Here is one I posted on another list last week!!
I had a phone call today , child age 2 with a fever, crying didn't want to be disturbed but lying on a chair next to mother, hot but wanted to throw the covers off, pain in stomach, flatulence, possibly constipated, draws knees up, thirstless.
I prescribed a remedy and had an email later this evening:-
quote:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Miraculous recovery of ------! Within half an hour of giving her ------- 6 (didn't have any 30) she had eaten a biscuit, drunk a lot of bathwater and farted a lot! She is now jumping up and down on her bed resisting pyjamas. Thanks
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Anyone want to guess the remedy? I took 4 rubrics from the above.
Rochelle
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
www.rochellemarsden.co.uk
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
- Sharing a Case
-
APEX PRECITECH
- Posts: 216
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2005 11:00 pm
Re: - Sharing a Case
From Praful Vijaykar's chart of acutes , the following
axis is seen.
Dull,hot, thirstless: Sulphur,lyc,apis,merc,bry,nat m.
Further eliminating: Constipated, wants someone near
,And flatulence . Lyc ?
Venkat
--- ROCHELLE wrote:
---------------------------------
Here is one I posted on another list last week!!
I had a phone call today , child age 2 with a fever,
crying didn't want to be disturbed but lying on a
chair next to mother, hot but wanted to throw the
covers off, pain in stomach, flatulence, possibly
constipated, draws knees up, thirstless.
I prescribed a remedy and had an email later this
evening:-
quote:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Miraculous recovery of ------! Within half an hour
of giving her ------- 6 (didn't have any 30) she had
eaten a biscuit, drunk a lot of bathwater and farted a
lot! She is now jumping up and down on her bed
resisting pyjamas. Thanks
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Anyone want to guess the remedy? I took 4 rubrics from
the above.
Rochelle
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
www.rochellemarsden.co.uk
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ADVERTISEMENT
ATTENTION PLEASE:
The Minutus Group is established purely for the
promotion of Homoeopathy and educational benefit of
its members. It makes no representations regarding the
individual suitability of the information contained in
any document read or advice or recommendation offered
which appears on this website and/or email postings
for any purpose. The entire risk arising out of their
use remains with the recipient. In no event shall the
minutus site or its individual members be liable for
any direct, consequential, incidental, special,
punitive or other damages whatsoever and howsoever
caused.
****
If you do not wish to receive individual emails, send
a message with the subject of 'Digest' to
ashahrdar@yahoo.com to receive a single daily digest.
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
minutus-unsubscribe@egroups.com
Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo!
Terms of Service.
________________________________________________________________________
Yahoo! India Matrimony: Find your partner online.
Go to http://yahoo.shaadi.com
axis is seen.
Dull,hot, thirstless: Sulphur,lyc,apis,merc,bry,nat m.
Further eliminating: Constipated, wants someone near
,And flatulence . Lyc ?
Venkat
--- ROCHELLE wrote:
---------------------------------
Here is one I posted on another list last week!!
I had a phone call today , child age 2 with a fever,
crying didn't want to be disturbed but lying on a
chair next to mother, hot but wanted to throw the
covers off, pain in stomach, flatulence, possibly
constipated, draws knees up, thirstless.
I prescribed a remedy and had an email later this
evening:-
quote:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Miraculous recovery of ------! Within half an hour
of giving her ------- 6 (didn't have any 30) she had
eaten a biscuit, drunk a lot of bathwater and farted a
lot! She is now jumping up and down on her bed
resisting pyjamas. Thanks
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Anyone want to guess the remedy? I took 4 rubrics from
the above.
Rochelle
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
www.rochellemarsden.co.uk
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Yahoo! Groups Sponsor ADVERTISEMENT
ATTENTION PLEASE:
The Minutus Group is established purely for the
promotion of Homoeopathy and educational benefit of
its members. It makes no representations regarding the
individual suitability of the information contained in
any document read or advice or recommendation offered
which appears on this website and/or email postings
for any purpose. The entire risk arising out of their
use remains with the recipient. In no event shall the
minutus site or its individual members be liable for
any direct, consequential, incidental, special,
punitive or other damages whatsoever and howsoever
caused.
****
If you do not wish to receive individual emails, send
a message with the subject of 'Digest' to
ashahrdar@yahoo.com to receive a single daily digest.
To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
minutus-unsubscribe@egroups.com
Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to the Yahoo!
Terms of Service.
________________________________________________________________________
Yahoo! India Matrimony: Find your partner online.
Go to http://yahoo.shaadi.com
-
Julian Winston
- Posts: 622
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2020 10:00 pm
Re: - Sharing a Case
>Here is one I posted on another list last week!!
No guessing.
Rubrics:
stomach, pain, general, drawing up limbs amel
Stomach thirstlessness heat,during
Fever, heat uncovering, desire for
All lead to Bryonia-- which also does not like to be disturbed.
Many years ago, I came into my office at school to find a student
lying on the file cabinets. He seemed to be in pain. I asked if I
could help and he said, "No. I have this stomach thing that comes
every few months. I just need to lie quietly. It goes away in about
an hour. If you want to help, I'd like a big glass of ice-water."
I got him the water.
He sat up, holding his side, and gulped it down.
I asked, "Where does it hurt?" ad he pointed to his left side just
under the ribs. This was NOT his stomach. But it was the side he was
lying on.
I asked him if he'd accept some help, and he said "sure."
Thirsty for large gulps of cold water
Lies on painful side
Does not want to be disturbed
Worse from movement.
A single dose of Bryonia 30 had him up in ten minutes. "Gee, it
didn't last too long this time," he said.
About 4 years later, I bumped into him at a design conference. I
asked him if he remembered that incident. He told me he did and that
since then he had not had a single attack of whatever it was--
although he had them regularly every few months for a few years.
JW
No guessing.
Rubrics:
stomach, pain, general, drawing up limbs amel
Stomach thirstlessness heat,during
Fever, heat uncovering, desire for
All lead to Bryonia-- which also does not like to be disturbed.
Many years ago, I came into my office at school to find a student
lying on the file cabinets. He seemed to be in pain. I asked if I
could help and he said, "No. I have this stomach thing that comes
every few months. I just need to lie quietly. It goes away in about
an hour. If you want to help, I'd like a big glass of ice-water."
I got him the water.
He sat up, holding his side, and gulped it down.
I asked, "Where does it hurt?" ad he pointed to his left side just
under the ribs. This was NOT his stomach. But it was the side he was
lying on.
I asked him if he'd accept some help, and he said "sure."
Thirsty for large gulps of cold water
Lies on painful side
Does not want to be disturbed
Worse from movement.
A single dose of Bryonia 30 had him up in ten minutes. "Gee, it
didn't last too long this time," he said.
About 4 years later, I bumped into him at a design conference. I
asked him if he remembered that incident. He told me he did and that
since then he had not had a single attack of whatever it was--
although he had them regularly every few months for a few years.
JW
Re: - Sharing a Case
Thanks Julian, Ventkat, Marie !!! It wasn't Bryonia as no way did Mum say
that the child was < movement only that she wanted to lie close to her but
was not clingy like Puls would be.
I took 4 rubrics,
Flatulence obstructed,
Thirstlessness during fever,
Constipation in children
Covers kicks off.
Only 1 remedy comes through all 4 rubrics and that is Chamomilla which cured
the case with 1 dose of 6x. This fit the case because the child didn't want
to be disturbed but wanted to lay near mum.
I learnt something here as I didn't know that Cham. was in the rubric
constipation as I always associate it with green diarrhoea during
teething!!!
Regards
Rochelle
------------------------------------------------------------
Here is one I posted on another list last week!!
I had a phone call today , child age 2 with a fever, crying didn't want to
be disturbed but lying on a chair next to mother, hot but wanted to throw
the covers off, pain in stomach, flatulence, possibly constipated, draws
knees up, thirstless.
I prescribed a remedy and had an email later this evening:-
quote:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Miraculous recovery of ------! Within half an hour of giving her ------- 6
(didn't have any 30) she had eaten a biscuit, drunk a lot of bathwater and
farted a lot! She is now jumping up and down on her bed resisting pyjamas.
Thanks
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Anyone want to guess the remedy? I took 4 rubrics from the above.
Rochelle
www.rochellemarsden.co.uk
that the child was < movement only that she wanted to lie close to her but
was not clingy like Puls would be.
I took 4 rubrics,
Flatulence obstructed,
Thirstlessness during fever,
Constipation in children
Covers kicks off.
Only 1 remedy comes through all 4 rubrics and that is Chamomilla which cured
the case with 1 dose of 6x. This fit the case because the child didn't want
to be disturbed but wanted to lay near mum.
I learnt something here as I didn't know that Cham. was in the rubric
constipation as I always associate it with green diarrhoea during
teething!!!
Regards
Rochelle
------------------------------------------------------------
Here is one I posted on another list last week!!
I had a phone call today , child age 2 with a fever, crying didn't want to
be disturbed but lying on a chair next to mother, hot but wanted to throw
the covers off, pain in stomach, flatulence, possibly constipated, draws
knees up, thirstless.
I prescribed a remedy and had an email later this evening:-
quote:
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Miraculous recovery of ------! Within half an hour of giving her ------- 6
(didn't have any 30) she had eaten a biscuit, drunk a lot of bathwater and
farted a lot! She is now jumping up and down on her bed resisting pyjamas.
Thanks
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
Anyone want to guess the remedy? I took 4 rubrics from the above.
Rochelle
www.rochellemarsden.co.uk
-
Julian Winston
- Posts: 622
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2020 10:00 pm
Re: - Sharing a Case
>I took 4 rubrics,
While one cannot deny the result, I believe that the rubrics selected
when compared with the case *as presented* are a bit of a leap.
"possibly constipated" does not equal "Constipation in children"
nor does "flatulence" equal "Flatulence obstructed."
If this case were presented, as is, to our students in Wellington,
and they suggested the rubrics just mentioned, we would ask, "How did
you get that? Where does it say that?"
If one takes the rubrics:
Uncovering, desire for
Pain, Stomach, drawing up limbs amel
Stomach, pain, general
Rectum, flatus
Thirtstlessness during fever
Aversion to being disturbed
Bryonia comes up in first place (11/6) with Chamomilla in third (9/5)
If we remove "Pain, Stomach, drawing up limbs amel" and substitute
"Stomach, pain, bending double, amel."
Chamomilla comes up 9/6 followed by a bunch of others (Mur. ac,
Coloc, Chel., Sulph, etc.) until we get to Bryonia in place 15.
Bryonia , while it has pain > drawing up knees, it does NOT have
Pain > bending double.
Very interesting, eh? (I'm using The Complete Rep. 4.5)
So it all hinges on selecting the exact rubric. If you eliminate both
the bending double and drawing knees up, you get both Cham. and
Bryonia, and a bunch of other to differentiate.
We don't have the alternate universe machine to let us go back and
try a different remedy to see if that was "close enough" to give
relief.
As for the try of Lycopodium... it has the general stomach pain, and
the flatus. It has uncovering, and Thirstlessness (both as a "1"),
but does not have aversion to being disturbed.
One thing we can possible learn from the suggestion of Lycopodium is
that thinking of Keynotes for "acute, stomach" does not get you in
the ballpark. This is the problem with "keynote" prescribing--
narrowing down to something known, rather than sorting out the case.
JW
While one cannot deny the result, I believe that the rubrics selected
when compared with the case *as presented* are a bit of a leap.
"possibly constipated" does not equal "Constipation in children"
nor does "flatulence" equal "Flatulence obstructed."
If this case were presented, as is, to our students in Wellington,
and they suggested the rubrics just mentioned, we would ask, "How did
you get that? Where does it say that?"
If one takes the rubrics:
Uncovering, desire for
Pain, Stomach, drawing up limbs amel
Stomach, pain, general
Rectum, flatus
Thirtstlessness during fever
Aversion to being disturbed
Bryonia comes up in first place (11/6) with Chamomilla in third (9/5)
If we remove "Pain, Stomach, drawing up limbs amel" and substitute
"Stomach, pain, bending double, amel."
Chamomilla comes up 9/6 followed by a bunch of others (Mur. ac,
Coloc, Chel., Sulph, etc.) until we get to Bryonia in place 15.
Bryonia , while it has pain > drawing up knees, it does NOT have
Pain > bending double.
Very interesting, eh? (I'm using The Complete Rep. 4.5)
So it all hinges on selecting the exact rubric. If you eliminate both
the bending double and drawing knees up, you get both Cham. and
Bryonia, and a bunch of other to differentiate.
We don't have the alternate universe machine to let us go back and
try a different remedy to see if that was "close enough" to give
relief.
As for the try of Lycopodium... it has the general stomach pain, and
the flatus. It has uncovering, and Thirstlessness (both as a "1"),
but does not have aversion to being disturbed.
One thing we can possible learn from the suggestion of Lycopodium is
that thinking of Keynotes for "acute, stomach" does not get you in
the ballpark. This is the problem with "keynote" prescribing--
narrowing down to something known, rather than sorting out the case.
JW
Re: - Sharing a Case
Hi Julian,
I admit that maybe from Mum over the phone I got the impression that she thought that the flatulence was causing the pain and I would have made the leap Constipation in children because it was a possible causation. One thing I have to ask you is, where in the Complete - and I have the Millennium Edition is Thirstless(ness) during fever? I have both Cara and the new ISIS and can only find this rubric in Murphy or Boerike? Is it in the hard copy and not searchable on the computer?
Welcome aboard I like your challenges!!!
(Incidentally Lycopodium is a Rx that has worked very well on Mum in the past!!)
Regards
Rochelle
www.rochellemarsden.co.uk
I admit that maybe from Mum over the phone I got the impression that she thought that the flatulence was causing the pain and I would have made the leap Constipation in children because it was a possible causation. One thing I have to ask you is, where in the Complete - and I have the Millennium Edition is Thirstless(ness) during fever? I have both Cara and the new ISIS and can only find this rubric in Murphy or Boerike? Is it in the hard copy and not searchable on the computer?
Welcome aboard I like your challenges!!!
(Incidentally Lycopodium is a Rx that has worked very well on Mum in the past!!)Regards
Rochelle
www.rochellemarsden.co.uk
Re: - Sharing a Case
Dear Rochelle, Thirstless during fever is quite a large rubric, easily found
in the Food section, and there is also, in Fevers, the rubric, thirst absent
with fever, also Fever with little thirst, and fever with or without thirst
- which are all related.
It is best to go back to the good old books sometimes
)
Best, Joy
www.homeopathicmateriamedica.com
--- ROCHELLE wrote:
---------------------------------
Hi Julian,
One thing I have to ask you is, where in
the Complete - and I have the Millennium Edition is
Thirstless(ness) during fever? I have both Cara and
the new ISIS and can only find this rubric in Murphy
or Boerike? Is it in the hard copy and not searchable
on the computer?
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
in the Food section, and there is also, in Fevers, the rubric, thirst absent
with fever, also Fever with little thirst, and fever with or without thirst
- which are all related.
It is best to go back to the good old books sometimes
)Best, Joy
www.homeopathicmateriamedica.com
--- ROCHELLE wrote:
---------------------------------
Hi Julian,
One thing I have to ask you is, where in
the Complete - and I have the Millennium Edition is
Thirstless(ness) during fever? I have both Cara and
the new ISIS and can only find this rubric in Murphy
or Boerike? Is it in the hard copy and not searchable
on the computer?
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
-
APEX PRECITECH
- Posts: 216
- Joined: Sat Nov 26, 2005 11:00 pm
Re: - Sharing a Case
Lyc is not in Thrstlessness during fever. This
thirstlessness Praful talks about is when the pt feels
hot- when he cannot tolerate heat- e.g. throwing
covers off. This is a srp sx. In every repertory you
may find cold agg,amel,becoming agg etc but not this.
This is more than a keynote which Julian thinks. You
wanted a guess and Julian jumped into it. I zeroed
from eight. May be the words stomach centred acutes
made him say that. Praful says his chart will work
70%. I use it when giving an off hand Rx. When srp are
present, I go for it. There is one more elimination
strategy he gives; when hot,thirstless,dry lips,mouth-
bry,lyc.
Your case wasn't bry. As for Boger's(heat &fever)
concommittants
peevish(cham,lyc are there)
abdominal pain: 4cham,lyc
tirstless: cham
flatulent symtoms;both are not represented
Regards
Venkat
--- ROCHELLE wrote:
---------------------------------
Hi Julian,
I admit that maybe from Mum over the phone I got the
impression that she thought that the flatulence was
causing the pain and I would have made the leap
Constipation in children because it was a possible
causation. One thing I have to ask you is, where in
the Complete - and I have the Millennium Edition is
Thirstless(ness) during fever? I have both Cara and
the new ISIS and can only find this rubric in Murphy
or Boerike? Is it in the hard copy and not searchable
on the computer?
Welcome aboard I like your challenges!!!
(Incidentally Lycopodium is a Rx that has worked very
well on Mum in the past!!)
Regards
Rochelle
www.rochellemarsden.co.uk
thirstlessness Praful talks about is when the pt feels
hot- when he cannot tolerate heat- e.g. throwing
covers off. This is a srp sx. In every repertory you
may find cold agg,amel,becoming agg etc but not this.
This is more than a keynote which Julian thinks. You
wanted a guess and Julian jumped into it. I zeroed
from eight. May be the words stomach centred acutes
made him say that. Praful says his chart will work
70%. I use it when giving an off hand Rx. When srp are
present, I go for it. There is one more elimination
strategy he gives; when hot,thirstless,dry lips,mouth-
bry,lyc.
Your case wasn't bry. As for Boger's(heat &fever)
concommittants
peevish(cham,lyc are there)
abdominal pain: 4cham,lyc
tirstless: cham
flatulent symtoms;both are not represented
Regards
Venkat
--- ROCHELLE wrote:
---------------------------------
Hi Julian,
I admit that maybe from Mum over the phone I got the
impression that she thought that the flatulence was
causing the pain and I would have made the leap
Constipation in children because it was a possible
causation. One thing I have to ask you is, where in
the Complete - and I have the Millennium Edition is
Thirstless(ness) during fever? I have both Cara and
the new ISIS and can only find this rubric in Murphy
or Boerike? Is it in the hard copy and not searchable
on the computer?
Welcome aboard I like your challenges!!!
(Incidentally Lycopodium is a Rx that has worked very
well on Mum in the past!!)
Regards
Rochelle
www.rochellemarsden.co.uk
-
Julian Winston
- Posts: 622
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2020 10:00 pm
Re: - Sharing a Case
asks:
Stomach, thirstlessness, heat, during.
As I said, I only say something when I think I can offer. Otherwise
I'm happy lurking.
JW
Stomach, thirstlessness, heat, during.
As I said, I only say something when I think I can offer. Otherwise
I'm happy lurking.
JW
-
jean vanhove
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Wed Apr 01, 2020 10:00 pm
Re: - Sharing a Case
may i make a suggestion ? Why is there no one who gives some other symptons
related to this, what is felt in the neck, is the skull normal, how did
delivering work out, long-short, heavy baby or not, what are the childs food
habits and drinking habits, is there anyone who has checked the iris ? is
there a slight colouring in the iris around the pupil ? is the child making
movements or is it completely calm ? is this the first time you saw the
child ? is there a history of the child ? i ask those questions because i
have also notice about osteopathy, cranio sacral therapy, iriscopy and
radiestesy, specialized in electromagnetic field elemination, and studying
food allergy by the system develloped by Mark Elzen.
another suggestion can be argentum nitricum.
May you all be blessed in the circle of light
jean
http://users.skynet.be/jeanvanhove
Healing System Kathleen Milner Belgium
related to this, what is felt in the neck, is the skull normal, how did
delivering work out, long-short, heavy baby or not, what are the childs food
habits and drinking habits, is there anyone who has checked the iris ? is
there a slight colouring in the iris around the pupil ? is the child making
movements or is it completely calm ? is this the first time you saw the
child ? is there a history of the child ? i ask those questions because i
have also notice about osteopathy, cranio sacral therapy, iriscopy and
radiestesy, specialized in electromagnetic field elemination, and studying
food allergy by the system develloped by Mark Elzen.
another suggestion can be argentum nitricum.
May you all be blessed in the circle of light
jean
http://users.skynet.be/jeanvanhove
Healing System Kathleen Milner Belgium