Minutus

Hi,

Lynn C. gave me a great site for comparing miasms.
http://homeoint.org/articles/miasms/indexen.htm I am not so familiar
with the authors. I am trying to figure out where homeopaths agree
about miasm identities of remedies. I really like Banerjea's way of
giving percents of various miasms, but he is not necessarily backed by
everyone. Besides added categories, I wish I knew more about the
source of disagreement aside from vague differences of clinical
experience.

Some of the vocabulary is foreign. I tried Radar 10 with no results.

UNKNOWN VOCABULARY
Under Grimmer there is a miasm called Kanz. Never heard of that.
Cancer in German? Under Ritcher there is Vak. The EH has this listed
as vak-sin-e-ah, cow pox. Ritcher has Gicht. Couldn't find that.

LAST COLUMN
I wish there were some instructions on how to read the chart. Then
letters and numbers in the last column must mean something.
If anyone has a clue, I would appreciate your insight.

Best,
Ellen

Guide

The last column may give you an idea about the agreement between the authors. The number of authors who classified the remedy is on the far right. The classifications are as follows : p means psoric (psor.), k sycotic (syk.), and f syphilitic (syph.).

Hi,
That's very helpful. I found the guide by pressing the language
button (English).
Best,
Ellen

here's another version of the chart
http://85.195.74.125/miasmen/miasmen.php?lang=en

which includes Tub and Canc Miasm
it's color coded and a little easier to read
it does not have Kanz under Grimmer's column

you wrote:

Some of the vocabulary is foreign. I tried Radar 10 with no results.

UNKNOWN VOCABULARY
Under Grimmer there is a miasm called Kanz. Never heard of that.
Cancer in German? Under Ritcher there is Vak. The EH has this listed
as vak-sin-e-ah, cow pox. Ritcher has Gicht. Couldn't find that.

LAST COLUMN
I wish there were some instructions on how to read the chart. Then
letters and numbers in the last column must mean something.
If anyone has a clue, I would appreciate your insight.

Best,
Ellen
Imagine Peace