Minutus

Irene, might I point out that, if indeed Joe is reacting to one of his remedies when he is acting out towards you (as you and perhaps several others see it) then, by extension, he would not be able to notice, acknowledge, nor assess this fact at all (assuming it is fact... I am not making judgments on this one way or the other. Merely sharing some neutral observations). Were he able to do so, he would no longer be reacting to the remedy. Do you see? In essence, you or anyone else can talk to or reason with him (or anyone else in a situation where he/she is experiencing such reactions to a remedy) all day long, and he will not be able to see your point, by virtue of the fact that the remedy is causing him to see things differently. In Joe's case, he thinks he sees "clearly" now. That may or may not be a delusion (I can't pretend to make that judgment), but the fact remains that he is seeing things differently than before and this is happening at such a deep level that he can't even begin to entertain the ideas that you or others may be presenting to the contrary, no matter how compelling your arguments may be to your own ears. Being seasoned homeopaths, we should all be able to recognize and understand this phenomenon, even when the fallout affects us directly and unpleasantly. This would then become a scenario of understanding, compassion, and forgiveness. It would also make room for healing a lot of deep wounds.

Agi

And I suppose you know that because of your wide clinical and practical experience with the method?

It is quite amazing to read that you criticize people the same way you claim in your newsletters and website that the enemies of homeopathy attack you...yes I do read your stuff whereas you do not read mine.
Dr. J. Rozencwajg, NMD "The greatest enemy of any science is a closed mind" www.naturamedica.webs.com

I am delighted to see how people are analysing me without a clue about what has happened, with the thinking, or should I write the delusion, they know what way anything has "changed" me, assuming indeed that if there was a change, it was of course for the worst.

"if indeed......acting out towards..." are assumptions, not facts but in any case, feel free to keep debating my mental and psychological status and believe whatever you want....any publicity is good publicity...have a nice week-end.
Dr. J. Rozencwajg, NMD "The greatest enemy of any science is a closed mind" www.naturamedica.webs.com

John,
You are nuts. I don't mean that as a compliment.
Ellen

Sorry John. Just stay out of the business of others when there is nothing of value to gain.

Great points! My "nosy" question was not which remedy but given the short time frame of noticeable change, is it possible a trazillionth billionth potency was taken way up the Fib scale?
As a seasoned homeopath, you may question the direction of cure, though we don't know if the remedy was taken to cure anything or just as a constitutional or experiment.
I was on a palliative remedy which at the time I thought was the simillimum, at least I was told.
Looking back I can see how wrong it was, but during it's action over a couple of years, I didn't and my thinking and behavior was not upto par and resulted in unpleasant consequences.
Proper homeopathic treatment should make one more compassionate, understanding, humble, not less so.
Though abandoning a long term friend and colleague during their most needy time can be a sign of one's true personality, something homeopathy doesn't easily change if ever. The term is fair weather friends and while it hurts, ultimately better to move on.
Susan

Once again you do not know what you are talking about, like the "short time frame of noticeable change".

Enough, as many members have asked.
Dr. J. Rozencwajg, NMD "The greatest enemy of any science is a closed mind" www.naturamedica.webs.com