Rubrics help sought.

[H. Balasubramanian]

Dear friends,
One of my patients suffering from wheezing problems
says that he is free from this problem, when he is in
hill station. I couldn’t find a rubric in Kent
repertory. If it is in other repertory, please give
the rubric with remedies.
=====
BE HAPPY AND MAKE OTHERS HAPPY.

With best wishes,
H.B.
from India

visit: http://education.vsnl.com/susceptibilit ... doctor/com

__________________________________________________
Yahoo! Plus
For a better Internet experience
http://www.yahoo.co.uk/btoffer

[Shannon Nelson]

What does "hill station" mean? (Is it simply someplace in the
hills/mountains?)
Could it be > mountains, or
could he be allergic to something that is absent in "hill station" and
present in the place he usualy is?

Shannon
on 4/17/03 2:39 PM, H. BALASUBRAMANIAN at balah12002@yahoo.co.uk wrote:

[Tanya Marquette]

why dont you just ask him what he means by 'hill station.'

tanya

[Rosemary Hyde]

Radar (Synthesis) has "Respiration asthmatic mountains amel" with one
remedy, Syph. I was surprised -- I would have predicted Tuberculinum, which
I always thought was > mountains and of course has breathing problems. Oh,
well.

Rosemary

[Patti Mount]

Not only that Rosemary BUT it is a rubric from Dr Farokh Master who has done extensive clinical work with
asthmatics so it should be a very reliable rubric as well!

best, Patti.

[Joy Lucas]

You need to cross reference all the time - generals/environment will also
give you Tub in mountain air amel; mountain air is usually clean and clear
so 'ailments from pollution' possibly useful, 'ascending high mountains
amel' and possibly 'clear weather amel'.

best wishes, Joy
on 4/17/03 10:28 PM, Rosemary Hyde at rosemaryhyde@mindspring.com wrote:

Radar (Synthesis) has "Respiration asthmatic mountains amel" with one
remedy, Syph. I was surprised -- I would have predicted Tuberculinum, which
I always thought was > mountains and of course has breathing problems. Oh,
well.

Rosemary

[Wendy Howard]

> > Radar (Synthesis) has "Respiration asthmatic mountains amel" with one
which
Oh,

There's also
GENERALITIES; MOUNTAINS; amel. being in (2) : prot., syph.
from the Complete Repertory (4.5).

A search in ReferenceWorks for Mountains/Altitude ameliorates gives the
remedies:
carl., coca, conv., falco-p., graph., kali-n., lith-m., lyss., med.,
nat-caust., nat-f., osm., plb-m., prot., sil., stront., Syph., titan-s.,
tub., zirc.

Regards
Wendy

[vtyekkirala]

Hi,
To the list given by Wendy, I wish to add sul-ac also
under ailments from pollution.
With best wishes,
V.T.Yekkirala.

[Patti Mount]

Hi HB,

The rubric in RADAR Synthesis is placed there from many clinical case experiences by Dr Farokh Master from
experience in his clinic of 25 homeopathic practitioners that he over-sees in India and in which he also
practices... so that means that he has clinically seen Syph. cure in that rubric... Does this explain it OK for
you?

Regards, Patti.

[H. Balasubramanian]

Dear Shannon, Rosemary, Patti Mount, Joy Lucas, "Wendy
Howard", V.T.Yekkirala.,
Thank you all for enlightening reply. I meant by
hillstation, hill or mountain. You have given me the
correct guidance.
However, I require a clarification from Patti Mount
Farokh Master who has done extensive clinical work
with asthmatics so it should be a very reliable rubric
as well!”
What exactly Dr. Farokh wrote? Does he recommend Syph
or Tuber?
=====
BE HAPPY AND MAKE OTHERS HAPPY.

With best wishes,
H.B.
from India

visit: http://education.vsnl.com/susceptibilit ... doctor/com

__________________________________________________
Yahoo! Plus
For a better Internet experience
http://www.yahoo.co.uk/btoffer