Its just that it reminds me of a case that did so well on this and there was
only a vague issue around the possible causation of a nbws the antibiotic
but a huge one with milk, and because the picture seemed to fit so well I
gave it.
What happened to the boils, any treatment or suppression, it might seem so
as the state has gone inwards as far as her fits and tantrums. I am very
curious about how and why this has happened. It made me think about going
right back to the beginning of the case and thus the boils are still
important to me.
This rx is sycotic as well as tubercular and with allergies present (which
can create horrendous moods in themselves) you can expect an alternating
state of energy (fits and tantrums) and asthenia (a very depleted state).
It is hard to say whether you have a situation that is blocked, i.e. the
indicated remedy isn't working and if so why not - or - she simply hasn't
had the right remedy.
And we don't know the whole case - sometimes it is worth looking elsewhere
for the simillimum, although what you say about her are strong and guiding
sx, perhaps there is another aspect of the case that will give further
clues.
best wishes, Joy
www.homeopathicmateriamedica.com
on 9/3/03 6:01 PM, Bob&Shannon at
shannonnelson@tds.net wrote:
Hm, I'm not sure what to think about Penecillin. (She benefits from silica
every now and then.) I see that some things fit, yet in a very general way.
She's never had penecilin, nor have I except once as a teen (no apparent
aftereffects). But then, she benefitted hugely from Lyssin, and had never
been bitten by any dog...
Tho it covers the boils (which she had only in the long past, and only from
milk), it does not (so far as I am reading to far) cover the fits and
tantrums that milk predisposed her to, and I don't see much at all about
other mentals. Covers general predisposition to allergies -- which she
certainly has! -- and a depleted state -- ditto...
Vermeullen's list of remedies to compare { Sulphur. Silicea. Calcarea
carbonica. Sepia. Mercurius. Nepenthes) are all, except the last, ones that
she's benefitted from in the past, which is interesting.
Can you say any more about why it seems especially indicated?
Since I've been floundering for so long, I'm really willing to try about
anything. If I do try this with her, what posology would you suggest, and
are you seeing this as an "overall" remedy for her, or more an un-blocker
(tho I dunno where that particular block would have come from) or something
else?
Curious,
Shannon
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]