I notice a sharp decline in the number of posts here. Look at the statistics
2011 552 454 394 306 356 227 247 131
2010 654 677 819 667 642 405 410 421 423 749 394 804
2009 554 443 586 871 1474 1263 1945 895 671 577 1177 922
2008 804 496 561 594 465 539 726 735 979 591 554 595
2007 818 737 845 725 1447 896 572 551 603 1090 857 930
2006 407 553 731 758 821 622 548 628 620 639 938 369
2005 643 795 859 509 513 924 861 736 760 669 517 411
2004 708 748 1029 816 667 640 1009 871 621 722 919 561
2003 627 437 488 342 329 241 294 467 593 874 1005 741
2002 605 852 683 398 502 457 723 847 655 562 1107 691
2001 49 18 42 103 68 59 58 105 467 538 552 472
2000
Venkat
Postings
Re: Postings
I think that you will find that it is because it used to be a forum for classical homeopathy and then became a forum for what anyone felt like talking about. Classical Homeopaths and students really want to discuss Classical Homeopathy not everything that anyone fancies. Facebook is now the place where people do the serious talking that used to take place on here. It is very sad to see its decline. I can remember when I first came to this forum and it had the greats like David Little, Chris Gillen and Joy Lucas, to name but a few. I learnt so much about Hahnemann's methods from these generous people and I am extremely grateful for the time they dedicated to helping us. And I am still learning a lot from some of them, just not on here!
Kerry
2011 552 454 394 306 356 227 247 131
2010 654 677 819 667 642 405 410 421 423 749 394 804
2009 554 443 586 871 1474 1263 1945 895 671 577 1177 922
2008 804 496 561 594 465 539 726 735 979 591 554 595
2007 818 737 845 725 1447 896 572 551 603 1090 857 930
2006 407 553 731 758 821 622 548 628 620 639 938 369
2005 643 795 859 509 513 924 861 736 760 669 517 411
2004 708 748 1029 816 667 640 1009 871 621 722 919 561
2003 627 437 488 342 329 241 294 467 593 874 1005 741
2002 605 852 683 398 502 457 723 847 655 562 1107 691
2001 49 18 42 103 68 59 58 105 467 538 552 472
2000
Kerry
2011 552 454 394 306 356 227 247 131
2010 654 677 819 667 642 405 410 421 423 749 394 804
2009 554 443 586 871 1474 1263 1945 895 671 577 1177 922
2008 804 496 561 594 465 539 726 735 979 591 554 595
2007 818 737 845 725 1447 896 572 551 603 1090 857 930
2006 407 553 731 758 821 622 548 628 620 639 938 369
2005 643 795 859 509 513 924 861 736 760 669 517 411
2004 708 748 1029 816 667 640 1009 871 621 722 919 561
2003 627 437 488 342 329 241 294 467 593 874 1005 741
2002 605 852 683 398 502 457 723 847 655 562 1107 691
2001 49 18 42 103 68 59 58 105 467 538 552 472
2000
-
Soroush Ebrahimi
- Moderator
- Posts: 4510
- Joined: Thu Feb 07, 2002 11:00 pm
Re: Postings
Dear Kerry
I agree with you.
One thing that can be done is that I go back to posting Organon aphorisms and we then discuss each one before we go on to the next. If you (members) think this is a good idea please let me know.
Soroush
From: minutus@yahoogroups.com [mailto:minutus@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of kerry
Sent: 25 August 2011 16:07
To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Minutus] Postings
I think that you will find that it is because it used to be a forum for classical homeopathy and then became a forum for what anyone felt like talking about. Classical Homeopaths and students really want to discuss Classical Homeopathy not everything that anyone fancies. Facebook is now the place where people do the serious talking that used to take place on here. It is very sad to see its decline. I can remember when I first came to this forum and it had the greats like David Little, Chris Gillen and Joy Lucas, to name but a few. I learnt so much about Hahnemann's methods from these generous people and I am extremely grateful for the time they dedicated to helping us. And I am still learning a lot from some of them, just not on here!
Kerry
I notice a sharp decline in the number of posts here. Look at the statistics
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
2011
552
454
394
306
356
227
247
131
2010
654
677
819
667
642
405
410
421
423
749
394
804
2009
554
443
586
871
1474
1263
1945
895
671
577
1177
922
2008
804
496
561
594
465
539
726
735
979
591
554
595
2007
818
737
845
725
1447
896
572
551
603
1090
857
930
2006
407
553
731
758
821
622
548
628
620
639
938
369
2005
643
795
859
509
513
924
861
736
760
669
517
411
2004
708
748
1029
816
667
640
1009
871
621
722
919
561
2003
627
437
488
342
329
241
294
467
593
874
1005
741
2002
605
852
683
398
502
457
723
847
655
562
1107
691
2001
49
18
42
103
68
59
58
105
467
538
552
472
2000
86
15
17
24
Venkat
I agree with you.
One thing that can be done is that I go back to posting Organon aphorisms and we then discuss each one before we go on to the next. If you (members) think this is a good idea please let me know.
Soroush
From: minutus@yahoogroups.com [mailto:minutus@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of kerry
Sent: 25 August 2011 16:07
To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Minutus] Postings
I think that you will find that it is because it used to be a forum for classical homeopathy and then became a forum for what anyone felt like talking about. Classical Homeopaths and students really want to discuss Classical Homeopathy not everything that anyone fancies. Facebook is now the place where people do the serious talking that used to take place on here. It is very sad to see its decline. I can remember when I first came to this forum and it had the greats like David Little, Chris Gillen and Joy Lucas, to name but a few. I learnt so much about Hahnemann's methods from these generous people and I am extremely grateful for the time they dedicated to helping us. And I am still learning a lot from some of them, just not on here!
Kerry
I notice a sharp decline in the number of posts here. Look at the statistics
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
2011
552
454
394
306
356
227
247
131
2010
654
677
819
667
642
405
410
421
423
749
394
804
2009
554
443
586
871
1474
1263
1945
895
671
577
1177
922
2008
804
496
561
594
465
539
726
735
979
591
554
595
2007
818
737
845
725
1447
896
572
551
603
1090
857
930
2006
407
553
731
758
821
622
548
628
620
639
938
369
2005
643
795
859
509
513
924
861
736
760
669
517
411
2004
708
748
1029
816
667
640
1009
871
621
722
919
561
2003
627
437
488
342
329
241
294
467
593
874
1005
741
2002
605
852
683
398
502
457
723
847
655
562
1107
691
2001
49
18
42
103
68
59
58
105
467
538
552
472
2000
86
15
17
24
Venkat
Re: Postings
I am all for posting Organon aphorisms
My feeling is that I can get a lot of non classical homeopathy info. in many different places but having a place to ground my classical homeopathic training would be beneficial for me.
blessings,
Lora Roberts
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
2011
552
454
394
306
356
227
247
131
2010
654
677
819
667
642
405
410
421
423
749
394
804
2009
554
443
586
871
1474
1263
1945
895
671
577
1177
922
2008
804
496
561
594
465
539
726
735
979
591
554
595
2007
818
737
845
725
1447
896
572
551
603
1090
857
930
2006
407
553
731
758
821
622
548
628
620
639
938
369
2005
643
795
859
509
513
924
861
736
760
669
517
411
2004
708
748
1029
816
667
640
1009
871
621
722
919
561
2003
627
437
488
342
329
241
294
467
593
874
1005
741
2002
605
852
683
398
502
457
723
847
655
562
1107
691
2001
49
18
42
103
68
59
58
105
467
538
552
472
2000
86
15
17
24
My feeling is that I can get a lot of non classical homeopathy info. in many different places but having a place to ground my classical homeopathic training would be beneficial for me.
blessings,
Lora Roberts
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
2011
552
454
394
306
356
227
247
131
2010
654
677
819
667
642
405
410
421
423
749
394
804
2009
554
443
586
871
1474
1263
1945
895
671
577
1177
922
2008
804
496
561
594
465
539
726
735
979
591
554
595
2007
818
737
845
725
1447
896
572
551
603
1090
857
930
2006
407
553
731
758
821
622
548
628
620
639
938
369
2005
643
795
859
509
513
924
861
736
760
669
517
411
2004
708
748
1029
816
667
640
1009
871
621
722
919
561
2003
627
437
488
342
329
241
294
467
593
874
1005
741
2002
605
852
683
398
502
457
723
847
655
562
1107
691
2001
49
18
42
103
68
59
58
105
467
538
552
472
2000
86
15
17
24
Re: Postings
Dear Soroush
I think that problem now is that most of the Classical Homs that gave great input are no longer on this list, so a lot of those that could give the best guidance are gone.
Kerry
I think that problem now is that most of the Classical Homs that gave great input are no longer on this list, so a lot of those that could give the best guidance are gone.
Kerry
-
Soroush Ebrahimi
- Moderator
- Posts: 4510
- Joined: Thu Feb 07, 2002 11:00 pm
Re: Postings
Have you any suggestions?
So do we jump in quickly (as used to happen before) and say "That is not 'Hahnemannian' homeopathy."?
TNX
Soroush
From: minutus@yahoogroups.com [mailto:minutus@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of kerry
Sent: 25 August 2011 16:59
To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Minutus] Postings
Dear Soroush
I think that problem now is that most of the Classical Homs that gave great input are no longer on this list, so a lot of those that could give the best guidance are gone.
Kerry
Dear Kerry
I agree with you.
One thing that can be done is that I go back to posting Organon aphorisms and we then discuss each one before we go on to the next. If you (members) think this is a good idea please let me know.
Soroush
So do we jump in quickly (as used to happen before) and say "That is not 'Hahnemannian' homeopathy."?
TNX
Soroush
From: minutus@yahoogroups.com [mailto:minutus@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of kerry
Sent: 25 August 2011 16:59
To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Minutus] Postings
Dear Soroush
I think that problem now is that most of the Classical Homs that gave great input are no longer on this list, so a lot of those that could give the best guidance are gone.
Kerry
Dear Kerry
I agree with you.
One thing that can be done is that I go back to posting Organon aphorisms and we then discuss each one before we go on to the next. If you (members) think this is a good idea please let me know.
Soroush
Re: Postings
My personal opinion is that a list dedicated to Hahnemann's methods should uphold Hahnemann's methods. If someone feels that it isn't true to Hahnemann's teaching, and they wish to point that out, then they should explain why it isn't and what they consider to be the alternative. Hopefully they will do that in a pleasant manner that helps students to understand rather than alienates people. I can understand though how many Classical Homeopaths totally lost patience, because it was the same members, again and again, trying to promote methods that weren't Classical in anyway.
Perhaps one way would be for the moderators to invite Classical homeopaths back, on the promise that the list will be well moderated and that non Classical Homeopathy discussion will not be tolerated or encouraged. There are lots of lists and groups out there for political views, vaccination, polypharmacy, etc and it seems extremely sad that this list has become just another one of those lists, especially when it had such a good reputation some years ago.
Kerry
Perhaps one way would be for the moderators to invite Classical homeopaths back, on the promise that the list will be well moderated and that non Classical Homeopathy discussion will not be tolerated or encouraged. There are lots of lists and groups out there for political views, vaccination, polypharmacy, etc and it seems extremely sad that this list has become just another one of those lists, especially when it had such a good reputation some years ago.
Kerry
Re: Postings
--- In minutus@yahoogroups.com, kerry wrote:
Hi Kerry,
Yes, I miss them too.
Joy and Ardavan are on World Homeopathic Community.
Leilanae
---------------------------------------------
Hi Kerry,
Yes, I miss them too.
Joy and Ardavan are on World Homeopathic Community.
Leilanae
---------------------------------------------
Re: Postings
How can an explanation of anything not "Classical" be considered Promotion ? Anyone with an explanation that doesn't fit into the "Classical" model gets fried, beaten and eaten. I for one am glad that some people have left, nasty derisive posts are not good for homeopathy, Classical or otherwise. Everything has a cycle, whether we are talking about list serves, or something else, this is just part of the cycle. I learned a lot when this group was originally formed, but in the last 3 years not so much learned homeopathy as the art and use of sarcasm and nasty comments. Sad really, but maybe it is time for Minutus to die the way Lyghtforce apparently did.
Now just watch. Rik will have to say something exceptionally nasty, since it seems whenever I post he must have his say.
Sue
Now just watch. Rik will have to say something exceptionally nasty, since it seems whenever I post he must have his say.
Sue
Re: Postings
Hi Leilanae
Joy also has a great group on Facebook for studying remedies, working cases, studying the Organon, etc.
And Roger van Zandvoort also has a great group were the Complete Rep is used to work a case a day: a great way of getting to grips with different rubrics and ways of looking at cases.
Kerry
Joy also has a great group on Facebook for studying remedies, working cases, studying the Organon, etc.
And Roger van Zandvoort also has a great group were the Complete Rep is used to work a case a day: a great way of getting to grips with different rubrics and ways of looking at cases.
Kerry