small ball shaped, without urging
for days. Takes allopathic medicine on regular basis
for constipation.

Parent?s history:
Father dead had tuberculosis.
Mother still alive and well.

Present symptoms:
Headache comes on almost on weekly basis that is after
every seven days often appears a day earlier than a
week. Knows headache will be coming on such and such
day.
Headache begins after flatulency starting from nape of
neck extending forwards to the forehead and centering
on the left eyebrow.
Before headache:
Starts taking tablets to remove constipation
Heaviness of the abdomen
Dullness of mind.
Pain, aching whole body.
Flatulency.
Vomiting of food and mucous. Not ameliorating.
Frequent urging for stools. No ameliorating.
During headache:
Sour eructations.
Forceful retching.
Strong aversion to drink anything
Desire strong for coitus. (probably full rectum
irritating prostates to cause erections. )
Strong desire for salted things.
Desires to sleep yet can not, though better after
sleep.

One year ago, had an accident in a car, head injury,
lost a lot of blood, left upper limb multiple compound
fractures, broken bones were repaired through surgery.
Has developed cicatrices on the wounded spots,
elevated, hard, nodulated and painful to pressure.

Mind.
Except irritability nothing special.
Mild temperament.

Had been under treatment with different homeopaths.
Will collect the list of remedies taken by the
patient.
Curiosity begets rewards.

--------------------

Dr. Saboor
Homeopathic Physcian & Consultant.
drsaboor51@hotmail.com
drsaboor51@yahoo.com
Phone Clinic: 92-433-521206
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Send your FREE holiday greetings online!
http://greetings.yahoo.com

[shukribn]

In a message dated 1/4/02 1:44:02 PM Eastern Standard Time,
drsaboor51@yahoo.com writes:
Few remarks:

Generals-food-flatul.food -agg, is an important Rubric, to keep its
remedies in mind in finding the simillimum.

His craving, and stool symptoms when a child might not belong to the remedy
he needs now, his state now might need a remedy different from when he was a
child.

Aversion to water/drinks could be an important symptoms.

Shukri
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

[Piet Guijt]

Hello, Dr.Saboor,

Nothing special?

What did you observe when he came to you?
What were the main complaints he talked about, and what kind of emotions he
has toward them?
(Even when you ignore them to be normal for a sick person).
What do his complaints mean to him, and in what and how it hinders him?
How does he react in this on his surrounding, and what action does he take?
etc....
Is the patient hot or cold, and why he thinks he is?

You have to concentrate on this first, when you also use symptoms of the
past, without checking this.
the chance of failure is very big.
best regards, Piet

__________________________________________________
and educational benefit of its members. It makes no representations
regarding the individual suitability of the information contained in any
document read or advice or recommendation offered which appears on this
website and/or email postings for any purpose. The entire risk arising out
of their use remains with the recipient. In no event shall the minutus site
or its individual members be liable for any direct, consequential,
incidental, special, punitive or other damages whatsoever and howsoever
caused.
subject of 'Digest' to ashahrdar@yahoo.com to receive a single daily digest.

[Cl.Mennel]

Dear Dr. Saboor, dear Joy,

at first I thought of Aluminia, too, but then I had a close look at the
M.M. by Kent, Clarke, and Boericke and I think even more worthwhile to
look at is Alumen, the potash of aluminium, I think it fits better with
the stool an rectum symptoms and the vomitting of mucus.

Aluminia has got very peculiar mental symptoms and a very specific frame
of mind which should be checked: weakness, specific confusion of
thought, strange attitude towards knives etc.

For Alumen, not many symptoms of mind are mentioned, maybe due to lack
of proving, see Kent and Clarke.

But as Joy has said, there are a lot of questions to be asked.
Anyway, to check Alumina and especially Alumen can't be wtong.

All the best
Claudia

This email refers to