Hi Joy, others, No, I am not going to read a hundred + pages starting at § 102, but I did read aphor 102 Here it is: *********** § 102 In the course of writing down the symptoms of several cases of this kind the sketch of the *disease picture* becomes ever more and more complete, not more spun out a...

Hi list, I have also learned some valuable things on this list. The trouble is that I keep getting involved in discussions like the ones that have been discussed. There is no rational reason why I should - I could just lurk and learn where there is something to learn. But it is one of my weaknesses ...

Hi Fran, I agree with what you said about Julian - and I had many controversial discussions with him. But he never resorted to personal insults. Not that I remember. That to me is the main point. Regards Luise -- One thought to all who, free of doubt, So definitely know what's true: 2 and 2 is 22 - ...

It is generally said that the concept of "the remedy must fit the patient not the disease" derives from Kent, not Hahnemann. On reading the Organon and the CD I did not come across anything that made me question this. But I did not look for it, specifically and I have myself done no specif...

On Sat, 11 Jul 2009, Richard Nash- Shannon wrote: As I said in my previous mails on this topic some months ago: I stayed on because I deliberately did not want the "purifiers" to succeed completely - so I "oiled my feathers against all this as a duck does against water", as I exp...

Hi Irene, This is a good thing! Some posters in the past have suggested to send the "rude" emails as pm's, in oder to keep them off the list. This I think is contra-productive. This is what happened on Lyght force. Jon was pretty strict about personal attacks on-list, but refused to act on...

Hi Paul and others, The argument that plants and animals (like apis, ternetula etc) are "one" in Hahnemann's view holds true only as long as they are alive. Look at aphor 10, footnote ************* §10 The material organism, considered without life force, is not capable of any sensation, a...

Hi Shannon, No idea. And I doubt that anyone knows. I do not know. Would (now) quite easy to find out. A couple of years ago a book was published listing (all??) the homeopathic MD's since Hahnemann's time up to ??, where they practiced etc. Some light research could find out whether there were more...

Hi Snannon,
Indeed! Thanks for catching it.

Regards

Luise
--
One thought to all who, free of doubt,
So definitely know what's true:
2 and 2 is 22 -
and 2 times 2 is 2:-)
==========> ICQ yinyang 96391801 <==========

Hi Shannon, This is just not true!!! At the time of Hahnemann (as before and as to-day) no doctor was allowed tho make his own remedies in the State of Saxony (neiter in other states, such as Prussia), it had then and has now to be done by a pharmacist. It was against the law! for H. to prepared the...