Crategus oxy

[Athanasios Razis]

I can't say i appreciate that you responded to a coherent email in a segmented/Frankenstein way breaking it down to incoherent sentences. But then again that was probably the only way to introduce your theories on magnets, circuits and cables without having to argue any of the main points. I would nevertheless appreciate it if you could take the time to also respond the the rest of the arguments as you conveniently chose to answer to some and ignore others. For example i noticed that in you recent response to Jeff you referenced the Organon, but you completely missed my reference to Organon with regards to Hahneman's explanation on how the energy of the remedy works after it has been introduced to the organism.... And i did mention Bach as an example of another great healer whose analysis agreed with Hahneman's but then again we ignore him as well cause he was just lazy!

To sum up if you have a case of a clear Apis symptoms - with IDENTICAL symptomatology to the symptomatology of Apis you are telling me that you will use a different remedy cause you are not looking for the remedy with the identical symptomatology but with a similar one? Which in this case would be what? Cantharis? And what is similar for you? Same presentation but with one or two different modalities? Because this is what you have been arguing all along your emails. And again i made a clear distinction between using the same substance that was also ingonred in your answer...

Last but not least Chickenpox will not cure Small pox if the symptoms are not identical to the symptomatology (proving) of Chickenpox. Not every person with Chickenpox will develop the same symptomatology.

Thanos

[Irene de Villiers]

In that case I'll not waste much more time on the matter.
However it happens to be standard practice on email lists, to split up the answer between the original email sentences, to save time and maintain coherence. I spent some time answering, so I'm sorry it was not what you desired. It's not usual either to be rude to someone who takes the time to answer your queries.
Nor is it usual to introduce disparate comments as it they were germane to the preceding discussion. For example you introduce chickenpox, not previously in the conversation, as if it was relevant to what went before:
Chickenpox was not in the conversation.
However - no it will not cure cowpox or smallpox.
Cowpox and smallpox are very similar.; Both are Orthopoxviruses.
Chickenpox is not like either of them, it is a varicella virus, so cannot help either of the Orthopoxvirus diseases.
The similarity of TB (Mycobacterium tuberculosis) and Leprosy (Mycobacterim laprae) is also the reason TB vaccine protects against Leprosy - as they are similar - but TB vaccine has zero efficacy against TB (as they are identical).

Remedy and illness symptoms MUST be similar, NOT identical and not VERY different.

Namaste,
Irene

(PS The magnet idea was from Hahnemann, not my original analogy.)
REPLY TO: only
--
Irene de Villiers, B.Sc AASCA MCSSA D.I.Hom/D.Vet.Hom.
P.O. Box 4703 Spokane WA 99220.
www.angelfire.com/fl/furryboots/clickhere.html (Veterinary Homeopath.)
"Man who say it cannot be done should not interrupt one doing it."