Ars for a warm blooded person?

[Jan Klüssendorf]

BTW - would anyone consider giving Arsenicum to a warm blooded person who is
untidy?
Regards
Rochelle

[Jan Klüssendorf] And what about giving Ars to a very tidy person (+ a lot
of others symptoms which fit) BUT *very* warm blooded?
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

[Peter Quenter]

>>>
blooded person who is
untidy?

for sure -
- if the person has burning pains all over and better from
warmth,
and Ars alb-kind of anxiety, and the mental restlessness,
and diarrhoea and vomiting and weakness from the same, etc
...
being warm and untidy may have little to do with the actual
disease going on

- if the person has always been chilly and tidy, but now
with the
burning pains all over better from warmth, and Ars-alb kind
of anxiety, and the mental restlessness, and diarrhoea and
vomiting and weakness from the same, has *also* now become
warm and untidy - then I *might* question the use of Ars
alb -
here the warm and untidy *may* be part of the
disease-expression, and a remedy that is similar as Ars alb,
but opposite in its temperature and tidiness may be more
appropriate -

Always depends on what is important in the given individual
case;
which are the actual disease-symptoms -
in one case being warm is not disease, in another it is -

best
peter quenter