Vital Sensation - (was Joy's case - Symphytum - Humpty Dumpty)

[vtyekkirala]

Hi,
This is meant only for those who attended the seminars on the subject or
read the Insight into Plants books by Rajan.

The sensation expressed by the pt as - "My life is falling apart" +
diarrhoea and the physical trauma with the same expression behind it
- all leads to my conclusion of vital sensation as that corresponding to
the plant family Leguminosae of which bapt is a well known.remedy.
Now if we are able to find out the miasm in Rajan's classification we
get to know the smm. The way the pt copes up to his vital sensation
expresses the miasm and so it appears to me as the failed state of
typhoid miasm.
I quote:-
"since then everything has been falling apart - doesn't know what to do
with his life, cannot make decisions, cannot bring it all together, doesn't
know what direction to go in, feels pulled in many directions, father
wants him to work with him (furniture business), is getting angry with son
for not getting his act together, his friends keep telling him the same
thing
"pull yourself together"- unquote.
So it all points out to the remedy as read off the grid map devised by Rajan
as bapt. Out of curiosity I checked and found the vital sensation of this
drug (page 321, vol1) -
"feels scattered and must collect all pieces immediately or
desperately trying to put all my pieces together and if I can
get them together , I am fine "
(obviously what is mentioned by Rajan corresponds to the active
or success stage while what we are seeing in this patient is the failed
state.)
Now my question is whether bapt could have worked as smm better than
symph in this case. We don't know much on the M/E of bapt, but since
we are matching at the vital sensation level which happens to be deeper
than the mental state, it should work if we are to go by Rajan's experience.
Would love to hear your comments.....
and thanks Joy for sharing your case.
With best wishes,
V.T.Yekkirala.