Synopsis of Mur-ac case - 5000 miles away from home.
Posted: Thu Jul 28, 2005 10:54 pm
The one Mur-ac case that was particularly interesting and
succesful was a serious chronic fatigue case (not surprising)
who had had lots of other remedies.
The recurrent thing that kept coming up was how she felt her life
had been a series of failures and that she had never
accomplished anything. it was quite amazing to hear how many
things she had attempted that had not worked out, it was asif
she was jinxed. This affected every area of her life. the CFS
eventually created a state in which she literally did not have the
energy to work, have a relationship or anything.
I dont have the case with me here so cant remember the couple
of very relevent physical symptoms that fitted the theme and
which went into the repertorisation but the key rubric was 'Never
succeeds' plus irresolution and discouraged and ailment from
mortification because of an event that occured early on. There
was some modality I cant remember too. She was 'cured' of her
CFS over a period of 6-8 months. She had had it for years. Id like
to know if anyone else has seen this never succeeds thing being
a big feature of a true Mur ac case.
She had no particular dwelling on the past and I disagree that
the delusion about changing the past is the key one. Why is that
one more important than the delusions about being empty,
phantoms and animals? Its only key if you decide in advance that
they have issues to do with the past which you may expect from
muriaticum - then it fits conveniently but Id like to see that
confirmed clinically. It wasnt in either of my cases. What she did
have were big mother issues to do with being a mother (burnt
out) and being mothered which is a muriatic thing.
Scuse my grammar and my typing
Robin
succesful was a serious chronic fatigue case (not surprising)
who had had lots of other remedies.
The recurrent thing that kept coming up was how she felt her life
had been a series of failures and that she had never
accomplished anything. it was quite amazing to hear how many
things she had attempted that had not worked out, it was asif
she was jinxed. This affected every area of her life. the CFS
eventually created a state in which she literally did not have the
energy to work, have a relationship or anything.
I dont have the case with me here so cant remember the couple
of very relevent physical symptoms that fitted the theme and
which went into the repertorisation but the key rubric was 'Never
succeeds' plus irresolution and discouraged and ailment from
mortification because of an event that occured early on. There
was some modality I cant remember too. She was 'cured' of her
CFS over a period of 6-8 months. She had had it for years. Id like
to know if anyone else has seen this never succeeds thing being
a big feature of a true Mur ac case.
She had no particular dwelling on the past and I disagree that
the delusion about changing the past is the key one. Why is that
one more important than the delusions about being empty,
phantoms and animals? Its only key if you decide in advance that
they have issues to do with the past which you may expect from
muriaticum - then it fits conveniently but Id like to see that
confirmed clinically. It wasnt in either of my cases. What she did
have were big mother issues to do with being a mother (burnt
out) and being mothered which is a muriatic thing.
Scuse my grammar and my typing
Robin