Hering : Calabar / Physostigma - The Guiding Symptoms by C. Hering (will be online for Christmas)

[Dave Hartley]

Hi Sylvain,

This is the same, as far as I can see.

T.L. BRADFORD , Index of Homoeopathic Provings
Physostigma venenosum
Calabar Bean. Eserene. Faba calabarica. Ordeal Bean. Chop nut. Tinct. trit.
of bean.
PAGE 221
Allen: Cyclopaedia, V. 7. Cyclop. Drug Path., V. 3. Hering: Guid Symptoms,
V. 3. Macfarlan: High Pot. Provings.
Allen: Tr. Am. Inst. Hom., 1874.
Berridge: N. A. J. Hom., V. 23, p. 375.
Beckwith: Tr. Hom. Med. Soc., Ohio, 1870.
Chase, Cullis et al.: Tr. Mass. Hom. Med. Soc., 1861-'66. N. A. J. Hom., V.
19, p. 29.
Christison: Pharmac. Jl., V. 14, p. 474, 1855.
Bowman: Med. Times and Gaz., 1863.
Fraser: Edin. Med. Jl., 1863.
Von Graafe: Arch. f Ophthal., V. 9, pt. 3, p. 112, 1863.
Macfarlan: Hom. Phys., V. 12, p. 93; V. 13, p. 490.
Ogle: Brit. Jl. Hom., V. 22, p. 140.
Payne: N. E. Med. Gaz., V. 13, p. 145.
Swan: Hahn. Mo., V. 9, p. 266.
Sharp: Essays.
Wesselhoeft: N. A. J. Hom., V. 19, p. 29, 1874.
Hering's Guiding Symptoms (as it appears in Encyclopedia Homeoapthica 2.0)
Physostigma venenosum
Calabar bean; eserine. leguminosae.
A climbing plant, native to Africa.
The alcoholic tincture is prepared from the finely pulverized bean.
Toxicological reports, experiments and provings are numerous.
See Allen's Encyclopedia, vol.
7, p. 466.
CLINICAL AUTHORITIES.
-Mental disorder, Kenyon, Raue's Rec., 1875, p. 32, from Trans.
N. Y. S., 1873-4, p. 293; Nervous excitability, Nash, Times Ret, 1875, p.
37, from Trans.
N. Y. S., 1875, p. 176; Cerebro-spinal meningitis, Hale, A. H. O., vol.
10, p. 134; Wells, A. H. O., vol.
10, p. 476; Myopia (3 cases), Woodyatt Times, Ret., 1877, p. 64; Ill
effects of blow upon eye, Dudgeon, Org., vol.
3, p. 267, from B. J. H., Jan., 1880; Eserine in glaucoma, Cant, Smith,
Buzzard, Fitzgerald, Brailey, Snell, T. A. J. H., 1886, p. 423; Nervous
disorders during dentition, Penfield, T. A. J. H., 1884, p. 256; Piles,
Swan, Hah.
Mo., vol.
9, p. 267; Sighing during menses, Fiske, Raue's Reck., 1875, p. 176;
Neuralgic pains in limbs, Kenyon, Raue's Rec., 1875, p. 246, from Trans.
N. Y. S., 1873-4, p. 293; Tetanus, Helmuth, Raue's Rec., 1875, p. 250,
from Trans.
N. Y. S., 1873-4, p. 295.

warm regards,
Dave Hartley
www.Mr-Notebook.com
www.localcomputermart.com/dave
Seattle, WA 425.820.7443
Asheville, NC 828.285.0240

[Robyn]

Hi Sylvain
I have had a little look at the Hering entries for both Calabar and
Physostigma and have found something interesting.
In the section of Calabar p.115 there are
references to 5 people with conditions. Doing a search in EH I found that
nowhere in Allens or Hering (other than Calabar) are these 5 cases to be
found. It is only in CALABAR. However, there are other symptoms recorded in
CALABAR which are to be found in PHYSOSTIGMA in both Allens and Hering.

Possible conclusion - that these are an error or that they are provings that
were added after the others or maybe they are poisonings. Maybe Julian
Winston may be able to solve this!

The two entries in Hering do not appear to be exactly the same to me. There
are symptoms in CALABAR that are not in Physostigma and vice versa.

Regards
Robyn

The ignorance of yesterday is the knowledge of today
which in turn becomes the ignorance of tomorrow