Luise, New poll

[F. Shaddel]

Dear Luise
Your comment included very important points which I agree with most of them but let me disagree you about below ponit:
"They will only serve to increase the in-fighting and cement the
differences between the homeopaths. One of those basic differences was
discussed not too long ago in connection with the articles by Anrde
Saine and the rather bitter fights between groups of prominent
homeopaths previous to these articles.

They will also increase and cement the differences between
prescribers of different methods of prescribing diluted/potentized
remedies."

I have a question. If one patient is being visited by 10 different Homeopaths and is receiving 10 different prescriptions with different doses because of diversity in Homeopthy methods, Do not you think only one of these prescription is the most suitable for this patient (Because we have only one simillimum and one proper dose) and another 9 practitioners (and maybe all of them) are wrong and maybe hurt the patient?
Do you really believe we have the right to allow 90% of practitioners hurt the patients (And accordingly Homeopathy) for our survival and we just colse our eyes on this big mismanagement? What kind of commiunity and unity is this?
I am a fan of Homeopathy but when I put myself in place of Health authorities, if I think your view is the majority view of Homeopathy circle, I will give my vote to stop practising such non scientific method (Which its practitioners even can not discuss with each other about correct method and prescriptions) for goodness of people health.
But I am sure the majority of Homeopaths believe to scientific discussions and trying to find the best method but we are in the beggining of this way and it will not be easy.
Regards
F. Shaddel
Associate Professor in Organon and Principles
Academic Registerar, Pioneer University
Education Affairs Director CTCH
Administrator to HMA, UK in Middle East
-----------------------------
CTCH Administration Office
Tel-Fax: +44-1235-519465
Email: director@ctchdubai.com
Website: www.ctchdubai.com
Correspondance: 3 Exeter Court, Oxford, OX11 8UH, UK
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

[Luise Kunkle]

Hi F.,

From the address below it seems you live in Dubai and have strong
connections to the UK, and probably to India.

Hoemeopaths in India and perhaps in Europe the UK (about Dubai I know
nothing) may be among the countries that are not in danger of having
their remedies banned. So you probably cannot understand what I am
talking about.

I, on the other hand, do not understand what such kind of competition
has to do with scientific endeavour.

Regards

Luise
--
One thought to all who, free of doubt,
So definitely know what's true:
2 and 2 is 22 -
and 2 times 2 is 2:-)
==========> ICQ yinyang 96391801 <==========