Page 1 of 1

Help with case please

Posted: Fri Jan 17, 2003 12:33 am
by Wendy Howard
I have a case which I'd appreciate some input on as the picture is quite
distinctive but I've not had much success so far in finding a good enough
reflection of it in the literature. (I have the patient's permission to post
this.)

The patient's life is completely dominated by seizures. She's extremely slow
on waking -- can't talk, can't open her eyes. On a good day she can muster
just enough energy to shower and dress herself but grinds to a complete halt
after that. Medication gets her going just enough to enjoy a reasonable
period before lunch, but following lunch she goes into seizure for a good
3-4 hours, gets a brief respite around 4.30-5.00pm, then continues
throughout the evening. At night it can be even worse though sleeping
tablets give relief.

The seizures are very characteristic. The torso goes rigid and leans
backward. There is no arching as the back is rigidly straight (though the
head draws back slightly). In the days when she could stand, this was
clearly evident. Now she has to lie down so the head gets drawn back to a
greater extent instead. Her eyes are either closed or staring at the
ceiling. She remains fully conscious throughout but can't speak or otherwise
communicate. When she could stand, standing helped -- she used to hang onto
a secure handrail and literally dance about it -- and if she could walk that
was even better and would sometimes abort an attack. That's now impossible.
When she gets warning of an impending seizure she goes to lie down as
otherwise she will fall. As mentioned, the torso goes rigid, as do the left
arm and leg which are fully extended. The fingers are extended while the
toes are curled up. She gets bad cramps in the legs and toes while this is
happening. The right leg is drawn up to the body (this happened even in the
days when she could stand) and the right arm moves violently from the elbow
as if she were karate-chopping something repeatedly. If anyone tries to hold
her arm to stop the movement, they can't. The seizures are extremely violent
and exhausting and she's become quite emaciated. She gets a lot of hot
flushes during all this.

Even in her good moments, she has a tendency to slip into this posture --
her torso goes rigid, the right leg bends and the left leg extends -- and
she's constantly slipping down in her chair as a result. Her symptoms are
generally worse when lying down.

While this overall pattern is pretty consistent, the day-to-day occurences
of seizures and their quality and duration is variable and unpredictable.
The condition has been developing over about 20 years. It started with
migraine headaches < mornings. Then, following a car accident where she was
shunted from behind, she noticed weakness in the fingers of the right hand.

There is a mental picture to go with this, but it's the seizures I'm trying
to pin down at the moment so if anyone recognises their precise character in
a remedy, I'd be very happy to hear about it.

Regards
Wendy

Re: Help with case please

Posted: Fri Jan 17, 2003 12:39 am
by Rochelle


What aura does she get as I find that this can be useful in differentiating
between remedies. Personally I would go for the mental and emotional picture
and as long as seizures are in the remedy I wouldn't get too tied down by
details.
Regards
Rochelle
www.rochellemarsden.co.uk
---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.443 / Virus Database: 248 - Release Date: 10/01/03

Re: Help with case please

Posted: Fri Jan 17, 2003 11:06 am
by Wendy Howard
Rochelle wrote:
differentiating
picture

Yes, good point and one I'd already noted to ask her when I see her today.
Thanks.

As for concentrating on the mental/emotional picture, I've found that often
leads to the prescription of too many similars and not enough simillimums --
I prefer to make sure that all aspects of the case match the remedy if
possible, and physical symptoms tend to be less open to misinterpretation.

Regards
Wendy

Re: Help with case please

Posted: Fri Jan 17, 2003 8:51 pm
by Phosphor
distinctive.
is there any medical diagnosis?

andrew

Re: Help with case please

Posted: Sat Jan 18, 2003 1:12 am
by Wendy Howard
> >I have a case which I'd appreciate some input on as the >picture is quite

Andrew wrote:

Yes, but it's not particularly helpful and could even be misleading. It was
made 3 years after the accident without any thorough investigation in the
way of tests, and the patient's own insistence about the aetiology (from the
accident) was dismissed by the specialist. The early unilateral
manifestation contraindicates the diagnosis. Her picture has some common
symptoms, but is not a typical picture of the condition. If the diagnosis is
valid, then she's right on the edge of the envelope.

I deliberately excluded it from my post for these reasons. I've spoken to
her GP who agrees it's questionable and there may be some possibility of a
reassessment.

Regards
Wendy

Re: Help with case please

Posted: Sat Jan 18, 2003 9:05 pm
by Dale Moss
Wendy,

Have you considered Strychninum? That she's conscious throughout is striking, as is her degree of rigidity.

Cinnabar

Re: Help with case please

Posted: Sat Jan 18, 2003 11:35 pm
by Wendy Howard
Many thanks to everyone for your input. Many remedies I'd already
considered, and quite a few I hadn't. It's fascinating to see how different
minds assimilate and process the same data! I've filed all your suggestions
for reference and will let you know how she gets on.

Thanks again.

Regards
Wendy