Minutus

Hart Matthews has sent you a link to a blog:

The NY Times reports on the homeopathic use of Ambien to wake people from persistent vegetative states.

Blog: Higher Health
Post: Ambien may be homeopathic to near-coma state
Link: http://higher-health.blogspot.com/2011/ ... -coma.html

--
Powered by Blogger
http://www.blogger.com/

Not sure if this is considered homeopathic until an Ambien remedy is made and proven.
My homeopath gave me Chromium 3X and I felt same effects as when using crude chromium picolinate.
If taking a crude substance and potentizing it is supposed to make it work better or replace the need for the crude form, then Calc Carb remedy should be suitable to replace calcium supplements, calcium fortification of milk, orange juice, etc. Does taking Calc Carb remedy effect calcium blood levels?
Susan

Hi Susan,

I invite you to actually read the blog post that you objected to. Had you taken the time to read those 11 sentences, you would have seen your question regarding potentization answered.

Regarding your larger questions, one could write a book in response. But it needs to be pointed out in the context of this international homeopathic forum, populated as it is by trained and experienced homeopaths, that it takes a certain level of chutzpah to argue these points when you don't understand what makes a prescription homeopathic.

Blessings,
Hart

--
Dynamis Homeopathic
www.TreatingPeopleNotDisease.com
higher-health.blogspot.com
TreatingPeople@gmail.com
919.286.7626

Theories are like patches on a coat, one day they just wear off.
- Tibetan saying

Hart,
I did reread your post, actually read first the NY Times article. It's an interesting idea but you shouldn't feel it is an argument to discuss it.
This forum may have experienced homeopaths but also many learning or honing their skills. I would have to relook at what makes a prescription homeopathic, and actually interested in doing so.
Some homeopaths here post info about current and upcoming cases to get feedback on treatment, some actually earn income from it.
As for the Ambien reversal, it's possible that there is a genetic predisposition where some may respond and some may not.
For example, cannabis sativa can produce catatonia in bipolar, but obviously millions of people smoke pot and don't become catatonic.
So the remedy cannabis sativa may help reverse a catatonic state, possibly mostly for those who have a genetic predisposition for bipolar.
A native NYC-er, I have plenty of chutzpah. It's one reason why NYC became the main destination for tourists, immigrants and homeopaths from around the world and within the USA who come here to do consultations.
Susan

Dear Susan
You asked: "makes a prescription homeopathic?"
Remedy supplied by a homeopathic pharmacy? NO!

Remedy selected on the basis of Symptom Similarity? May Be.

Right Potency ? Not on its own!
A remedy can only be deemed to have been 'homeopathic' after its actions on the patient have been analysed!

The patient is the only TEST and TESTER!

For the analysis of the patient's reactions PLEASE read the ORGANON!
Rgds

Soroush
From: minutus@yahoogroups.com [mailto:minutus@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of healthyinfo6@aol.com
Sent: 04 December 2011 20:05
To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Minutus] Re: Higher Health:Ambien may be homeopathic to near-coma state
Hart,
I did reread your post, actually read first the NY Times article. It's an interesting idea but you shouldn't feel it is an argument to discuss it.

This forum may have experienced homeopaths but also many learning or honing their skills. I would have to relook at what makes a prescription homeopathic, and actually interested in doing so.

Some homeopaths here post info about current and upcoming cases to get feedback on treatment, some actually earn income from it.
As for the Ambien reversal, it's possible that there is a genetic predisposition where some may respond and some may not.

For example, cannabis sativa can produce catatonia in bipolar, but obviously millions of people smoke pot and don't become catatonic.

So the remedy cannabis sativa may help reverse a catatonic state, possibly mostly for those who have a genetic predisposition for bipolar.
A native NYC-er, I have plenty of chutzpah. It's one reason why NYC became the main destination for tourists, immigrants and homeopaths from around the world and within the USA who come here to do consultations.
Susan