Minutus

Hi Rosemary,

Hope you are reading this as well as anyone else who knows about
cancer. I am considering giving a more aggressive treatment or maybe
I should stay with the successful remedy that I am using now. I am
asking if Naja will help with a skin ulcer that may be cancerous. I
don't see Naja among Dr. Ramakrishnan's remedies, but I think his
examples are general remedies. The Px is a sure bet for Carc if I
were to alternate remedies.

She is very worried about having a cancerous growth. More than
anything it is at the nape of her neck and visible. People are
telling her to get it cut off because it is ugly. Px says that the
doctor will remove the growth on her skin and then do a biopsy on it.
So she is not sure if it is cancerous. Also because this is the order
of the procedure, the doctor's assessment is not an option. Is the
doctor's procedure really that fixed? Couldn't he do a bioposy
without removing the growth? In any case, this is not an obvious life
or death situation. So I could just continue with the treatment.

Or should I be more aggressive following Dr. Ramakrishnan's split dose
method. Could I use Naja 1 LM instead of 200c? That's what she has.

The tumor is bleeding and since the second remedy (naja) it is growing
in size. Phos 6c vanished the small growths around the tumor, but I
was seeing no mental amelioration so I changed to Naja. She reps as
Lach, but is more repressed like a Nat mur. Has devoted the last 15
years to a emotionally difficult son (who was helped by Judith
Reichenberg using homeopathy). She is nurturing and loving. She is a
outgoing person and on the surface seems like a phos, but much more
controlled and actually wishes to hide. Now she is coming out hiding
in her family and this is her first year as a successful realitor.
As a yogi, I see the location of the tumor as the 5th chakra. As she
comes out in public, it is not surprising that it is located there.

The patient has had many wart and preconcerous growths removed. She is
a fair red head who has spent much time under the tropical sun. I am
telling her not to remove this one and let the remedy do the work.
Naja 1 LM mentals are all doing very well, but she was not taking it
often enough. My reading is the physicals are beginning to aggravate
and we just have to wait. What do you think?

Blessings,
Ellen Madono

Re biopsy, a small sample can be removed and sent for pathology, no need to
remove the whole tumour.
Dr. J. Rozencwajg, MD, PhD, NMD.
"The greatest enemy of any science is a closed mind".

--- In minutus@yahoogroups.com, "Dr. J. Rozencwajg, MD, PhD."
wrote:
no need to
maybe
it.
order
life
dose
growing
a
hiding
she
She is
am
it
aggravate
usually cancerour ulcers r syphilitic and growths belon to
sycosis.ur patien has had the hitory of warts removed by local
treatment, so in my opinion u must consider anti sycotic remedies
THUJA,NAT-S,MEDORRHINUM etc.Kent says that cacer is not curable when
we don't find the childhood symptoms becaus cancerous diathesis
starts right from childhood.so find out the patient's childhood
cnstitution, mind symptoms and the present physica general symptoms
and then aply exact similar remedy.if u give the abve mentioned
details i ll try to help u.
best wishes
Dr,Meer Zahid

I thought so. I will show her this.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Dear Dr. Meer,

Sankaran lists naja as syphilitic. It is most famous for its use with heart
sx. I used it because she was most concerned with mental symptoms when we
started the case. Also they were the most distinctive. I really need to
first know what we are dealing with. I will have her get a biopsy pronto.
Also, I forgot to mention that a similar tumor appeared near her eye after
she started Naja and then went away after she scratched it. So the naja is
doing something to the tumor. It is not irrelevant. If the mental ex are
ameliorating, maybe I need to alternate with a syocotic or cancer miasm
remedy. Thank-you for your kind offer. I have it repped out, it is just
that I have too many symptoms in my repping. This is always my problem. I
relied on the SRP's and mental sx.

By the way, in going from Lach to Naja, I am following Mangialavori. The
big snake remedy comes up and then I check the other snake remedies to see
if there is a closer fit.

Today she said she wakes in the morning and checks her chest to see how she
is doing. IF her chest is constricted, she needs to take her remedy (She
was not doing that). When she began Naja, her whole day was dominated by
her dreams. Recently they have been free from dream influence and she has
not had these anxious dreams. But if she gets into an axious state, it will
be reflected in the dream. She talks as if when she wakes she has to
convince herself that the anxious dream is not reality. Typically she is
worrying about something related to her kids and she blows it out of
porportion during the dream. In the past, I repped the dream, but maybe
there is a more general rubric related to not being able to get out of the
dream. Mind - as if in a dream has 95 remedies in it including lachasis.

When the seasons change, this problem becomes more intense. All of this is
new information and I haven't repped it. I think she is becoming more aware
of herself. She drinks too much and today she was complaining about this.
Usually, she brushes it aside as her fixed character or something that she
likes in herself. Dreams affecting the mind including Lach and Thuja.

Blessings,
Ellen
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Dear Ellen,
Some extracts on snake remedies in cancer for info. Hope it helps. Naja is
recommended by WMcGeorge for cancer of trachea and generally for cancer (one
case cured) by AH Grimmer. Dr Grimmer seems to think Naja alone or even Naja
to start with may not work too well in cancer. For skin cancer, Lachesis is
recommended by:
JH Clarke AH Grimmer TS Hoyne S Lilienthal FJ Master EB Nash.

Regards.

Sarvadaman Oberoi
New Delhi, India
Mobile: +919818768349
+911244076374
Website: http://www.freewebs.com/homeopathy249/
EXTRACTS
*List of All The Snake Remedies ( Authors mentioned under each remedy)*
1. Bitis arietans
2. Bothrops lanceolatus
3. Bungarus Fasciatus
4. Cenchris contortrix
5. Crotalus Cascavella,
*6. Crotalus horridus *

W Boericke JB D'Castro M Castro JH Clarke W McGeorge AH Grimmer EM
Hale HS Khaneja S Lilienthal
7. Dendroaspis polylepsis
*8. Elaps corallinus *

NM Choudhuri
9. Hydrophis cyanocinctus
*10.Lachesis mutus *

JB D'Castro JH Clarke EA Farrington W McGeorge AH Grimmer TS Hoyne TS
Iyer GHG Jahr EG Jones JT Kent PS Kamthan J Laurie S Lilienthal FJ
Master EB Nash AU Ramakrishnan CG Raue
11. Lachesis Trigonocephalus
*12. Naja tripudians *

W McGeorge AH Grimmer
13. Toxicophis pugnax
14. Vipera berus
*List of Cancers ( Remedies with authors mentioned under each snake remedy)
*
1. Bone

Lach. Lachesis muta

FJ Master
2. Vertebrae

Lach. Lachesis muta

FJ Master
3. Thyroid Gland

Lach. Lachesis muta****

AU Ramakrishnan 200C 1M 10M daily plussing method alternating weeks followed
by single doses alternating week/fortnight/month split dose method
4. Lungs

Lach. Lachesis muta

left sided**** AU Ramakrishnan 200C 1M 10M daily plussing method alternating
weeks followed by single doses alternating week/fortnight/month split dose
method
5. Eyes

Lach. Lachesis muta

JB D'Castro TS Hoyne
6. Mouth

Lach. Lachesis muta

FJ Master
7. Lips

Lach. Lachesis muta

JB D'Castro TS Iyer FJ Master
8. Tongue

Crot-h. Crotalus horridus

W Boericke JB D'Castro M Castro JH Clarke W McGeorge AH Grimmer EM Hale HS
Khaneja S Lilienthal
Lach. Lachesis muta

JB D'Castro AH Grimmer TS Iyer TS Hoyne JT Kent FJ Master
9. Throat

Lach. Lachesis muta

left sided AH Grimmer
10. Larynx

Lach. Lachesis muta****

AH Grimmer PS Kamthan FJ Master AU Ramakrishnan
11. Trachea

Naja Naja tripudians

W McGeorge 6C cricoid cartilage
12. Stomach

Crot-h. Crotalus horridus

W Boericke M Castro W McGeorge 6x
Lach. Lachesis muta

W McGeorge S Lilienthal FJ Master
13. Liver

Lach. Lachesis muta

FJ Master
14. Kidney

Crot-h. Crotalus horridus

right sided HS Khaneja 6C
15. Intestines

Lach. Lachesis muta
16. Rectum

Lach. Lachesis muta****

AU Ramakrishnan
17. Uterus

Elaps Elaps corallinus

NM Choudhuri
Crot-h. Crotalus horridus

M Castro
Lach. Lachesis muta*****

TS Hoyne S Lilienthal EB Nash AU Ramakrishnan CG Raue
18. Ovaries

Lach. Lachesis muta

left sided EM Hale TS Hoyne FJ Master EB Nash
19. Breast

Lach. Lachesis muta

JH Clarke W McGeorge left breast TS Hoyne GHG Jahr EG Jones S
Lilienthal
FJ Master EB Nash CG Raue
20. Skin

Lach. Lachesis muta

JH Clarke AH Grimmer TS Hoyne S Lilienthal FJ Master EB Nash
*GRIMMER Arthur H., The Collected Works (gm1)*

*Therapeutics*

*Homeopathic remedies that have cured patients suffering from cancer*
*Crotalus horridus*

The symptoms and conditions found in this snake poison are fairly common to
all the serpent toxins. They all have marked effect of the heart, vessels,
and blood and on the autonomic nervous system. Extreme fluctuation of
temperature from severe coldness and collapse to a very high degree of
fever; they all have torpor and confusion of mind even sinking into states
of unconsciousness. All the symptoms and conditions are worse during and
after sleep; profuse debilitating hemorrhages of dark clotted or
disorganized fluid blood is found in all the snake poisons as are gangrenous
ulcerations and sloughing of tissues. These remedies are helpful in the
advanced stages of the cancer disease although if recognized and applied in
the early stages, definite curative results can be obtained. Each Snake
poison has definite characterizing indications for its own specific uses,
enabling the prescriber to find the most suitable remedy for each special
case.

The symptoms of *Cench., Crot-h.* and *Elaps* are mostly right sided while
those of *Lach.* are mostly left sided.

*Elaps* is noted for the blackness of its hemorrhages, discharges and
secretions, even the ear-wax being black.

*Naja* has the power to relieve the terrible pains of cancer along with the
Euphorbiums.
*Other (Remedies)*

*The polarity of remedies in relation to the polarity of disease*

* *

A small group of remedies that correspond in their pathogenesis to the three
miasms and at the same time contain the electronic elements relating to
malignancy with clinical confirmations of their curative action in such
cases is the following group of 68 remedies which can be viewed and studied
with profit in the search for a helpful remedy in cancer cases:
*Malignancy and All Three Miasms*
(The only snake remedy included here is Naja)
*Remedy* *Polarity* *Disease Cured*

Naja 0 cancer of breast cured
After many years of cancer study and treating thousands of cancer cases with
strictly homeopathic remedies used in various potencies, I am convinced that
there can never be a one individual specific remedy for cancer disease
occurring in many different patients.
*First*, because the many etiologic factors that enter the field of causes
such as irritations from blows (trauma), burns, intense heat and cold,
drugs, processed and adultered foods, made noxious by poisoned metal
containers like aluminum, and poisoned water supplies from aluminum
fluorides; poisoned air from carbon and sulphur dioxides and lately
radio-active fallout

- all are hazards to health in our modern environment and these are all
cacinogenic agents.

* *

*Second*, the known and proven constitutional cause that runs through many
families, this factor may not be universally recognized because a generation
of tuberculosis may be followed by one of cancer, and even individual
patients may develop cancer on advancing tubercular disease.

* *

*Third*, each individual case of sickness has a body chemistry peculiar to
itself and only reacts to the curative remedy called for by the polarity and
blood chemistry of the individual victim of sickness. In the hands of many
homeopathic prescribers for several generations of doctors, the homeopathic
approach in medicine has its worth in the cure and palliation of cancer.
*List of remedies according to their polarity (magnetic)*
In functional disease a remedy from any polarity group that is indicted may
be the similimum, but in the *chronic cancer states* only those remedies in
the *negative group* will prove sufficient *except where the tubercular
constitution is dominate* and then *neutral remedies* like *Naja*, Symph.
and Tub. will be needed, sometimes *to be followed by deep chronic remedies
from the negative group.*
*CHOUDHURI N. M., A study on Materia Medica (cda1)*

* *

*Elaps corallinus*

This medicine is prepared from the venom of the Brazilian coral
snake.

It was proved by Mure and Lippe, who extracted the poison from the living
snake, and triturated it with sugar of milk.

We notice that this remedy seriously affects the auditory, nasal, and the
throat passages, and is consequently curative in many affections of those
regions.

Thus for example, we use it in chronic otorrhoea when accompanied with
deafness.

The patient complains of constant buzzing in the ear as if a fly were
imprisoned in the auditory meatus.

He is also subject to epistaxis and eruptions about the nose and the face.

This is a grand remedy for ozoena.

The nose feels stopped up and occasionally emits a foul smell.

This is accompanied with chronic pharyngitis.

The posterior wall of the throat is found to be covered with a dry
greenish-yellow membrane, wrinkled and fissured, extending to the nares.

Occasionally portions of this membrane are expelled through nose of throat
leaving an angry, raw surface.

Deglutition is extremely painful.

All the discharges of this remedy are black, and this is so prominent that
we can call this a characteristic symptom.

Thus in the epistaxis the blood is black.

The blood from the uterus too is dark coloured.

Even the wax from the ear is dark.

*Lastly before we close let us add that Elaps is a capital
remedy for uterine cancer.*

* The flow of dark-coloured blood, in these cases, is so very free that the
patient becomes severely prostrated.*

She feels as if something had burst in the womb, and there follows a
continuous stream of dark fluid blood.

This extreme haemorrhage gives them a pale, haggard, cachectic look.

About the skin symptoms of Elaps we know very little, but we
have read about Dr. Clark curing a case of long standing irritating rash in
axilla, which frequently used to give rise to suppuration of the axillary
glands.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

I sent that post called "sunlight, moles and cancer" bout how
I treated a mole homeopathically
using sunlight and a magnifying glass.
I included in it a couple of quotes from two classical authors
that I found in Encyclopedia Homeopathica
supporting that approach. The original post should be in the group archives.
Check out the the article that I have on my website called
"Myth: Sunlight Causes Skin Cancer" which is relevant.
www.canhealyourself.com

Roger Barr
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Dear Sarvadamn,
Thank-you for your imput. Lach comes up very strongly because it is a big
remedy. It is good to know the opinion of the experts. I am not very
practiced at trying several remedies within a short period. There is always
a first time.
Thank-you,
Ellen Madono.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

--- In minutus@yahoogroups.com, "Ellen Madono"
wrote:
maybe
it.
order
life
dose
has.
growing
but I
as
15
is a
hiding
she
She is
am
it
aggravate
here r some more points to consider.

don't puzzle ur mind between naja and lachesis.lachesis patients are
always hot while naja patients are always cold.lachesis has aversion
to company while naja is company desire. u can easily differenciate
between .don't apply any remedy similar to mind and dissimilar to
physical generals. such a remedy will palliate mind symptoms 4 some
time and will not complete the case.aperfact similar remedy can cure-
similar to mental s physical generals and particulars.
regarding to biopsy warn the parient strictly not to cut off the
tumour. u know the rmovel of warts at last caused this tumour so if
this tumour is removed the poison of disese(miasm) will harm the
internal organs that s too dangerous for the patient.
best of luck
Dr Meer Zahid

dear Ellen,
some more points to cosider,
don't puzzle ur mind between lachesis and naja or this and
that.lachesis is predominately hot remedy, its patients are sesitive
to heat they can't bear and tolerate any kind of heat, while Naja
patients r cold ,their symptoms r agg by cold and they can'n bear
cold. if some remedy is similar to mind symptoms and disimilar to
physical generals it will not cure the patien completely though may
ameliorate mind symptoms temporarily, or may ameliorate the symptoms
to which its similar. and in the mean time the disease will profress
and this time will be wasted.onlny a perfact similar remedy ,similar
to mental physical general and particular symptoms, can help in this
kind of cases.GET the childood dispositions mind symptoms physical
general symptoms COMBINE them all and FIND the exact similar
remedy.this is the only wahy .
regarding to biopsy ,warn the patient strictly not to remove total
tumor.u know the removal of warts (in this case)at last caused this
cacancerous growth, and if this is removed the poison of disease
(miasm),which is now being lacated by nature in tumor, will go to the
intenal organs and damage them.if the cancerous tumor or growth is cut
off the pathient lives considerably shorter than if not cut off.
yours sincerely
Dr, Meer Zahid