Minutus

Well thinking of Manchinella and fear of the devil - it appeared relevant
Rochelle
Registered Homeopath
EFT(Advanced) Practitioner
www.southporthomeopathy.co.uk

Dear Rochelle
As Carc has done well, I would stick with it and repeat the same potency or go up one step (ie if you gave 30 C go up to 200 C)
(Kent says NEVER desert a remedy that has done well until you are sure the picture has changed)
Regards

Soroush

She had Carc in May and then I gave 1M in August . I didn't think I wanted to repeat the potency too soon and I have very rarely given Carc 10M. This Sx have appeared since the Carc which is why I thought it could be connected. Ok , it could be toxins clearing but 3 weeks is a bit much for any woman to take.

These were the main Sx that were left and I really didn't think Mez suited the case re M and E's which was why I went for the Sepia and in a 30 not to disturb the Carc too much.
Rochelle
Registered Homeopath
EFT(Advanced) Practitioner
www.southporthomeopathy.co.uk

I ABSOLUTELY agree that 3 weeks is FAR too long.
Has she had a physical examination to ensure that her cervix and womb are OK?
If everything is OK, then I would repeat the remedy? However, you may wish to consider a lower potency.
What was the reason for starting with 1M?

Regards

Soroush

She hasn't had a physical exam as this sort of thing really isn't that unusual at menopause. However I did tell her to keep in touch and if she is still bleeding I will suggest this to her.
I didn't actually begin with a 1M as such but did my usual way of giving Carc when it is indicated for M and E's that is 30, 200, 1M, in 24hours. I do this because by clinical experience early in my practice I found it was the best way to give this Rx so patients don't have the bad aggs they were getting with just a 30 or 200. It is quite unusual for me to have to repeat this Rx but in this woman's case she had a flu virus in July which was sorted with Bryonia and her energy depleted again. That is why I repeated in August and I felt it was best to give the highest potency that I gave last time. It has brought back her energy and M and E wise she if a different woman so much better, self assured and everyone has noticed the difference.
I am not in the habit of giving a lower potency than I have given previously unless it is a long time since I gave the Rx . It is just something I was taught.
Rochelle
Registered Homeopath
EFT(Advanced) Practitioner
www.southporthomeopathy.co.uk

Hi Rochelle,
Re going down in potency, one caution I remember from my 1st homeopath
(not from class) is that if the "focus" of the imbalance has shifted
from M/E to "very physical", then you may need (or so he felt, and
did) to come down in potency to keep pace with the current state. E.g.
I had been up to 10M with "my constitutional", then got a rather bad
illness that he deemed to be within the scope of the same remedy, but
needing... he gave me either 30 or 200, can't remember. I was
surprised (and even skeptical ) at the time, but it did indeed
work...
Shannon

Dear Shannon,
My understanding of what you have written below is that we were taught to boost a Rx that has been given high to get more life out of it when it is waning with 1 dose of a low potency, but usually in a 6C.
Rochelle
Registered Homeopath
EFT(Advanced) Practitioner
www.southporthomeopathy.co.uk

Rochelle while reading about products, I've read about graphite, will his help your person with her issues.
The complaints of Graphites are worse morning, evening and during the NIGHT, especially before midnight. It is useful in people who are morbidly fat, or have been fat and are now emaciating; with constipation more commonly than diarrhoea; in women in these conditions whose menstrual habit is pale, late, short and scanty; catarrhal discharges that are albuminous and viscid represent to the mind some peculiar general states of the sick man not explainable and not common to diseased conditions nor to many remedies; hence, strange, rare and peculiar. Raw surfaces upon the skin are generally marked by such viscid glutinous discharges.

No information in this letter should be construed as medical advice.
This information is for educational purposes only.

Jeff Frankel
10360 Pine Lakes Blvd
North Fort Myers, Fl 33903
239-731-2655
http://www.msprotocols.com/
________________________________

See what's new at AOL.com and Make AOL Your Homepage .

Dear Rochelle
I am yet to find someone who can give me a logical reason for giving 30, 200, 1M in 24 hours - without evaluating what the first 30 has done.
(If your stalled engine starts, when you turn the key, what do you do? You let go of the key and observe. If you turn the key when the engine is turning, you damage the engine.)
If you are afraid of agg, why not start with LM and double dilute if necessary. You can give a dose and wait to see what happens.
[LMs are Hn's 'Perfected system']
Then you find it is gentle and curative.
You can switch this person to LMs too.

Regards

Soroush

Hi Rochelle,

Nope, that's definitely not what he was about; he did explain his
thinking to me very carefully! It's perhaps also relelvant, that at
that point my prior M/E symptoms of the remedy were not being
expressed; I was in a very sick, stuck, almost stuporous state, with
only a few symptoms showing, but those very physical and pretty severe
(in a "stuck" sort of way). Some people would have given low potency
for those reasons as well (tho others would not, I know)... And--I
will never know whether 10M wouldn't have worked fine also but
like I said, the lower potency did the job nicely!
Shannon