Page 1 of 1

Help - Homoeopathy Trial Challenge

Posted: Mon Nov 26, 2001 7:22 am
by Soroush Ebrahimi
Dear Colleagues

I hope you have seen my challenge to those who say Hom does not work or it is just placebo.

So far only one person in Las Vegas has accepted the challenge and even provided his address and telephone number.
He may drop out when we put our contract before him!
However, we must react to this positively.

Do we have any one who is a homoeopath in Las Vegas to supervise his case taking and remedy taking.
In the absence of any homoeopaths in Las Vegas we may have to ask him to take a few days holiday and go to perhaps LA and be seen by one there.

A FULL case needs to be taken before hand and then the taking of the remedy must be supervised daily (three times during the first day) until he develops symptoms. A full assessment of the symptoms he develops must also be made, listed and signed by him and then we compare that with the remedy symptom picture that was tried - to see the match of symptoms.

Before that, we need someone to draw up a legal contract so that each keeps to their part of the bargain and especially that he cannot sue if and when he falls ill. He must promise not to antidote either so we will need to do checks on for example coffee in take and blood analysis will need to be done for which he will have to pay.

PLEASE can you assist in to making this a good programme. This is our chance to answer some of these guys with a properly conducted personal experience.

Let us think this through with care and consider all aspects so that it become a good reportable case.

Your input at all levels would be appreciated.
Regards
Soroush
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Re: Help - Homoeopathy Trial Challenge

Posted: Mon Nov 26, 2001 12:52 pm
by Minervabks
I do think that as homoeopaths we need to rise to the challenge when
materialistic 'scientific' people disparage homoeopathy as hocus-pocus. There
is of course 200 years of evidence contained in our massive libraries.
Anybody with a genuine enquiring mind would at least treat that with some
respect at least. The Faculty of Homoeopathy in the U.K. has repeatedly
conducted various trials, Dr David Reilly in Glasgow in particular. They are
written up on a regular basis in the British Homoeopathic Journal for anybody
to read.
If a sceptic annoyed me enough I would suggest that they take Plutonium 30 in
the morning, a 200 at lunchtime and a 10M for bedtime. I would suggest this
regime for a month at least. It does not have the advantage of being a
traditional remedy with thousands of cured cases but I would be interested
myself in the reaction. I realise that this is a rather sadistic suggestion
but I must admit to a dislike of closed 'scientific' types who assume that
there is nothing on Heaven and Earth beyond their mollusc- like version of
'reality'. The Plutonium might at least wake the sceptic up and that would be
a gift in itself.
I apologise if my sadism offends anybody!
Stewart McOwan
Minerva Homoeopathic Books
173 Fulham Palace Road
Hammersmith
London W6 8QT
Tel 00 44 020 7385 1361
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]