Minutus

Find some solution of this statement from your standard text book of
homeopathy.

Julian Winston said "A single dose of x-ray in 30 potency produce symptoms"

You all know that the x-ray in 30 potency can also cure the same symtpoms
which were observed during the x-ray 30 proving / trials.

If x-ray 30 in potency form produce symptoms then how can the same x-ray 30
potency will recognize that in patient it does not has to produce the new
symptoms rather to cure the symptoms and in healthy individual it has only
to produce new symtpoms and not to cure some old symptoms.

How can it be possible, x-ray 30 potency can differentiate between a healthy
and sick person. In healthy person it will produce the symptom and in sick
it will subside the symptom.

Does x-ray 30 has any kind of radar system. Does X-ray 30 can recognize
between a healthy and sick person?

Further how can you ensure that in sick x-ray 30 when will subside the
symptoms will not prodcue any other new symptoms.? When at the same time you
also say wrongly selected homeopathic potencies can also produce symptoms.
Then what is similia principle?

Homeo Bond 007
In search of Homeopathy

_________________________________________________________________
Chat via SMS. Simply send 'CHAT' to 1889918. More info at
http://ninemsn.com.au/mobilemania/MoCha ... lipid=6800

The x-ray 30 potency doesn't need to differentiate - it is the vital force
which does that - time for you to read some standard books on homeopathy?

Joy Lucas

www.homeopathicmateriamedica.com
on 10/11/03 7:13 PM, Homeo Bond 007 at homeobond007@hotmail.com wrote:

Find some solution of this statement from your standard text book of
homeopathy.

Julian Winston said "A single dose of x-ray in 30 potency produce symptoms"

You all know that the x-ray in 30 potency can also cure the same symtpoms
which were observed during the x-ray 30 proving / trials.

If x-ray 30 in potency form produce symptoms then how can the same x-ray 30
potency will recognize that in patient it does not has to produce the new
symptoms rather to cure the symptoms and in healthy individual it has only
to produce new symtpoms and not to cure some old symptoms.

How can it be possible, x-ray 30 potency can differentiate between a healthy
and sick person. In healthy person it will produce the symptom and in sick
it will subside the symptom.

Does x-ray 30 has any kind of radar system. Does X-ray 30 can recognize
between a healthy and sick person?

Further how can you ensure that in sick x-ray 30 when will subside the
symptoms will not prodcue any other new symptoms.? When at the same time you
also say wrongly selected homeopathic potencies can also produce symptoms.
Then what is similia principle?

Homeo Bond 007
In search of Homeopathy
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

At 6:13 PM +0000 10/11/03, Homeo Bond 007 wrote:

[snip]
Once again, you show that you have NO IDEA of what homeopathy is about.

READ THE ORGANON!!!!!!!!!

That is the "standard textbook" that explains what you ask.

If you cannot understand this, then as Kent said in a lecture about a
"physician in this city" (Journal of Homeopathics, 1890) "Is there
no saving a man who will not save himself? Echo answers, 'no saving!'"

JW

LET ME GET THIS RIGHT ......
30

You are asking why the remedy produces symptoms in a healthy patient and
cures them in a sick person ??????

And I expect an answer, as you often post and then don't take part in any
further discussion. I will continue to post this to you privately, if so,
until you answer.

Paul Booyse

Hi HomeoBond,

What you're asking is simply the basics of homeopathy, what it is and how it
works. These same things are true of *any* remedy -- what it can produce in
a healthy person -- *if* the susceptibility and circumstances are
appropriate -- it can cure in a person who suffers from those same symptoms
-- *if* the rest of the patient's case provides appropriate context for the
remedy to work in.

There are many books available that describe homeopathy and how it works.
Let us know if you would like suggestions.

Best wishes,
Shannon
on 10/11/03 1:13 PM, Homeo Bond 007 at homeobond007@hotmail.com wrote:

Hi Paul,

Good luck!!!
He's told us (or was it on a different list? I forget...) that "he" is
actually "they", and he/they do not usually (bother to) answer posts, only
to generate them.

Talking to my dog is more rewarding; at least she wags her tail for me!
(Plus, she actually understands a lot of what I say, which HB does not seem
to.)

Cheers to us all!

Shannon
on 10/11/03 3:20 PM, Paul Booyse at pb000014@pixie.co.za wrote:

Hello Shannon,
I know, I remember the previous postings. The point is, even if a person is
a complete newbie, and asks a genuine question like this, I would have time
for it. But 007 refuses to answer posts, so there is no discussion, just
replies to 007, but nothing in return. I find this discourteous and in fact
malicious. Not to mention that we start getting cross postings to this list
and others. Usually I just delete, but this one has really peeved me off.

In view of the fact that 007 only generates posts and doesn't reply, there
can be no discussion and as this is a discussion list I would like to call
for 007's (at least the email address) removal from this list - please
Ardavan ? Any seconds ?

Regards,
Paul

At 1:36 AM +0200 10/12/03, Paul Booyse wrote:

I'll second that.
The only thing I get from his posts is abysmal ignorance about homeopathy.

Since this is a Discussion list, and he refuses to DISCUSS, then his
presence is an annoyance.

JW

>LET ME GET THIS RIGHT ......
****************************************************************

Dear Paul Booysee
I do not participate in discussion. The reason is you people hate me. You
people have the wrong opinion that we should only tackle 007 posts just by
ignoring them. I have no objection. I think by ignoring the posts you also
give more direction and depth and I send the same posts in non-homeopathic
forum for finding the answers with the comments that homeopaths also have no
answers to these questions.

Mostly I am not interested in reply as I think you people have no answers of
my questions. These questions, I collect from 400 different forums and then
post them with my own name so that any body may not have any objection.

Second reason of not replying the posts is most of the questions are in the
form of informations for homeopaths. So that they can see their own face in
the mirror , what they use to say in discussion forum and what they actually
do in practice.

I read all posts throughly and ask those questions which stand un - answered
so if you do not reply to my posts (which are actually your own posts) then
it is actually you are not replying to your own posts.

I request to all members, I am not against homeopathy. I am in this field
for the last 20 years or so. But I do have thousand and thousand of queries
which is yet to be answered. These are very beneficial for the study purpose
and not for teasing. But when people call my bad names and reply in
humourous manner, then I come to know what is the status of a person in
homeopathy and where that person is stand?

I will try to reply to your posts. Go a head.
Homeo Bond 007

_________________________________________________________________
Hot chart ringtones and polyphonics. Go to
http://ninemsn.com.au/mobilemania/default.asp

***************************************************************

O.K first response

you said "You are asking why the remedy produces symptoms in a healthy
patient and
You used the word "healthy patient" in your statement? first teach me what
is healthy patient?

007

_________________________________________________________________
Chat via SMS. Simply send 'CHAT' to 1889918. More info at
http://ninemsn.com.au/mobilemania/MoCha ... lipid=6800