State of disposition/case presentation

[Farbod Rahnama]

Dear Listee
I had a case of this kind. The case was so interesting for me.:
About 2 years ago a 50 years old woman came to me. She was crying when she entered the office, she was crying during my case taking , crying when I was preparing her remedy and crying when living the office. Causation: she had a 28 years old girl living abrode whit her husband. She came back to see her mother while she was pregnant, in her holiday she , her husband and her mother took a trip. They had a car crash on the road and my patient was watching her daughter when a bus ran over her and killed her. It has occured 8 mounths ago
She was worried of her husband and son. Because she thouth they are upset because of her weepings.
Weeping , music
weeping while telling her sickness
ailment from death of loved ones
No physical symptoms except eye pain. No modality.
What do you thinking? what do you prescribe for such a patient? Please let me know your idea.

Thanks
Farbod
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

[Rosemary Hyde]

Yes, this is interesting. Four things occur to me. One is that you were
able at least to observe her. She was weeping, and weeping in the repertory
has lots of modalities. The weeping appears overwhelming, taking away her
ability or willingness to observe anything about herself or to talk about
it. Also what else could you notice about her hair, skin, posture, gait,
complexion, clothing, manner, attitude, way of talking? The second biggie
is that worry of hers that her husband and son are upset with her weeping. I
think I might have asked why. What was she worried about? At the least,
this is a form of anxiety, and also of renouncing her own needs in favor of
other people's needs (staphysagria??). If I still didn't have a remedy, I
might have been inclined to ask her if I could ask her husband and son to
tell me what they had observed and how they perceived her actions. And
finally, if she couldn't/ wouldn't talk about her constitutional history and
issues, they probably could fill you in at least somewhat on these. From a
combination of observing the patient carefully and talking to the parents or
owners, I've been able, as have many other homeopaths, to get good cases for
babies and pets, with remedies working well. This sounds like an analogous
situation since the patient at this point seemed unable to communicate
verbally.

For what it's worth... Rosemary C. Hyde, Ph.D.

[Ahmed N. Currim]

The three mind symptoms given come out to Ign; and eye pain has Ignatia
also.What do you think? you know your patient better than anyone. Kind
regards, Ahmed N. Currim

[Soroush Ebrahimi]

I think this is 'one sided' case where everything comes to the same issue
again!

The concern for her husband etc could be out of sympathy - (I'm
worried/unwell - don't want to make them unwell."

Soroush