Minutus

Hi Group, ( i don't know if this if offtopic or not)

I had replied to a question in a share ur experience section of NDTV
site. A chest specialist has replied that homoeopathy has no cure and
that he has seen ppl suffer from homoeopathy and if there is give proof.
is what he says.

Plz go thorough this site

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/View ... &pollid=24
Section Tuberculosis Subject: Re:Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

Sent by Dr Anirban Biswas (NO) Thursday, March 09, 2006

Site : http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/readtop20.asp
or

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/View ... &pollid=24
I have 2 doughts

Was my first reply wrong? I had replied for that particular case?
Now what must i do? Ignore the question? If reply what to reply?

Dr.Nandana.T.Pai

Hi Group, ( i don't know if this if offtopic or not)

I had replied to a question in a share ur experience section of NDTV
site. A chest specialist has replied that homoeopathy has no cure and
that he has seen ppl suffer from homoeopathy and if there is give proof.
is what he says.

Plz go thorough this site

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/View ... &pollid=24
Section Tuberculosis Subject: Re:Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

Sent by Dr Anirban Biswas (NO) Thursday, March 09, 2006

Site : http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/readtop20.asp
or

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/View ... &pollid=24
I have 2 doughts

Was my first reply wrong? I had replied for that particular case?
Now what must i do? Ignore the question? If reply what to reply?

Dr.Nandana.T.Pai

Dear Nandana,
The links are not working. (even after I googled)
I believe you are a homeopath. I would first ask the allopath what he means
by a cure before any details. Allopathic bungling 1. in the form of
vaccination and 2. The cocktail of antibiotics has made more people
tubercular if not directly affected. Then why so many (even in urban India
where there is 100% DPT vaccination) are affected by Tuberculosis . Again ,
this treatment by anti b has resulted in severe long term problems such as
stunted children, backward childred, vitiligo, chronic tonsilitis and
glandular troubles.

Second, for the proof: Did you not ask for help from your college where
they would have given you plenty ? Well our books are full of them. In
particular, Koppikar's clinical experiences,(published by B Jain Publishers)
has some interesting stuff. This man has more than 70 years experience. Even
his once mechanical rx ofcal carb, ferrum and arnica morning , noon and
night based on cough , blood spitting atc cured a guy and the patient
repeated this experiment with his fellow patients and all of them got
'cured'. But this is one of his accidents. .Read the book for more. But also
look at Dewey's, lilienthal, Jahr's , Burt's and Ruddock's therapeutics for
what they have done in such cases.

The reason we have so much diabetics, ringworm , asthmatics are all the
handiwork of Allopathic treatment. They may not have tuberculosis. But they
are 'tubercular'. My own son is a case in point.

Regards
venkat

Date: Sat, 11 Mar 2006 23:59:22 +0530
From: "Nandana T. Pai"
Subject: TB Help for Homoeopathy

Hi Group, ( i don't know if this if offtopic or not)

I had replied to a question in a share ur experience section of NDTV
site. A chest specialist has replied that homoeopathy has no cure and
that he has seen ppl suffer from homoeopathy and if there is give proof.
is what he says.

Plz go thorough this site

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/View ... &pollid=24
Section Tuberculosis Subject: Re:Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

Sent by Dr Anirban Biswas (NO) Thursday, March 09, 2006

Site : http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/readtop20.asp
or

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/View ... &pollid=24
I have 2 doughts

Was my first reply wrong? I had replied for that particular case?
Now what must i do? Ignore the question? If reply what to reply?

Dr.Nandana.T.Pai

Cut and past from the site

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/view ... &pollid=24
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

I noticed a soft growth in my lower neck region. It was diagnosed for
TB. There was no symptoms what so ever, no weightloss, no exersion etc.
Actually Im one of the fittest and active persons in my group. Im a
regular member of gymnasium. when it was diagnosed for TB of lymph
glands APPROXIMATELY an year back after tuberculin test as well as FNAC,
I took regular medication for about 10 months, but the glands seemed the
same. However, a later biopsy done also confirmed TB. The doctor
mentions that I need to take altered medcation for additional year
(which means two years of medication for infection of two lymph nodes!!)
I want to consult TB speciallist for my case. Im in Pune, INDIA and
would want to know any TB hospital/speciallist in Pune. Thanks a lot, Jyoti
- Sent by Sunitha (India) Tuesday, January 10, 2006

Reply | Back
Sunitha, Homoeopathy is a system which is there even before the so
called Dots etc came into being. The success rate of homoepathy is 99%
especialy in TB. Most of the poineers of homoeopathy and even the
propogators of Homoeopathy in the early days where recovered from the
conditon even in the termanal stages when all the systems had told no
hope. Your case is very simple and can be treated in a matter of few
monts. So Plz see a good Homoeopathy in ur area. Dr.Nandana.T.Pai Kochi
Kerala
- Sent by Dr.Nandana.T.Pai (India) Wednesday, February 01, 2006

Reply | Back
Re:Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

that homeopathy can cure TB, it is your claim.Can you support it by
authentic scientific data?dont compare this nuisence system with
DOT.Being a chest physician I have very sad experience with patients of
TB who were treated with homeopathy initially.Belief is one
thing,science is another.DOT is made free by govt. of India free to
every TB patients.Any patient with TB, must access DOT, in nearby hospital.
- Sent by Dr Anirban Biswas (NO) Thursday, March 09, 2006
Reply | Back
For those who are not able to open the link.

Dr.Nandana.T.Pai

Hi Nandana,
I look forward to others' thoughts, but my thought would be to just
treat this as tho there were no diagnosis (except perhaps to avoid
those remedies that we are advised to avoid in cases of encapsulated
tuberculosis--silica and what else? I forget.).

Even tho s/he has no symptoms of tuberculosis, I'm sure there will be
symptoms "of the person" to prescribe on?
Shannon
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Additionally double check for sarcoidosis - it mimics TB, but is not TB.

Pls see http://www.arthritis.org/conditions/onl ... ochure.pdf

and http://www.waterforddisability.com/Sarc ... reness.htm
Rgds
Soroush

Hi Group, ( i don't know if this if offtopic or not)

This is a repost as i am not geting the answer for the question i asked.

I had replied to a question in a share ur experience section of NDTV
site. A chest specialist has replied that homoeopathy has no cure and
that he has seen ppl suffer from homoeopathy and if there is give proof.
is what he says.

Plz go thorough this site

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/View ... &pollid=24
Section Tuberculosis Subject: Re:Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

Sent by Dr Anirban Biswas (NO) Thursday, March 09, 2006

Site : http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/readtop20.asp
or

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/View ... &pollid=24
I have 2 Questions

Was my first reply wrong? I had replied for that particular case?
Now what must i do? Ignore the question? If reply what to reply?
Dr.Nandana.T.Pai

For those who are not able to open the link i am pasting it below

Cut and past from the site

http://www.doctorndtv.com/shareExp/view ... &pollid=24
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

I noticed a soft growth in my lower neck region. It was diagnosed for
TB. There was no symptoms what so ever, no weightloss, no exersion etc.
Actually Im one of the fittest and active persons in my group. Im a
regular member of gymnasium. when it was diagnosed for TB of lymph
glands APPROXIMATELY an year back after tuberculin test as well as FNAC,
I took regular medication for about 10 months, but the glands seemed the
same. However, a later biopsy done also confirmed TB. The doctor
mentions that I need to take altered medcation for additional year
(which means two years of medication for infection of two lymph nodes!!)
I want to consult TB speciallist for my case. Im in Pune, INDIA and
would want to know any TB hospital/speciallist in Pune. Thanks a lot, Jyoti
- Sent by Sunitha (India) Tuesday, January 10, 2006

Reply | Back
Sunitha, Homoeopathy is a system which is there even before the so
called Dots etc came into being. The success rate of homoepathy is 99%
especialy in TB. Most of the poineers of homoeopathy and even the
propogators of Homoeopathy in the early days where recovered from the
conditon even in the termanal stages when all the systems had told no
hope. Your case is very simple and can be treated in a matter of few
monts. So Plz see a good Homoeopathy in ur area. Dr.Nandana.T.Pai Kochi
Kerala
- Sent by Dr.Nandana.T.Pai (India) Wednesday, February 01, 2006

Reply | Back
Re:Re:TB Hospitals/Doctors in Pune

that homeopathy can cure TB, it is your claim.Can you support it by
authentic scientific data?dont compare this nuisence system with
DOT.Being a chest physician I have very sad experience with patients of
TB who were treated with homeopathy initially.Belief is one
thing,science is another.DOT is made free by govt. of India free to
every TB patients.Any patient with TB, must access DOT, in nearby hospital.
- Sent by Dr Anirban Biswas (NO) Thursday, March 09, 2006
Reply | Back