Minutus

May I paste a post here

it is from a reply to someone else's question
on this topic

produces no response at
remedies --
say that *every*
enough observer,
first, if possible,
Hello all -
........
an
and
one

As I see it, *any* dose of *anything* will always affect the
VF -
*everything* affects us -
the VF is constantly and unceasingly balancing and
harmonizing and maintaining us in response and interaction
with the environment - inside and out - food, remedies,
drugs,
potencies, emotions, weather, events, and the whole
Schebaeng -

One dose of a potency will, too, have an affect on the VF -
it is only a *matter of degree* whether we consciously
become
aware of it, or not -
(of course this may be considered speculative, as it ( I )
cannot be proven or disproved ...
Yet, jumping ahead to Organon #63 - ( but without wanting to
really start a discussion on this ahead of time !! ) could
be interpreted confirmatively, even in light of Hahnemann
here referring to crude doses -

Asides - can anyone truly conceive of something affecting
the VF (taking a dose, or anything) without it affecting the
VF ... ???
how could it be that one dose would affect *not at all* but
then two doses would affect the VF ?!?

if there was truly *no* effect from the first dose, would
then the second dose not be quasi just another *first* dose
!!??!! without effect !!??
How could there ever be provings ?!?!?

Yes, sure, the artificial disease from a single dose is, in
most
cases/people, quite imperceptible or at least ever
so slight as to be negligible, yes - especially if the
dosing is not continued -
yet, might it not rather be only the 'crude-ness' of our
senses, the robustness of the human VF, and the lack of
observational astuteness that causes us ( no, not us
to make statements such as " ... it will have no effect ....
"
?!?

And yes, Hahnemann does state medicinal diseases to be more
difficult to cure than natural diseases -

These are some of the thoughts I always have in mind when I
hear of
people taking remedies indiscriminately ....
or making wishy-washy statements about
" ... the VF will 'recognize' the remedy it needs, and it
will simply dis-regard the ones that it doesn't need .....
"
and/ or people taking remedies long-term .....
and/ or mixed together ...
(

Who knows ...

best
peter quenter