Minutus

DEAR FRIENDS,

COULD YOU PLEASE TELL ME WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ELECTRO
HOMOEOPATHY AND THE CLASSICAL HOMOEOPATHY?

IS IT SAME ? OR DIFFERENT ?

REGARDS,

Dr.ABDUL JALAL,DIMS.,MD.,PHD

By "electro homeopathy" are you referring to the method where remedies
(usually many at a time) are selected according to how they affect
electrical skin responses? If so, it is very different from classical
homeopathy. If that is not what you refer to, can you describe it?
Thankyou,
Shannon
on 7/12/04 2:14 PM, Dr. Abdul Jalal at abduljalal@yahoo.com wrote:

In einer eMail vom 12.07.04 21:12:55 (MEZ) Mitteleuropäische Zeit schreibt
abduljalal@yahoo.com:

<< DEAR FRIENDS,
COULD YOU PLEASE TELL ME WHAT IS THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ELECTRO
HOMOEOPATHY AND THE CLASSICAL HOMOEOPATHY?
IS IT SAME ? OR DIFFERENT ?
REGARDS,
Dr.ABDUL JALAL,DIMS.,MD.,PHD
13.7.4.
Could it be you mean electroacupuncture vs. acupuncture?
Kind regards, Dr.medic. Viorel V. Bucur (www.dr-bucur.com).

At 7:14 PM +0000 7/12/04, Dr. Abdul Jalal wrote:

It is different-- VERY different.

Classical Homeopathy (Hahnemannian homeopathy) is based upon matching
the characteristic symptoms of the case with the known symptoms the
remedies produce in provings, and giving the single remedy that is
the best match.

ElectroHomeopathy uses a MACHINE to measure the resistance through
acupuncture meridians, and to see which remedies (PLURAL) "balance"
the readings. Usually more than one remedy is given. Often nosodes
and isodes are indicated.
I am of the opinion that the EH Machines are nothing but psychotronic
devices and the value of them lies in the ability of the operator.
Generally, the experience seen by classical homeopaths is that
treatment by EH machines are at the best superficial, and at the
worst suppressive.

Although the EH machines use *homeopathic remedies* as a medium, the
use of them is NOT homeopathic.

JW

Electro Homeopathy is something that came out of Italy I think and
used to be a combination of various medicines. They used to have a
combination of medicines ( I remember it is only from plants) for
each condition - much like some of the biochemic combinations. For
example there used to be a combination called Green or something that
was considered very good for Skin problems. I remember using some of
the medicines successfully for some conditions - a friend of mine
ordered them from Italy and I borrowed some. Count Mattei is the
founder of this. I read a couple of books by this group long back. I
got the following from a Google search. I remember this being
correct.
Electro Homoeopathy
1. Invented by Count Ceasre Mattei of Italy in 1865. 12. Basic
Principle 'Complexa Complexis Curantur'3. Treatment of diseases is
based on Temperaments. 4. Medicines extracted from medicinal plants
only.
5. There are only 60 medicines..
6. Compound medicines are used. 7. Lymph and Blood are purified
8. Electro Homoeopathy is related with Od Force. 9. Some of the
medicines are used according to Law of Polarity. . .
I think JW must be talking about something else - something related
to Dowsing machines.
Nothing could be more different than Homeopathy and Electro
homeopathy.

I am not sure about CLASSICAL homeopathy though. Anything could be
CLASSICAL after a couple of successful seminars
@yahoogroups.com, Julian Winston wrote:
matching
psychotronic
the

>Electro Homeopathy is something that came out of Italy I think and

Ah, yes. The work of Mattei...
I am talking about what was originally called Electro Acupuncture by
Voll (EAV) and these machines have been coming thick and fast since
Voll's first one which I think was called the "Dermatron".
There are a number of practitioners who call themselves "homeopaths"
who use these machines. There is a whole clinic in Nevada that uses
them for all their work.
certainly from your description
Very funny!!

JW

In einer eMail vom 13.07.04 10:25:07 (MEZ) - Mitteleurop. Sommerzeit schreibt
jwinston@actrix.gen.nz:

>
13.7.4.
Well, this is like chalk and cheese. Let us not mix apples and pears.
Kind regards, Dr.medic.Viorel V. Bucur (www.dr-bucur.com).