Minutus

Can anyone think of a rubric for someone who always speaks their mind?

Thanks
Rochelle
Registered Homeopath, EFT(Advanced)Practitioner
www.southporthomeopathy.co.uk

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Hi Rochelle,
There's "Truth, tells the plain: alum, bov, choc, ephe, falco-p, hyos,
verat"
But I'd be inclined to look more at the hows and whys. Is is simple
straightforwardness (in which case perhaps not even a symptom), or is
it aggressive, can't keep a secret", or or ??
Best,
Shannon
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

That's the one - Thanks Shannon. I couldn't think what it was!! In her case it's probably aggressiveness.!!

Cheers
Rochelle
Registered Homeopath, EFT(Advanced)Practitioner
www.southporthomeopathy.co.uk

Hi Rochelle,

Adding to Shannon's comments, but also a few remedies suggested by Refworks:

Speaks her mind (5): 3Apis, camph., falco-p., ruta, scut.

More distant possibilities -

Mind; OBJECTIVE, reasonable (p, 24) (24)
Mind; HONEST (p, 9) (9)
Mind; INJUSTICE, cannot support (p, 55, 1-20) (55)
Mind; INTEGRITY, sensation of (p, 4) (4)

regards, Barbara

--- In minutus@yahoogroups.com, Robert & Shannon Nelson
wrote:

Speaks her mind (5): 3Apis, camph., falco-p., ruta, scut.
*****and adding to what Barbara and Shannon wrote:

here is 'speaks her mind' from EH search
EH - speaks her mind

apis arg-met. camph. falco-pe. ign. phos.

Ruta also came up in that search, however I removed it as it said the following: Next day she still
lay in state of prostration, somnolence, and stupefaction, she could hardly be roused to speak, her
mind was confused, and she was semi-delirious.

Arg-met ref was from Degroote, Apis was from a urticaria case in a journal, Camph was a chronic
fatigue case, Falco was from Norland, Phos was from Richardson-Boedler, and was also looking at
Agrimony for that case and laast but not least was Ignatia from Jonathon Shore.

Here's another EH search that yielded 34 rems, however have not gone through the results and sifted
the ringins:

EH - outspoken / outspokenly / outspokenness

acon. aconin. am-c. arg-n. aur-m-n. aur-s. bar-s. carl. caust. choc. con. crot-c. ferr-s. graph.
grat. haliae-lc. hep. lac-leo. lampo-cy. lob. loxo-recl. lsd. meny. merc. nat-p. pall. phos. plat.
plb. positr. sulph. thuj.

I also wanted to say that as Shannon mentioned, what can be behind it will give more than just
'telling the plain truth' or being honest --- eg., it can be a subconscious protective/defensive
stance, or an aggressive one if one feels imminent or actual attack from some quarter ---- and this
can become a way to ward attack off as well. All this kind of thing can lead to other 'Mind' rubrics
as you would know. Truth is in the eye of the beholder unless it is a 'fact' that is seen by all.

You could also look at things like Censorious, defiant, Intolerance................

Would be interested to see what comes of this one Rochelle

Best

Robyn

--
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.1.405 / Virus Database: 268.10.9/417 - Release Date: 8/11/2006
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Thanks for the research on this one Robyn. Yes its another of my complicated type cases that get driven my way!! I will see what the remedy I gave her does before I consider anything else. The outspoken bit wasn't really part of the presenting complaint or the aetiology but just something I knew there was a rubric for and couldn't remember what it was!!

Rochelle
Registered Homeopath, EFT(Advanced)Practitioner
www.southporthomeopathy.co.uk

Can anyone think of a rubric for someone who always speaks their mind?

Thanks
Rochelle

But I'd be inclined to look more at the hows and whys. Is is simple
straightforwardness (in which case perhaps not even a symptom), or is
it aggressive, can't keep a secret", or or ??
Best,
Shannon

)))))))))))
Hi Rochelle,
Taking Shan and Barbara’s lead, here are some rubrics having to do
directly or remotely -- with “speaking ones mind” - arranged according to
theme of the forcing function of that speech. Some I have had time to
compile into combined rubrics from RU, Synth 9.1, Murphy, Referenceworks.

Best,
Andy

Rubrics related to (“SPEAKS ONE’S MIND”)

=======================================
*“Speaks her/his/their mind”
=======================================
(RFW-LibraryF) (8): Apis(caseIFH), camph(caseIFH). c-di-o (proving-Klein),
cor-r (case mangialavori) falco-p.(proving-Norland), moly (“not afraid to
speak mind”-Vermeulen), rhus-g (desires to speak his mind-proving
Tumminello)

=======================================
*Desires to correctly or effectively communicate Fact or Detail
=======================================
MIND - OBJECTIVE, reasonable (Synth9.1plusRUplusMurphy)
alum. ars. aur. bell. calc. falco-pe. galeoc-c-h. HALIAE-LC. hep. lsd.
kali-c. lach. lat-h. merc. nat-m. nit-ac. porc-m. nit-ac. nux-v. plat.
puls. ruta scor. sep. sil. symph. tax. Tritic-vg.

Seriousness
Intellectual
Eloquent
Talk - pleasure in his own; reiterating; serious

Mind - TRIFLES, seem important, seem (Synth 9.1)
ars. calc. caust. cocc. ferr. Graph. Hep. ign. ip. lil-t. nat-m. Nux-v.
petr. scor. sil. thuj. tub.

Trifles, recriminations about

Mind - EXACTING, too (Synth9.1)
ARS. CARC. Puls. Sil.

MIND - CONSCIENTIOUS about trifles (Synth9.1plusRUplusMurphy)
aeth. ambr. ang. anh. Apis arg-met. arge-pl. ars-s-f. ARS. aur-ar. aur-i.
aur. bac. bamb-a. Bar-c. bar-s. bry. but-ac. calc-lac. calc-met. calc-p.
calc-s. calc-sil. calc. carbn-s. CARC. caust. cham. chin. chinin-ar.
chir-fl. cob. cocc. con. crot-c. cupr-act. cupr. cycl. Dig. dulc. dys.
ephe. ferr-ar. ferr-i. ferr-p. ferr-sil. ferr. galla-q-r. ferr. graph.
ham. helodr-cal. harp. hep. hura hyos. IGN. ignis-alc. iod. ip. kali-c.
kali-p. KALI-S. kali-sil. lac-d. lap-la. lac-del. lac-f. loxo-recl.
loxo-lae. lac-f. lac-h. lach. lil-t. LYC. M-AMBO. M-arct. m-aust. mag-sil.
malus-c. mang-n. mang-sil. musca-d. med. merc-i-f. merc. mez. Mur-ac.
nat-act. nat-ar. NAT-C. nat-m. nat-sil. Nicc. olib-sac. nit-ac. nit-s-d.
Nux-v. pin-con. Nux-v. ozone porc-m. Nux-v. positr. Nux-v. oci-sa. petr.
ph-ac. phos. pip-m. sacch-a. plat. sal-fr. plat. plb. plut-n. plb. podo.
PULS. rhus-t. ruta sarr. sec. ser-a-c. sil-met. SEP. SIL. spig. spirae.
Spong. STAPH. Stram. sul-i. tax-br. SULPH. syc. THUJ. Tritic-vg. tub.
uran-met. vanil. verat-v. verat. zinc-i.
Children - CONSCIENTIOUS, about trifles (Murphy)
ARS. Bar-c. Calc-p. calc-s. calc. Carc. cham. hyos. IGN. Lyc. nat-c.
Nux-v. puls. SIL. Staph. sul-i. Sulph. Thuj. verat.

MIRILLI'S THEMES - CONSCIENTIOUS
acon. adam. aeth. agar. all-s. alum. am-c. ambr. ANAC. androc. ang. anh.
apis arag. arg-met. arg-n. arge-pl. arg-n. arn. ars-s-f. ARS. asar-o.
aster. aur-ar. aur-i. AUR-M-N. AUR-S. AUR. bac. BAMB-A. banis-c. bar-ar.
BAR-C. bar-s. bell. bry. bufo cact. cadm-met. calad. calc-p. calc-s.
calc-sil. calc. carbn-s. CARC. catha-ed. CARC. cath-a. CARC. caust. CHAM.
chel. CHIN. chinin-ar. cic. cocc. coff. CON. cupr-act. cupr. cycl. DIG.
DIOS. dros. dys. ephe. falco-pe. eup-a. ferr-ar. ferr-i. ferr-p. ferr.
germ-met. glon. granit-m. GRAPH. haliae-lc. GRAPH. helodr-cal. ham. harp.
hell. HEP. hura hydrog. hyos. IGN. ignis-alc. IGN. IOD. ip. kali-ar.
kali-bi. KALI-C. kali-n. lac-ac. lac-lup. lac-c. lap-la. lac-del. lac-d.
lac-e. lac-h. lac-f. LACH. lsd. LACH. lact-v. lap-a. lat-h. lepr. lil-t.
LOB. LYC. M-AMBO. M-ARCT. m-aust. manc. mang. MED. mez. moni. morg-g.
MUR-AC. murx. nat-ar. nelum-lu. nat-ar. NAT-C. NAT-M. nat-p. nat-s.
nat-sil. NIT-AC. nuph. NUX-V. ozone op. orot-ac. op. oscilloc. paeon.
petr. ph-ac. phel. porc-m. phos. positr. phos. pip-m. plat. plb. plut-n.
plb. pop. psor. PULS. ran-b. rat. rhus-t. ruta samb. sarr. sec. sel. SEP.
SIL. sol spig. spirae. stann. STAPH. STRAM. stront-c. succ. tax-br. sul-i.
SULPH. syc. syph. tarent. tax. TEUCR. THUJ. tub. upa. uran-met. VALER.
verat-v. VERAT. zinc.

======================================
*Speech Direct, Responsible, or Intolerant of Dishonesty and Injustice
======================================
MIND - TRUTH - telling the plain truth- (RUplusSynth9.1plusMurphy)
alum. ara-maca. both. bov. choc. falco-pe. heroin. hyos. ina-i. lac-e.
podo. ozone olib-sac. positr. tritic-vg. Vanil. verat.

MIND - OBJECTIVE, reasonable (Synth9.1plusRUplusMurphy)
alum. ars. aur. bell. calc. falco-pe. galeoc-c-h. HALIAE-LC. hep. lsd.
kali-c. lach. lat-h. merc. nat-m. nit-ac. porc-m. nit-ac. nux-v. plat.
puls. ruta scor. sep. sil. symph. tax. Tritic-vg.

MIND – HONEST (Synth9.1plusRU)
am-br. calc-sil. calc. falco-pe heroin. nux-v. olib-sac. spect. nux-v.
SEP. STAPH. sulph. thuj. tritic-vg. vanil.

MIND - INJUSTICE, cannot support (Synth9.1plusRUplusMurphy)
am-c. am-m. ambr. ars. aur-m-n. AUR-S. aur. bell. bry. bung-fa. Calc-p.
calc. CARC. CAUST. chel. chin. coloc. corv-cor. crot-c. cupr-act. cupr-f.
cupr-m. cupr-p. cupr. dros. Dulc. fic-m. Falco-pe. elaps Foll. graph. Ham.
hecla hep. Ign. ignis-alc. Kali-i. Kola lac-e. lat-h. Mag-c. mag-m. med.
merc. musa naja nat-c. Nat-m. nit-ac. NUX-V. oxyg. pall. petr-ra. ph-ac.
PHOS. plat. plb. positr. plb. Podo. Puls. querc-r. rhus-g. sep. Spong.
STAPH. sulph. symph. thal. thea thuj. tub. verat.

MIRILLI'S THEMES - INJUSTICE
adam. arg-n. aur-m-n. AUR-S. bac. calc-p. calc. carc. CAUST. chel. chin.
choc. chr-ac. clem. corv-cor. coloc. falco-pe. cupr. dros. hecla hydrog.
HYOS. ign. kali-i. kola lac-leo. lac-e. lach. lat-h. lil-t. LYC. LYS.
mag-m. med. MERC. mosch. musa naja nat-m. nux-v. oxyg. porc-m. PHOS.
positr. PHOS. plb. plut-n. querc-r. sep. sil. STAPH. urol-h. sulph. tax.
thal. thea thuj. verat.

Mind; INTEGRITY, sensation of (Complete 2000) - nat-m, nux-v, plat

Duty, sense of
Freedom remarkable in what he had to do
Anarchist
Political
Defiant
Talk - prattling

=======================================
*Speech Outgoing, Petitioning, Questioning
=======================================
Confidence, self in
Positiveness
Audacity
Impetuous
Initiative
Independent- demonstrative
Talk - forcible; reiterating; prattling; serious

========================================
*Speech Impulsive
========================================
Quick to act
Abrupt
Impulsiveness
Answers, abruptly; hastily; snappishly; violently

=======================================
*Speech Ambitious, Power-desiring, Controlling
=======================================
Achieve, desire to
Egotism
Answers, dictatorial; abruptly; civil not; hastily; snappishly; violently
Anarchist
Fanaticism
Political
Ambition, much
Talk - forcible; himself,about; pleasure in his own; dictatorial;
inconsiderate; prattling

=======================================
*Speech Contrary, Polemical, or Critical of Others
=======================================
Hurt other peoples feelings, inclination
Impolite
Contradict, disposition
Slander, tendency
Abusive, insulting
Ridicule, disposition
Reproaches others
Censorious
Dictatorial
Disputatious
Contrary
Contemptuous
Answers, dictatorial; abruptly; civil not; hastily; snappishly; violently;
Gossiping
Censorious
Insolent
Contemptuous
Talk - forcible; dictatorial; inconsiderate; prattling
Defiant
Mocking
Jesting
Abrupt
Impulsive

=======================================
*Speech Egotistical
=======================================
Importance, feels his own pompous
Delusion great person
Boaster, braggart
Egotism
Contemptuous
Talk - forcible; himself,about; pleasure in his own; dictatorial
Answers, dictatorial

=======================================
*Speech in Exuberance
=======================================
Ideas exalted, loquacity with
Exuberant

=======================================
*Speech in Indiscretion
=======================================
Secrets, reveals
Indiscretion
Discrimination, lack of
Gossiping
Unobserving

=======================================
*Merely a “Talker”
=======================================
Explaining constantly
Loquacious
Talk - forcible; himself,about; pleasure in his own; reiterating
Discuss, desire
Conversation, desire
Unobserving
Ideas exalted, loquacity with
=======================================
*Unconscious or Unaware
=======================================
Automatic behavior
Explaining constantly
Unobserving
MIND - NAIVE - open, honest and childlike
falco-pe.
MIND - CONFUSION of mind - mixes subjective and objective
(synthplusRUplusMurphy)
calc. cann-s. cann-xyz. cypra-eg. hyos. nux-v. plat. SULPH.
Quick to act
Abrupt
Impulsiveness
Talk - reiterating
Answers, abruptly; hastily
Ideas exalted, loquacity with
Secrets, reveals
Indiscretion
Discrimination, lack of
Gossiping
Mocking

Great set of rubrics, Andy. Thanks! Rosemary

Hi - just found this in Complete; probably not useful, but seems to fit your
description :

Mind; DIRECT, open, blunt (p, 2) (2) : bos-s., uv-lux.

But Andy's masterpiece is probably more helpful.

bw, Barbara
--- In minutus@yahoogroups.com, "Rochelle Marsden" wrote:

Excellent Barbara! I have found that rubric in RU and the cross references it gives are Positiveness, Rashness, Audacity and Constructive. I think I like Audacity for my patient despite the fact that the Rx I gave her is not in that rubric!!

Rochelle
Registered Homeopath, EFT(Advanced)Practitioner
www.southporthomeopathy.co.uk