Minutus

I read one MM- A select Homeopathic Materia Medica- by
P. Ishwardas Tarkas and Ajit K. Kulkarni. There you
will find many of these triads ( I think in ArgNit).
Tomorrow I will tell you after I check up. The stuff
therin is somewhat mind boggling and sometimes too
clinical but an enjoyable book.
Esp tub and carc- the MM is by far the complete I have
got to see.
Reg Venkat

--- rochelle wrote:
[

________________________________________________________________________
Yahoo! India Matrimony: Find your life partner online
Go to: http://yahoo.shaadi.com/india-matrimony

Dear Joy,

These triads look also like Nash's leaders (he always had 3). Complementary remedies would not necessarily be expected to move from one to another, would they? I thought that Nash was just naming the remedies that are strongest for each symptom (such as restlessness). Was I missing something?

What's the difference between remedies that are supportive and those that are complementary?
Blessings,
Ellen Madono

I understand the leaders to be like red line sx - those that are
indisputably recognised for any remedy picture. Remedy relationships are
something else all together - that relationship can come from anything
natural, physical or from clinical experience which would include antidotes,
inimicals, related by acute and chronic etc.

By 'supportive' I was really referring to organ supports.

Best, Joy

www.homeopathicmateriamedica.com
on 11/9/04 6:25 pm, Ellen Madono at ellen.madono@verizon.net wrote:

Dear Joy,

These triads look also like Nash's leaders (he always had 3). Complementary
remedies would not necessarily be expected to move from one to another,
would they? I thought that Nash was just naming the remedies that are
strongest for each symptom (such as restlessness). Was I missing something?

What's the difference between remedies that are supportive and those that
are complementary?
Blessings,
Ellen Madono
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Here is information I have collected based of previous discussions on this
subject:

Kent's Triads

Sulphur, Calc Carb, Lycopodium, Skin (Anti-psoric).
Sulphur, Merc Sol, Thuja, Anti-Miasmatic.
Carbo Veg, China, Lycopodium, Flatulence.
Arsenicum alb, Phos, Sulphur, Burning Sensation.
Aconite, Ars Alb, Rhus tox, Restlessness.
Aconite, Chamomilla, Coffea, Pain Sensitivity.
Belladonna, Hyoscyamus, Stramonium, Delirium.
Lachesis, Naja, Crotalus, Snake Remedy Trio.
Kali iod, Sanguinaria, Stannum. Cough after pneumonia.

Aconite, Ignatia, Opium, Fear.
Ant tart, Opium, Nux Mosch, Drowsiness.
Ipecac, Cuprum Met. Veratrum Alb, Collapse in cholera.
Ignatia, Nat Mur, Acid Phos, Grief.
Causticum, Rhus tox, Sulphur, Rheumatism.
Belladonna, Calc Carb, Nat Mur, Upper Lips.
Glonine, Belladonna, Mellilotus, Headaches.
Gelsemium, Causticum, Sepia, Droopy Eyelids.

And from Boenninghausen, one not in Nash's List :

Aconite, Spongia, Hepar sulph, The Croup Powders.
Remember these in order: ASH. That is how they will be needed!
----------------
from Will Taylor discussion:

Kent speaks of viewing the series of remedies sometimes necessary in
bringing about cure as a process of gradual unfolding, without
hypothesizing a hierarchical relationship between the successive
prescriptions. From his lecture on the Second Prescription," What is more
beautiful to look upon than the bud during its hourly changes to the rose
in its bloom. This evolution has so often come to my mind when patiently
awaiting the return of symptoms after the first prescription has exhausted
its curative power. The return symptom image unfolds the knowledge by which
we know whether the first prescription was the specific or the palliative,
i.e., we may know whether the remedy was deep enough to cure all the
deranged vital wrong or simply a
superficially acting remedy, capable of only a temporary effect. The many
things learned by
the action of the first remedy determine the kind of demand made upon the
physician for the
second prescription."

Boenninghausen, in his Concordances, brings to this question his incredible
wealth of clinical
experience and knowledge of the materia medica. These are the most
exhaustive listings of
relationships between remedies that have been produced. Rather than
producing a theoretical scheme for division of the economy of the organism
into "layers", Boenninghausen has provided us with an essentially pragmatic
list of "what is likely to follow what". We find scattered in our
literature references to remedy relationships, e.g., the often cited "Calc
Lyc Sulph" series, references to complementary pairs of remedies such as
Bell/Calc c, Rhus t/Calc p, Puls/Sil, Acon/Sulph, Ign/Nat m, Apis/Nat m,
etc.; and Gibson Miller has given us the list of remedy relations found in
the back of current editions of Kent's Repertory; but we find nowhere as
extensive a listing of these relationships of remedies as Boenninghausen
has offered us.
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

http://www.boger-boenninghausen.com/

there's a good article on this website entitled
Boenninghausen's
Remedy Relationships - The missing link

Lynn Cremona
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Here is information I have collected based of previous discussions on
this subject:

Kent's Triads
Sulphur, Calc Carb, Lycopodium, Skin (Anti-psoric).
Sulphur, Merc Sol, Thuja, Anti-Miasmatic.
Carbo Veg, China, Lycopodium, Flatulence.
Arsenicum alb, Phos, Sulphur, Burning Sensation.
Aconite, Ars Alb, Rhus tox, Restlessness.
Aconite, Chamomilla, Coffea, Pain Sensitivity.
Belladonna, Hyoscyamus, Stramonium, Delirium.
Lachesis, Naja, Crotalus, Snake Remedy Trio.
Kali iod, Sanguinaria, Stannum. Cough after pneumonia.
Aconite, Ignatia, Opium, Fear.
Ant tart, Opium, Nux Mosch, Drowsiness.
Ipecac, Cuprum Met. Veratrum Alb, Collapse in cholera.
Ignatia, Nat Mur, Acid Phos, Grief.
Causticum, Rhus tox, Sulphur, Rheumatism.
Belladonna, Calc Carb, Nat Mur, Upper Lips.
Glonine, Belladonna, Mellilotus, Headaches.
Gelsemium, Causticum, Sepia, Droopy Eyelids.
And from Boenninghausen, one not in Nash's List :
Aconite, Spongia, Hepar sulph, The Croup Powders.
Remember these in order: ASH. That is how they will be needed!
----------------
from Will Taylor discussion:

Kent speaks of viewing the series of remedies sometimes necessary in
bringing about cure as a process of gradual unfolding, without
hypothesizing a hierarchical relationship between the successive
prescriptions. From his lecture on the Second Prescription," What is
more beautiful to look upon than the bud during its hourly changes to
the rose in its bloom. This evolution has so often come to my mind
when patiently awaiting the return of symptoms after the first
prescription has exhausted its curative power. The return symptom
image unfolds the knowledge by which we know whether the first
prescription was the specific or the palliative, i.e., we may know
whether the remedy was deep enough to cure all the deranged vital
wrong or simply a
superficially acting remedy, capable of only a temporary effect. The
many things learned by
the action of the first remedy determine the kind of demand made upon
the physician for the
second prescription."
Boenninghausen, in his Concordances, brings to this question his
incredible wealth of clinical
experience and knowledge of the materia medica. These are the most
exhaustive listings of
relationships between remedies that have been produced. Rather than
producing a theoretical scheme for division of the economy of the
organism into "layers", Boenninghausen has provided us with an
essentially pragmatic list of "what is likely to follow what". We find
scattered in our literature references to remedy relationships, e.g.,
the often cited "Calc Lyc Sulph" series, references to complementary
pairs of remedies such as Bell/Calc c, Rhus t/Calc p, Puls/Sil,
Acon/Sulph, Ign/Nat m, Apis/Nat m, etc.; and Gibson Miller has given
us the list of remedy relations found in the back of current editions
of Kent's Repertory; but we find nowhere as extensive a listing of
these relationships of remedies as Boenninghausen has offered us.

Hello,

Would someone please send me the Triads - it was posted sometime back
and I have lost it.
TIA

Cheers - Glenda

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]