Hi Ellen. Well.... in that case it should be KISSS :>)
-geo-
-----Mensagem Original-----
From: Ellen Madono
Sent: Monday, May 28, 2012 9:57 PM
To:
minutus@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Minutus] Re: combining homeopathy with other modalities
Hi Geo,
Yes, this is exactly the same problem as using multiple remedies. Dr. Roz
once told me KISS {Keep it simple, silly (stupid)}.
Best,
Ellen
I used to be a five element acupuncturist (stopped a few years ago)... and
also practice homeopathy.
Not a problem per-se. But the practitioner may get himself into
some difficulties with the follow through... Suddenly there is
some kind of change/movement/reaction and one just does not know
weather it is a result of the right similimum and not-so-correctly
chosen acu-points, or the other way around or both or none. It becomes very
difficult
in this sense... to the point where it becomes a guessing game.
Even if we are aware that Herings law of cure is valid in both therapeutic
systems,
it just does not eliminate the problem cited above.
-geo-
-----Mensagem Original-----
From: Dr. J. Rozencwajg, NMD.
Sent: Monday, May 28, 2012 8:10 PM
To: mailto:minutus%40yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [Minutus] Re: combining homeopathy with other modalities
It is chronic care in the sense that you use it repeatedly, but is not deep
care as it seems to address only the external expression of symptoms.
Let me clarify a bit, now that I am back at my computer and not fighting
with a phone to answer emails...
While using acupuncture or any other form of energy medicine like Medical
Qigong or Pranic Healing, what is regulated is the circulation of energy in
the body-mind and the removal of "blockages" that prevent the proper
circulation. At a deeper level of practice, the relationships between
elements, the "Mother-Child" issues, the Ko and Shen cycles are corrected,
which gives better, deeper and longer lasting results. But it need an
extreme level of expertise (IMO and as far as I am concerned, I am
definitely not one of those experts) to be able, through energetic
regulation, to remove origins, roots of pathologies.
For example, if everything started with intense fear, terror, like after an
assault or witnessing a murder, a lot of TCM practice will be aimed at the
Kidney and the effects its imbalance has on the other organs. Then you
bring everything back to equilibrium....cool....but the impact of the
assault that lead to terror has generally not been addressed, and for me,
only homeopathy can reach that deep and do it fast. TCM OTOH is, in my
hands, a lot more difficult to apply especially when considering
multifactorial origins of diseases....and there might also be a cultural and
educational bias as despite years of study, I still cannot think
"automatically" in terms of Chinese philosophy and even Taoist philosophy.
But imagine someone skilled gets there and manages to provide your
physiology with the proper energetic tools according to TCM.....and at the
same time you receive other tools, the homeopathic remedy. Which one will be
used? Will they be synergistic or antagonistic? Or will a bit of this and a
bit of that be used, with the final result being zilch? How are we to know?
That is why it is better not to go there, safer in fact.
But as you know, when it comes to using different tools for different jobs,
I have no problem with it at all, as long as you are able to evaluate the
action of each tool.....with some leeway for overlaps. So gemmotherapy with
homeopathy, I do that a lot, results are faster, and yes, at times I cannot
be 100% about the attribution of merits. Honestly, I do not care.
What do you mean by French style Aromatherapy? My "French" style
aromatherapy is oral ingestion of essential oils, something I do extremely
rarely as it is a very dangerous and toxic technique, albeit extremely
effective. In all my years of practice, I might have used it maybe half a
dozen times in life threatening situations......
Antidoting will happen, IMO, only if you open a homeopathic remedy when the
EO is floating around the room, then the structure of the "water memory"
(for lack of a better term for the time being) can be changed. But once the
remedy has been ingested, and the information delivered, if you witness
"antidoting", it means the remedy was not correct, or partial, or purely
symptomatic; what has happened is that the "antidote" has simply brought
back the pathology that was "silenced" to the foreground.
Makes sense??
Joe.
Dr. J. Rozencwajg, NMD.
"The greatest enemy of any science is a closed mind"
Visit my new website
www.naturamedica.webs.com