Minutus

Dear Colleagues

Teenager patient is sad and listens to sad music which calms him down.

Apart from MANGANUM-ACT (MANG) is there another remedy with this symptom pls?
Regards

Soroush

Hi Soroush,
That's a really interesting symptom because manganese is so important for the ears.
Can't find any other remedies listed for it - it would make sense if some of the plant remedies that are high in manganese also had this symptom - I know of Arnica and Ledum, but not of others - maybe if anyone has Scholten's book on the mineral analysis of the plants they could suggest others.
Apart from that maybe just generalise to expand it:
Combined, Mind; MUSIC, amel, am-m[1], androc[1], anh[1], aur[3], aur-m[1], cann-s[1], carc[1], croc[1], hydrog[1], mang[1], nat-m[1], posit[1], sul-ac[1], sumb[1], tarent[3], thuj[2], tub[1]

Combined, Mind; SENSITIVE, music, to, acon[2], aloe[1], ambr[2], anac[1], androc[1], bry[1], bufo[1], cact[1], calc[2], carb-an[1], carc[2], caust[1], cham[2], choc[1], coff[1], cop[1], croc[2], cupr[1], dig[1], falco-p[1], graph[2], ign[2], kreos[2], lyc[2], merc[1], nat-c[3], nat-m[2], nat-p[1], nat-s[2], nux-v[3], pall[1], ph-ac[2], phos[1], puls[1], sabin[2], sep[3], stann[1], sulph[1], tab[2], tarent[2], thuj[1], tub-k[1], viol-o[1], zinc[1], zinc-p[1]

Would be curious to know if the teenager fits the general manganum picture.
Gail.
________________________________

To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
From: finrod@finrod.co.uk
Date: Mon, 28 Jul 2008 07:51:40 +0100
Subject: [Minutus] Sadness & Music
Dear Colleagues
Teenager patient is sad and listens to sad music which calms him down.
Apart from MANGANUM-ACT (MANG) is there another remedy with this symptom pls?

Regards
Soroush
________________________________

Click here. Want to help Windows Live Messenger plant more Aussie trees?

Hi Soroush & everyone,

This is my first post to this group which I have been following for
some months now. Have learnt a lot from you all. Thanks.

My Radar program has the following rubric:

MIND - MUSIC - desire for sad music (1) nat-c

Regards,

Gill

found this rubric that includes mang but 3 others as well
tanya

MIND - MUSIC - desire for - sad music

bung-fa.mtf mang.ptk1 nat-c.mrr1 ozonesde2

MIND - SADNESS - music - amel. - sad music amel.

mang.a1,k,ptk1
________________________________
________________________________

my radar has 4 remedies under this rubric

MIND - MUSIC - desire for - sad music

bung-fa.mtf mang.ptk1 nat-c.mrr1 ozonesde2

With thanks - does any one have the MM for Bung-fa please?

________________________________

From: minutus@yahoogroups.com [mailto:minutus@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of tamarque@earthlink.net
Sent: 28 July 2008 12:26
To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: RE: [Minutus] Sadness & Music
my radar has 4 remedies under this rubric

MIND - MUSIC - desire for - sad music

bung-fa.mtf mang.ptk1 nat-c.mrr1 ozonesde2
No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG - http://www.avg.com
Version: 8.0.138 / Virus Database: 270.5.6/1576 - Release Date: 7/27/2008 4:16 PM

This is all I have from the Reversed Combined Repertory in Isis. Radar must have more.
Bungaris fasciatus (Bung) 1 rubric.

Paralysis, poliomyelitis.

And there is a picture - The branded Krait snake - a snake with what looks like large yellow and black horizontal stripes. They suggest the Miasm to be Syphilitic.
Gail.
________________________________

To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
From: finrod@finrod.co.uk
Date: Mon, 28 Jul 2008 12:34:57 +0100
Subject: RE: [Minutus] Sadness & Music
With thanks - does any one have the MM for Bung-fa please?

________________________________
If you do not wish to receive individual emails, you can simply change your setting at http://www.yahoogroups.com/group/minutus to receive a single daily digest.

Change settings via the Web (Yahoo! ID required)
Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily Digest | Switch format to Traditional
Visit Your Group | Yahoo! Groups Terms of Use | Unsubscribe
Recent Activity

*

Visit Your Group
Meditation and

Lovingkindness
A Yahoo! Group
to share and learn.

Yahoo! Health
Achy Joint?
Common arthritis
myths debunked.

Moderator Central
Yahoo! Groups
Get the latest news
from the team.

.

________________________________

Find out: SEEK Salary Centre Are you paid what you're worth?

soroush
here are a few symptoms of bung-fa. i don't know if it is my computor or the radar program
but i cant seem to get the sx copied easily or in a usable way. maybe somebody can let
me know how to do this with radar 9
tanya
DREAMS - EXPOSING - husband is exposing his genitals
DREAMS - EXPOSING - husband is exposing his genitals
DREAMS - FRIENDS
DREAMS - HANDS - losing control over her hands
DREAMS - HELPING - friends; his
DREAMS - HOUSE - old
DREAMS - LAUGHED AT; being
DREAMS - MEMORY - weakness of memory - person with whom she is talking on the phone; does not recollect knowing the
DREAMS - MEN - huge and strong man; a
DREAMS - MEN - huge and strong man; a - controlling her; was
DREAMS - MENSES - having her menses
DREAMS - NAKED people - husband; her
DREAMS - NAKED people - husband; her - caressed at the genitals by a lady doctor; being
DREAMS - NEGLECTED being
DREAMS - PRAYING
DREAMS - PROTECTED; being - not being protected from harm
DREAMS - ROMANTIC
DREAMS - SEDUCING - exposing thighs and breasts; by
DREAMS - SUGGESTIONS; giving - passenger; to the other
DREAMS - THROWING - things - anger; from
DREAMS - WEDDING - cousin is getting married
DREAMS -

GENERALS - FOOD and DRINKS - cheese - desire

acon-ac.rly4 adam.srj5 aeth.vh,mtf33 arg-n.mrr1,k,bg2,tl1 arizon-l.nl2 aster.vml3,gsw1,k,tl1 bamb-a.stb2.de bung-fa.mtf calc-p.mg1.de,bt3 calc.vh,mtf33,mrr1 carc.mlr1,fd2.de caust.vh,mrr1,mtf33 Chel.mrr1,vh chir-fl.gya2 Cist.tl1,mrr1,k coll.ld1.de,vml3 dendr-pol.sk4 fuma-ac.rly4 gaert.vh,fmm1,pte1,vml3 galeoc-c-h.gms1 ham.fd3.de hera.vml3 hyos.vh ign.tl1,b2.de,mtf33,mrr1,b7.de,gsw1,k kali-c.zf lyc.dgt mag-m.dgt mand.mg1.de,jl,sp1 med.vh medul-os-si.rly4 mosch.mrr1,tl1,k musca-d.szs1 nat-m.ser nat-sil.fd3.de nicotam.rly4 Nit-ac.vh,mrr1 olib-sac.wmh1 Phos.mrr1,mtf33,vh Plut-n.srj7 podo.fd3.de pot-e.rly4 puls.mtf33,k,tl1,mrr1 rhus-g.tmo3 rhus-t.mrr1,vh ribo.rly4 sep.sf1.de,bg2,bt3 stront-c.sk4 syc.fmm1,pte1,ptj1,vml3,bka1 tub.hu

GENERALS - FOOD and DRINKS - cold drink, cold water - desire - small quantities

bung-fa.mtf

GENERALS - FOOD and DRINKS - ice cream - desire

aids.nl2 amp.rly4 anthraq.rly4 arg-n.mrr1,k2,bt3,sne bit-ar.wht1 Bung-fa.mtf calc-p.mrr1 Calc.mtf33,k carc.mlr1,vh,dx1,fb,gk6 carneg-g.rwt1 Cuc-c.vml3 dendr-pol.sk4 dream-p.sdj1 elapsvh Eup-per.mrr1,k,gsw1 germ-met.srj5 helodr-cal.knl2 Kolastb3 lac-del.hrn2 loxo-recl.knl4 mang-p.rly4 Med.st nat-p.mrr1 nat-s.vh nat-sil.fd3.de nept-m.lsd2.fr orot-ac.vml3 PHOS.k,mrr1,mtf33 podo.fd3.de puls.k2,mrr1,mtf33,vh rad-br.bt3,c1 Sil.mtf33,st,bt3,k2 suis-em.rly4 Sulph.mrr1 suprar.rly4 tama.vml3 tub.mrr1,k,mtf33 verat.mtf33,k

GENERALS - FOOD and DRINKS - tea - desire

abrom-a.vml3,ks5 alum.bt3,bro1 aster.gsw1,k,vml3 bung-fa.mtf calc-s.gsw1,k Casc.kr1 chen-a.c1 Chin.gl1.fr,gl3,mtf33,st,bt3 coca-c.sk4 des-ac.rbp6 galeoc-c-h.gms1 ham.fd3.de hep.sne,k,bg2 hydr.k,gsw1 kali-p.fd1.de kolastb3 lac-h.sk4 lavand-a.ctl1 lepi.a1 lunakg1 lyss.al2 musavml3 nat-m.sne nat-sil.fd3.de nux-v.bt3,gl1.fr,gl3,st olib-sac.wmh1 plac-s.rly4 podo.fd3.de positr.nl2 Puls.vh,st,bt3 pyrusgsw1,k rhus-g.tmo3 Sacch.sst1,sht,vml3 sel.sf1.de,bt3,bg2 sep.vh,kr1 staph.sne suis-em.rly4 thuj.st,bt3 uran-n.c1,kr1,vml3

GENERALS - FOOD and DRINKS - warm food - aversion

Alum-p.k2,vml3,bt3 Apisk2 bamb-a.stb2.de Bell.gsw1,k,mtf33 bov.vh,dx1 bung-fa.mtf Calc.k,ptk1,gsw1 cham.vh,dx1 chel.dx1,vh Chin.mrr1,k cupr-ar.vml3 cupr.b7.de,bg2,gsw1,k,sst3 ferr.vh,dx1 GRAPH.k,mtf33,gsw1 guare.vml3,k ham.fd3.de hydrog.srj,vml3 Ign.bg2,gsw1,k,mtf33,b7.de kali-s.vh,k2 Lach.gsw1,k Lyc.k,kr1,gsw1 mag-c.k,gsw1 mag-s.gsw1,k,vml3 Merc-c.vml3,k merc-cy.ld1.de merc.k,gsw1 nat-m.sne nat-sil.fd3.de Nux-v.b7.de,bg2,bt3 petr.k,gsw1 PHOS.k,mrr1 psor.k PULS.bg2,k,mrr1,b7.de sacch.sht,sst1,vml3 Sil.k,gsw1,kr1,mrr1,mtf33 Verat.bg2,gsw1,k,mtf33,b7.de zinc.k,gsw1

GENERALS - HUNGER - agg.

Alum.k Anac.sf1.de,bg2 ars-i.k2,k13 Aur.b2.de,bg2,k bar-c.sne brass-n-o.srj bung-fa.mtf Cact.k calc-f.mg1.de,jl3 canth.b7.de,bg2,b2.de,k Caust.bg2,hr1,k,b2.de chel.bg2,sf1.de,sne cinasf1.de,bg2 CROT-H.k,hr1 Crot-t.k ferr.k GRAPH.bg2,k,sf1.de,b2.de hell.b2.de,b7.de,bg2,k IOD.bg2,k,sf1.de,b2.de KALI-C.b4.de,bg2,b2.de,hr1,k,sf1.de lac-leo.sk4 lyc.sf1.de,mrr1,bg2 nat-m.sne olnd.b7.de,b2.de,k,sf1.de,bg2 ph-ac.sne Phos.sf1.de,bg2,k plat.bg2,k,b2.de,b4.de Psor.k Rhus-t.bg2,b7.de,b2.de,k sang.sne SIL.k,sf1.de,hr1,bg2 Spig.b7.de,k,b2.de,bg2 stann.k staph.sne,bg2,sf1.de SULPH.k valer.k verat.bg2,k,b7.de,b2.de Zinc.k

GENERALS - PARALYSIS - sensation of

bung-fa.mtf musca-d.szs1 phos.h2 Prim-o.br1 sang.hr1

GENERALS - POLIOMYELITIS

Acon.hr1,kr1,st1,bro1 aeth.bro1 alum.st1 arg-n.st1 arn.kr1,st1,hr1 ars.st1 bell.hr1,kr1,st1,bro1 bung-cd.br1 Bung-fa.bro1 Calc.bro1 carb-ac.st1 Caust.bro1,hr1,kr1,st1 chinin-ar.st chr-s.bro1 cur.st1 dulc.st1 ferr-i.st1 ferr-p.st1 GELS.hr1,bro1,kr1,st1 hydr-ac.st1 hydroph.mtf11,jl3 hyos.kr1,st1,hr1 kali-i.st1 kali-p.bro1,hr1,st1 karw-h.jl3 kres.mg1.de lach.st1 lath.bro1,mg1.de,st1 merc.kr1,mg1.de,hr1,st1 nux-v.hr1,kr1,st1,bro1 phos.st1,bro1 phys.st1,br1 plb-i.st1 Plb.st1,bro1 rhus-t.hr1,bro1,k13,k2,kr1,st1 sec.bro1,st1 stry-p.st1 sulph.hr1,kr1,st1,bro1 verat-v.st1 verat.st1 vip.br1

GENERALS - STRENGTH, sensation of

adam.srj5 Agar.br1,k,b2.de,bg2 alco.a1 anh.br1,mg1.de ars.sf1.de bell.a1 bit-ar.wht1 bov.a1 bry.a1 Bufok bung-fa.mtf calc-f.sp1 calc.b4.de,bg2 cann-xyz.bg2 carbn-o.a1 chinin-s.a1 choc.srj3 clem.a1 cob.a1 Cocasf1.de,a1 Coff.k,bg2,b2.de,b7.de coli.rly4 corn.a1 cot.a1 dendr-pol.sk4 elae.a1 erech.a1 ferr.a1 fic-m.gya1 Fl-ac.k gast.a1 gels.a1 germ-met.srj5 gins.a1 haliae-lc.srj5 ham.fd3.de helon.a1 hippoc-k.szs2 ignis-alc.es2 irid-met.srj5 kolastb3,sf1.de lac-cp.sk4 lach.sf1.de lil-t.a1 m-arct.b2.de,b7.de maias-l.hrn2 meny.a1 Nat-p.sf1.de nep.jl3,mg1.de,srb2.fr nept-m.lsd2.fr ol-j.a1 Olib-sac.wmh1 OP.bg2,k,b2.de,b7.de ped.a1 phos.a1,bg pic-ac.sf1.de pip-m.a1,sf1.de plat.a1 plb.bg2 plut-n.srj7 psil.vml3,ft1 psor.bg pycnop-sa.mrz1 sars.a1 sinus.rly4 stram.k,b2.de,b7.de,bg2 stront-c.sk4 symph.fd3.de temp.elm1 valer.bg2 vanad.jl3 wies.a1 zinc.sf1.de

EXTREMITIES - HEAT - Knee

aids.nl2 anac.bg2 ant-t.bg2 apisbg2 apoc-a.a1 apoc.k arg-met.bg2 Ars.bg2 arund.k,a1 Asaf.bg2 aur-m.k,a1 Bar-c.bg2 Bar-m.k brom.bg2 bry.k,a1,bg2 bung-fa.mtf calc.bg2 camph.k,a1 cann-xyz.bg2 Carb-v.bg2 CAUST.bg2 Chin.bg2 cinak,bg2,b7.de coc-c.k,a1 colch.k,a1 dros.bg2,b7.de hyos.k,a1 ign.k,a1,bg2,b7.de iod.bg2 kali-c.bg2,kl,h2 kali-n.bg2 Lach.k led.bg2 Lyc.k,bg2 meny.k,bg2,b7.de,a1 Merc.bg2 mur-ac.bg2 nat-c.bg2 nat-m.bg2 nat-sil.fd3.de nit-ac.bg2 NUX-V.bg2 ol-j.a1,k olnd.bg2 Petr.bg2 ph-ac.bg2 phos.bg2,b4.de,a1,k plat.bg2 Puls.bg2 RHUS-T.bg2 sabad.bg2 sal-fr.sle1 Sars.k Sep.bg2 spig.bg2 STANN.bg2 Staph.bg2 Stront-c.bg2 sul-ac.bg2 sulph.bg2,k,a1 TARAX.bg2 thuj.bg2 ven-m.rsj12 verat.a1,k,bg2 zinc.bg2

EXTREMITIES - PAIN - Knee - left

apishtj1,bg1 asc-t.a1 aster.k bac.jl2 Bamb-a.stb2.de bapt.k benz-ac.k berb.mrr1,dgt1 brom.k bung-fa.mtf carb-ac.k caul.a1 chin.k chir-fl.gya2 des-ac.rbp6 diaz.sa3 fic-m.gya1 flor-p.rsj3 gard-j.vlr2 ham.fd3.de helia.ptk2 kalm.k kolastb3 lac-h.htj1 lac-lup.hrn2 luf-op.rsj5 nat-sil.fd3.de oci-sa.sk4 olib-sac.wmh1 ozonesde2 pall.k Plat.k podo.fd3.de rhus-g.tmo3 samb.bat1 sel.rsj9 xan.c1

EXTREMITIES - PAIN - Knee - left - morning

bung-fa.mtf

EXTREMITIES - PAIN - Knee - left - night

bung-fa.mtf

EXTREMITIES - PAIN - Knee - left - Lateral side

bung-fa.mtf

EXTREMITIES - PAIN - Knee - bending, on

bung-fa.mtf canth.k malar.jl2 oci-sa.sk4 phys.k Spig.k stann.k

EXTREMITIES - PAIN - Knee - motion - beginning to move

bac.jl2 bung-fa.mtf calc.bg1 cassia-s.zzc1,ccrh1 Led.k Puls.k Rhus-t.k verat.k

EXTREMITIES - PAIN - Knee - pressure - amel.

acon-c.k ars.k atra-r.skp7,bnm3 bung-fa.mtf cassia-s.ccrh1 tarax.bro1

EXTREMITIES - PAIN - Knee - walking

ammc.k anac.k ant-t.k arg-n.k asaf.k asc-t.k aur-m-n.k Aur.k Berb.k Bry.k bung-fa.mtf Calc-p.k caps.k caust.k CHEL.k Cinnb.k cist.k clem.k Coloc.k cortico.tpw7 crot-h.k cycl.k dig.k dios.k dros.k euph.k flor-p.rsj3 form.k gard-j.vlr2 gels.k grat.k Guaj.k hydr.k irisk jac-g.k jatr-c.k kali-bi.k Kali-c.k Lac-ac.k Lach.k LED.k lil-t.k Mag-c.k Med.k merc-i-r.k merc-sul.c1 merc.k mez.k Mygal.k nat-c.k nat-m.k nat-s.k nit-ac.k petr.k phys.k plan.k podo.fd3.de positr.nl2 sal-fr.sle1 staph.k stront-c.k symph.fd3.de thuj.k verb.k vip.k

EXTREMITIES - PAIN - Ankle - walking - while

alumn.k ambr.h1 aster.k bit-ar.wht1 bry.k bung-fa.mtf calc-p.k carc.fd2.de caust.k chel.k cycl.k des-ac.rbp6 Dros.k erig.mtf11 fl-ac.k kali-n.k Kalm.k Led.k lith-c.k mez.k nit-ac.k Phos.k puls.k rhus-v.k rutak stront-c.k stry.k sulph.k

EXTREMITIES - PARALYSIS - sensation of - Hands

bung-fa.mtf

SLEEP - DISTURBED - night - midnight - after - 2 h

bung-fa.mtf

SLEEP - SLEEPINESS - sitting - room; in a warm

bung-fa.mtf ind.a1

SLEEP - WAKING - dryness of mouth; from

bung-fa.mtf

WEDDING - cousin is getting married - person she is divorcing from; to the
GENERALS - FOOD and DRINKS - butter - desire

Complete 2008, Mind;

music; amel.; sad: (94) , aur[1], mang[1], mang-acet[1], nat-m[1]
Rochelle

Registered Homeopath
EFT(Advanced) Practitioner
www.southporthomeopathy.co.uk