Hello Samual, You're a real master in trying to change the subject ! First you criticized Scholten and Sankaran, because their remedy pictures and methods would be too speculative. After that you say you don't need their additional remedies anyway (so even if they had proven all their remedies, you ...

Samual wrote; More than our being glad, Sankaran and Scholten must be really glad and grateful ( as even I would be if I go laughing to the bank straight from my seminars) to have such faithful followers... You are a cynical person, maybe the real reason behind this is: ENVY, qualities of others? Yo...

Hi Rik, I agree these method should not replace the existing basics, but are meant to expand them. They are meant as a next step, in cases where the traditional approach/ knowlegde somehow fails. Student should not start with this advanced homeopathy, but learn the basics first. Having said this, we...

Rik, Even after a proving we can't take all the produced symptoms as belonging to the proven remedy. We have to confirm it in practice. Most valuable symptoms of our materia medica come from experience, and not from the provings. A proving is a good starting point, but not the end to come to a usefu...

Hello Rik, Scholten prescribes remedies from all kingdom, if and when indicated. He is also an expert on small remedies and plant remedies. Scholtens system regarding the periodic system is in use form more then 10 years by many homeopaths. So we can safely say that this contribution to Homeopathy w...

Hi Paul, all Thanks for the explanation, though I'm familiar with Sankarans teachings. Your explanation is from the view of Sankaran, so this way it sound logical. But the last years I tried to understand the nature of Sankaran level of prescription. Is this about the one never changing individual r...

Hi Paul, You wrote: for remedies from all 3 kingdoms. The remedy lies at the intersection of sensation and miasm. I read that book as well, but Sankaran did not change his approach. For example on page 199 he says: 'So we are talking about a sycotic animal. who has the theme of dependence and restri...

Hi Paul, I guess you a right that the primary action can be compared with the 'different song' by Sankaran. § 63 Every agent that acts upon the vitality, every medicine, deranges more or less the vital force, and causes a certain alteration in the health of the individual for a longer or a shorter p...

Hi Chris and Paul, There is no doubt that Hahnemann had this opinion, but this is highly debatable. Hahnemann found in Bry as a local keynote; "Constipation", but in provings by others "Diarrhoea" was the main observation. Same for Opium: Hahnemann: "Opium is almost the only...

Hi Paul, Isn't it a fact that our remedy pictures contain primary and secondary symptoms? It is a well-known fact that remedies show contrasting characteristic symptoms. Whether a certain symptom is primary or secondary is depending of the potency, or the prover/ patient. Primary and secondary repre...