Minutus

Hi Dr. Roz,

You are doing a very nice version of Dr. Frei's polarity analysis. If a remedy has plenty of clinical cases and a good proving one would hope that we would have both the extremes of the healthy individual and the pathology. Mangialavori and I suppose many others argued that the healthy polarity is not found in provings. The extreme pathologies are also not possible for provings. We can't put prover is in the hospital with remedy symptoms. So we are very dependent on the kind of description that Dale made of the case that she saw. Of course, it has to be a longtime cure, at least a couple of years. It seems to me that this kind of gut feeling is very important although it doesn't belong in our provings.

Kristy L sent me Tyler's description of Platina. In there, she mentioned the injuries of Platina.
"Therefore by Mental Traumatism we would express wounds of mind - heart - soul. The very phraseology we apply to these is borrowed from physical traumatism... "feeling very hurt"... "deeply wounded"... "cut to the heart". And we speak of "lacerated feelings"; of being "broken - hearted", while Shakespeare reminds us how " sharper than a serpent's tooth it is, To have a thankless child ".
In order to suggest remedies to counter such injuries and the damage, acute or chronic, inflicted by them, we must match them with drugs which, in the provers, have produced sensitivity to just such traumatic agents.
A physical wound may be a stab, scratch, tear, an acute abrasion, or chronic damaging pressure which, persisted in, may conduce to even malignant ulceration. Mentally one may experience all these wounds. And here Platinum, Staphisagria, Colocynth, Ignatia, Natrum muriaticum, Phosphoric acid may be found to have been not only causative but curative - according to symptoms."

We all know the narcissistic injuries. But it might be useful to consider the injury remedies that are not Platina. The Asteraceae (Like Arnica montana), have a very macho type of injury reaction. Part of their bravado is to show everyone else that they have a strong physical body. Coffea, Insects, Parasites and many other groups have this kind of bravado. Platina It is definitely more female, perhaps female macho. Not feminine. They want to show off their physical sexuality or their intellectual strength.

Best,
Ellen Madono

Hi Dr. Roz,

How has constitutional analysis been transformed into Core Analysis?

Best,
Ellen Madono

The physical pathologies are known through cured cases; those pathologies are an extension and a mix of the functional symptoms evoked through the provings and the physical weaknesses augmented by the external "assaults".

How many times did I prescribe Arnica for a bruised ego or after a patient tells me "after that meeting I felt completely beaten up"....symptomatic treatment, but oh so effective, opening the way for deeper ones.

I do not look too much at masculine or feminine trends of remedies unless dealing specifically with gynaecological or male problems. We have all given Sepia or Pulsatilla to males, even machos ones...

Joe.
Dr. J. Rozencwajg, NMD
"The greatest enemy of any science is a closed mind"

www.naturamedica.co.nz

The concept of constitution is different from one teacher/school/practitioner to the other, therefore I felt that we were not talking about the same thing at all quite often. The concept of Core stems from Eyzaiaga's constitution definition based on the genetic make-up of each person: it is the invariable part, who we are, how we react no matter what. It is described in more details in "Third Millennium Homeopathy".
Better?

Joe.
Dr. J. Rozencwajg, NMD
"The greatest enemy of any science is a closed mind"

www.naturamedica.co.nz

So, a cold Remedy has the symptom built into it to the DNA. That’s why the modalities are so important. Organon 133?

Eyzaiaga was active when Vithoukas started holding huge seminars in the US. My first teacher attended them. Where were you then?

Probably very busy soiling my nappies.........................
Dr. J. Rozencwajg, NMD
"The greatest enemy of any science is a closed mind"

www.naturamedica.co.nz

You spring chicken!

Dear Ellen

The link I sent originally is a fair balance of Platina.
What some people have objected to is the fact that I asked colleagues to consider how well it matched Trump.

All they had to say was – no it does not match, Trump was not a charlatan, has never stiffed people, never gone bankrupt, never been rude to women, never lied etc.

Rgds

Soroush
From: minutus@yahoogroups.com [mailto:minutus@yahoogroups.com]
Sent: Friday, November 24, 2017 9:43 PM
To: minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: [Minutus] Re: PotUS change to negative images of remedies
Hi,
I can't get emotionally involved in this mess. Maybe not living in the US helps. I can't always manage to do it, but when I meet a difficult situation, I cultivate kindness, putting myself in the other person's shoes and gratitude. One incident at a time.
Way back there, through that morass of unkindness, Maria B said something about getting totally negative images about certain remedies. This is a problem that I often have. I have such a negative image of some remedies like Platina that I am unable to use it effectively. Clearly, this is poor homeopathy. What do you to get around this mind block?
I am always happy to come across cases that give a more balanced view of a remedy that are so totally negative that I could not see a relatively normal person taking the remedy. Does anyone know of a balanced write up on Platinum?
Blessings,

Ellen Madono

Soroush

They could not react in you suggested way because they are too busy in the land of denial.

They claim none of Trump's and the GOP's behavior, caught on tapes/videos, over and over again really happened.

They claim it is not real. And their believe system getting rattled brings forth the kind of vituperative rage
typical of those suffering Cognitive Dissonce. So nothing rational will come from them on this issue.

t

Just a quick comment.

How much is reality and how much is fake media.

Did he or did he not grope? Frankly who cares, we had Clinton, Kenney, Jefferson in the white house and their behavior was not perfect (and quite a few more presidents in this list)

Did he go bankrupt - sure but so did a lot of people. And, interestingly enough at least he recovered and learned a lot from that situation. I am sick of sending 'politicians' to Washington DC to feather their own nests = go in a pauper and come out a multi millionaire - something is not right there.

Can he be rude - YES! He is NOT a politician, the American People are SICK of politicians, saying one thing and doing another.

He supports the United States!, He supports our Military - if we are in a country to fight we should be fighting not using our young people as cannon fodder to act like we are doing something.

Does he take a dim view of vaccinations? Looks like it. And he did not take the pharmaceutical millions to run for president.. He OWES very few people, that is a big plus in my book.

Like homeopathy, he is being lied about, the truth is being buried whenever possible, when things are effective no one ever mentions it - sounds a lot like what they are doing to homeopathy.

Maria