once upon a time in the land of Minutiae (oops, sorry, Minutus) there were 3 buddies (1, 2, and 3) who met up, in close contact, to discuss aetiology of disease one (1) of them had smallpox the others (2 and 3) were relatively healthy, however....... the parents of 2 had suffered themselves badly wi...

I would like to know what we are playing then, seeing as you, Shannon and Liz are getting very bullying in your attitudes to how posts are answered and demanding prescribed answers that you want, so can you PLEASE answer mine about how you use CAUSATION in your case taking and analysis - what is it ...

Oh not you again! Are you his agent as well now? I never alluded to the bug being the result. I refer to symptoms being the result. And yes some antibiotics do damage the bugs presence (as well as the host) but what is the value in that, what part does that play in this discussion. Antibiotics are n...

Wrong way round - you are blaming the bug and you also think like the allopath and as always not as Hahnemann taught us sx come last, susceptibility comes before sx, the template is what releases the susceptibility, i.e. causation, the trigger that releases the susceptibility and this is not the bug...

Bugs are bugs, they are just present. If anyone goes to the trouble of having lab tests when they get measles then of course the so called measles bug will be identified but who is to say it wasn't there all the time; who cares whether it is identifiable or not; how does it change anything; these so...

I haven't left any of your questions unanswered! If you want to repeat them please be quick as I am not lingering here for much longer. And it IS a discussion about whether microbes are causative of disease, if you now want to extend it to ANY injurious agent that causes the susceptibility of diseas...

What is your understanding then of Hahnemann's writings on causations?

Joy

http://www.joylucashomeopathy.com
http://www.streetcollege.co.uk

You obviously did get in your own particular ways - hep a.

Astonishing that homeopaths still do not understand causation.
Joy

http://www.joylucashomeopathy.com
http://www.streetcollege.co.uk

Then we cannot agree but you must realise that what you write is not how Hahnemann understood it.

Joy

http://www.joylucashomeopathy.com
http://www.streetcollege.co.uk

I am thinking there are 2 issues here to consider Are these sx presenting due to an emotional neglect, i.e. the dog is thinking this is its last meal ever and so cannot stop eating or is it due to some other clinical reason, i.e. physical such as a thyroid dysfunction. Presumably you could have test...