Page 2 of 2

Re: Post 7

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2014 2:10 pm
by John Harvey
Irene, that's very, very interesting, what you've put here. Perhaps this kind of thing is potentially of great value to physicians of all stripes. Thank you for the details. I'll be interested, if he's willing to risk further bashing by you, in Ardavan's response to it.

My question about larger parasites (larger than microbes), by the way, was not intended to be hairsplitting, but to ask whether you were including the larger parasites amongst those that the organism deals with using the same branches of the immune system. I don't recall taking unfair advantage of any semantic mistakes on your part, but I must admit that if anybody tempted me to do so, you would. Anyway, if you'd care to follow your own protocol requirements and quote us on our unfair tricksiness toward you, perhaps we will be able to address it. :-)

Also, it might help Ardavan work out what on earth you're talking about in criticising his "lesson" if you were to follow your own protocol in doing so. You keep asking everybody else to quote you etc., but you seem to except yourself from that requirement fairly consistently even after it's pointed out to you that you're doing so. With your writing in particular, which tends to go round in circles a bit, being able to see in quotations the exact topic of each critique in a message would probably serve as a useful anchor for us mere mortals.

Cheers!

John

Re: Post 7

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2014 7:22 pm
by Ginny Wilken
I sincerely wish you gentlemen would just quit it with the ad hominem stuff and snide innuendos, and just discuss the SUBSTANCE of these posts. What Irene is laying out is extremely valuable and eye-opening, and exactly what one might hope for on a list of advanced, dedicated homeopaths. If you can't discuss the science of it without upsetting folks, you're just not doing it right. I, for one, am not amused. Let it go, please, and be scientists.

ginny
All stunts performed without a net!

Re: Post 7

Posted: Wed Apr 23, 2014 9:41 pm
by drnpickell
I agree with you but, unless I've missed something, it is only one "gentleman" stirring the pot.