Minutus

Hi Patricia,
Are you asking about possible interactions between an essential oil, and a homeopathic remedy? Or are you asking whether one might "prove" an essential oil?

Do you have a specific situation in mind, and if so, which oil and which remedy, or what happened?

Shannon

-------------------------------------------- On Tue, 12/27/16, ShannonECN shannonecn135@gmail.com [minutus] wrote: Subject: Re: [Minutus] essential oils vs remedies To: minutus@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, December 27, 2016, 5:25 AM Hi Patricia, Are you asking about possible interactions between an essential oil, and a homeopathic remedy? Or are you asking whether one might "prove" an essential oil? Do you have a specific situation in mind, and if so, which oil and which remedy, or what happened? Shannon On 12/26/16 8:22 PM, Patricia Adams patricia.adams@globetrotter.net [minutus] wrote: can using essential oils cause proving of the homeopathic remedy ( if not used to fit the whole person etc.) Patricia

Hi,
Well long story short, i see a lot about essential oils recently and people ( my friends and I are in our 60's so lotsa ailments etc lol,) talking about using this one and that one for a certain ailment- and how the oil helped that ailment and I keep suggesting (what about the "the whole person" remedy as in homeopathy and I get that "here she goes again " look. Unless that essential oil fits "the whole person" wouldn't the ailment just wander of to another body part?
Patricia

From: tony.mitchell@yahoo.com [minutus]
Sent: Tuesday, December 27, 2016 1:02 AM
To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Minutus] essential oils vs remedies
-------------------------------------------- On Tue, 12/27/16, ShannonECN shannonecn135@gmail.com [minutus] > wrote: Subject: Re: [Minutus] essential oils vs remedies To: minutus@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, December 27, 2016, 5:25 AM Hi Patricia, Are you asking about possible interactions between an essential oil, and a homeopathic remedy? Or are you asking whether one might "prove" an essential oil? Do you have a specific situation in mind, and if so, which oil and which remedy, or what happened? Shannon On 12/26/16 8:22 PM, Patricia Adams patricia.adams@globetrotter.net [minutus] wrote: can using essential oils cause proving of the homeopathic remedy ( if not used to fit the whole person etc.) Patricia

The question is, What needs to be cured?
Symptom management vs the total health of the person.
Symptom management may be all your friends are looking for.
Example: I went to a retreat and did some pilo type yoga. Ok, overdid it, strained some muscles. The group was into essential oils nf had a sore muscle blend. This was an arnica sore muscle condition and one dose would have eliminated the whole syndrome. I was curious about the oils and used them. They smelled great, pain was relieved and I slept well and woke with the same pains I used the oils for the nightbefore. One dose of arnica in the morning eliminated the problem completely and effectively.

Yes the oils eliminated the pain and stiffness for awhile, but they did not stimulate a repair in the body just a short term relief. When their influence ended the situation returned.

Arnica eliminated all of it as it reached deeper into the body
Stimulating the bodies reactive forces to actually stimulate a cure.

You took the path less traveled, you know the difference. They just do not care they are suppressing.

Maria
yep thanks this is a good example of what I am seeing ...confirms things etc
It would have been so easy to just use an oil instead of doing the "whole person " think- but it is not to be and yes we homeopathy ones know that
Sent: Saturday, December 31, 2016 5:40 PM
To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Minutus] essential oils vs remedies
The question is, What needs to be cured?
Symptom management vs the total health of the person.
Symptom management may be all your friends are looking for.
Example: I went to a retreat and did some pilo type yoga. Ok, overdid it, strained some muscles. The group was into essential oils nf had a sore muscle blend. This was an arnica sore muscle condition and one dose would have eliminated the whole syndrome. I was curious about the oils and used them. They smelled great, pain was relieved and I slept well and woke with the same pains I used the oils for the nightbefore. One dose of arnica in the morning eliminated the problem completely and effectively.

Yes the oils eliminated the pain and stiffness for awhile, but they did not stimulate a repair in the body just a short term relief. When their influence ended the situation returned.

Stimulating the bodies reactive forces to actually stimulate a cure.

You took the path less traveled, you know the difference. They just do not care they are suppressing.

Happy New Year to all of you !

Maria again I concur with you - essential oils are nice to use but do not use them with remedies - some remedies will be negated by essential oils. However both have a place in alternative health but as you said I have never seen HEALING by essential oils in the physical sense - now mentally I have seen improvements.

Gisela

classical Homeopath
For all newbie's listen to my show on Sundays 12pm on http://nissancomunications.com
________________________________

From: minutus@yahoogroups.com on behalf of Maria Bohle mtbohle@gmail.com [minutus]
Sent: Saturday, December 31, 2016 5:40 PM
To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Minutus] essential oils vs remedies
The question is, What needs to be cured?
Symptom management vs the total health of the person.
Symptom management may be all your friends are looking for.
Example: I went to a retreat and did some pilo type yoga. Ok, overdid it, strained some muscles. The group was into essential oils nf had a sore muscle blend. This was an arnica sore muscle condition and one dose would have eliminated the whole syndrome. I was curious about the oils and used them. They smelled great, pain was relieved and I slept well and woke with the same pains I used the oils for the nightbefore. One dose of arnica in the morning eliminated the problem completely and effectively.

Yes the oils eliminated the pain and stiffness for awhile, but they did not stimulate a repair in the body just a short term relief. When their influence ended the situation returned.

Arnica eliminated all of it as it reached deeper into the body
Stimulating the bodies reactive forces to actually stimulate a cure.

You took the path less traveled, you know the difference. They just do not care they are suppressing.

I have used EO orally (and that is a very dangerous and acrobatic way, don't try this at home...) to treat dangerous infections, especially chronic ones that did not respond to anything, either conventional or natural including homeopathy.

They are extremely neurotoxic that way, so anyone interested needs proper training...got it from French practitioners, but I have not heard from them in ages, and I do not wish to take the responsibility to explain "how to..." sorry...

Joe.
Dr. J. Rozencwajg, NMD.

"The greatest enemy of any science is a closed mind"

www.naturamedica.co.nz
________________________________