Poor vs Rich
Posted: Sat Apr 30, 2005 5:03 pm
I would like to respond to David's posting.
I am a British Homeopath who has worked in several different countries with Frontline Homeopathy, as well as in my own semi-urban practice in the UK. As you say, David, Dr Banerji raises some interesting points, and I too think their is some truth in what he says, but would also disagree with him in roughly the same areas as yourself.
Time ad again I have been faced with serious and complex disease in a patient who is living on less than US$1 per day. My own concerns re: my ability to treat this person successfully have so often proved to be unfounded - the patient responds beautifully - gently and rapidly - to the appropriate remedy. Dare I add - permanently, too? I have treated several cases of advanced (life-threatening) pathology and have 5yrs of follow-ups on most, with no re-emergence of the presenting pathology.
Conversely, similar patients in the UK have done less well - OK but far from the response I have seen in poorer places. These UK patients are living with their disease, rather than moving forward towards "cure". Often I believe the obstacle to cure is not just the allopathic suppressive treatment they have taken alongside my treatment, but more importantly the psychological suppression brought about by what you describe as the disease of over-civilization - neuroses, mood disorders, the "spoiled brat" characteristics of many westerners is a major stumbling block.
I agree that the inner terrain of the body and psyche is being annihilated by the onslaught of poor - inappropriate diet, by the destruction of environment and the detachment form the "real" - natural world.
As I get older I am becoming the feminist who is advocating staying home with the kids - rear your own kids - they need you more than the extra money you might earn to pay someone else to mind them - and they certainly need you more than the latest Gap kid fashions or latest toy. The developing world think we are quite mad - and I believe they are right.
This madness is producing sociopathic adults, and a host of other severe mental and emotional disorders.
Then there is processed food - this is the best way to undermine health as fast as possible - processed food IS junk - we are evolved to eat fresh food, not this crap, to which we are becoming ever more allergic and suppressed. "Slow food" is the way forward! Lastly I am "for" parents not being over-worked and under-rested, obsessed with material things rather than the quality of the relationships within the home, especially with their kids.
I have worked in countries where clean water is rare - and it kills people, where measles is a killer on a regular basis, where malaria is omni-present and lethal, where food is not abundant and kids (and adults) have no choice - they eat what is put in front of them rather than being picky and throwing large amounts away.
Happiness is something that comes from within - it is most emphatically NOT money and NOT things. Happiness comes when you nourish your soul as well as your body. Be grateful for what you have - and SHARE with others - happiness follows.
Liz
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
I am a British Homeopath who has worked in several different countries with Frontline Homeopathy, as well as in my own semi-urban practice in the UK. As you say, David, Dr Banerji raises some interesting points, and I too think their is some truth in what he says, but would also disagree with him in roughly the same areas as yourself.
Time ad again I have been faced with serious and complex disease in a patient who is living on less than US$1 per day. My own concerns re: my ability to treat this person successfully have so often proved to be unfounded - the patient responds beautifully - gently and rapidly - to the appropriate remedy. Dare I add - permanently, too? I have treated several cases of advanced (life-threatening) pathology and have 5yrs of follow-ups on most, with no re-emergence of the presenting pathology.
Conversely, similar patients in the UK have done less well - OK but far from the response I have seen in poorer places. These UK patients are living with their disease, rather than moving forward towards "cure". Often I believe the obstacle to cure is not just the allopathic suppressive treatment they have taken alongside my treatment, but more importantly the psychological suppression brought about by what you describe as the disease of over-civilization - neuroses, mood disorders, the "spoiled brat" characteristics of many westerners is a major stumbling block.
I agree that the inner terrain of the body and psyche is being annihilated by the onslaught of poor - inappropriate diet, by the destruction of environment and the detachment form the "real" - natural world.
As I get older I am becoming the feminist who is advocating staying home with the kids - rear your own kids - they need you more than the extra money you might earn to pay someone else to mind them - and they certainly need you more than the latest Gap kid fashions or latest toy. The developing world think we are quite mad - and I believe they are right.
This madness is producing sociopathic adults, and a host of other severe mental and emotional disorders.
Then there is processed food - this is the best way to undermine health as fast as possible - processed food IS junk - we are evolved to eat fresh food, not this crap, to which we are becoming ever more allergic and suppressed. "Slow food" is the way forward! Lastly I am "for" parents not being over-worked and under-rested, obsessed with material things rather than the quality of the relationships within the home, especially with their kids.
I have worked in countries where clean water is rare - and it kills people, where measles is a killer on a regular basis, where malaria is omni-present and lethal, where food is not abundant and kids (and adults) have no choice - they eat what is put in front of them rather than being picky and throwing large amounts away.
Happiness is something that comes from within - it is most emphatically NOT money and NOT things. Happiness comes when you nourish your soul as well as your body. Be grateful for what you have - and SHARE with others - happiness follows.
Liz
__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]